<instructions>Your goal is to analyze the following comment and estimate how highly it will be upvoted by the Hacker News community.</instructions><comment><author>shadowgovt</author><text>Not just a blackout---they were threatening to put legal pressure both on YouTube directly (to show it was violating the safe-harbor provisions of DMCA) and the tech sector in general (to modify safe harbor to give copyright owners more control via legal remedy).&lt;p&gt;YouTube capitulated to a technological solution in part to avoid a legal solution being forced upon them.</text><parent_chain><item><author>henryfjordan</author><text>Youtube has it&amp;#x27;s own system outside of the DMCA to handle copyright claims in which the claimant has all the power. If the poster of a video wants to appeal a copyright claim, they appeal directly to the claimant who gets to decide. You can then appeal to YT directly (good luck with that) but in the meantime the claimant can issue a &amp;quot;strike&amp;quot; on your account. 3 strikes and you are out. So instead of fighting claims, posters are encouraged to just roll with the punches and be glad they get any money. Youtubers at this point will openly say &amp;quot;I&amp;#x27;d show a clip but then I won&amp;#x27;t make money on this video&amp;quot; even when that clip would 100% be fair-use.&lt;p&gt;Youtube designed this system after pressure from the major Movie &amp;#x2F; Music publishers to either give them stronger tools than the DMCA provides or face a blackout from these major publishers. They wanted final control over their IP on Youtube and they got it, damn the law. If they had to file real DMCA claims, these claims on obviously fair-use materials would disappear.</text></item></parent_chain></comment><story><title>CBS gets YouTube review of &apos;Picard&apos; taken down for using 26 seconds</title><url>https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200128/10284943817/cbs-gets-angry-joes-youtube-review-picard-taken-down-using-26-seconds-shows-trailer.shtml</url></story>
<instructions>Your goal is to analyze the following comment and estimate how highly it will be upvoted by the Hacker News community.</instructions><comment><author>jbob2000</author><text>Some claimants are so hilariously (or nefariously?) wrong too. My partner uploaded a video of her playing Greensleeves on violin. Though it only has about 10 views, it received a claim from some random company in the states.&lt;p&gt;Greensleeves was written sometime in the 16th century. That a company set themselves up an automated tool to search for people playing this song tells me that they are either idiots, or greedily trying to steal revenue from YouTubers.</text><parent_chain><item><author>henryfjordan</author><text>Youtube has it&amp;#x27;s own system outside of the DMCA to handle copyright claims in which the claimant has all the power. If the poster of a video wants to appeal a copyright claim, they appeal directly to the claimant who gets to decide. You can then appeal to YT directly (good luck with that) but in the meantime the claimant can issue a &amp;quot;strike&amp;quot; on your account. 3 strikes and you are out. So instead of fighting claims, posters are encouraged to just roll with the punches and be glad they get any money. Youtubers at this point will openly say &amp;quot;I&amp;#x27;d show a clip but then I won&amp;#x27;t make money on this video&amp;quot; even when that clip would 100% be fair-use.&lt;p&gt;Youtube designed this system after pressure from the major Movie &amp;#x2F; Music publishers to either give them stronger tools than the DMCA provides or face a blackout from these major publishers. They wanted final control over their IP on Youtube and they got it, damn the law. If they had to file real DMCA claims, these claims on obviously fair-use materials would disappear.</text></item></parent_chain></comment><story><title>CBS gets YouTube review of &apos;Picard&apos; taken down for using 26 seconds</title><url>https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200128/10284943817/cbs-gets-angry-joes-youtube-review-picard-taken-down-using-26-seconds-shows-trailer.shtml</url></story>