<instructions>Your goal is to analyze the following comment and estimate how highly it will be upvoted by the Hacker News community.</instructions><comment><author>dalbasal</author><text>I&amp;#x27;m not American, so I guess it&amp;#x27;s a bit out of place for me to comment . That said, my reading of this incident is naked corporatism.&lt;p&gt;Laws, industry regulations, corporate policies and police enforcement are jumbled together, collaborating in a corporatist manner.&lt;p&gt;(A) The airline has policies and business practices such as overbooking &amp;amp; &amp;quot;must fly.&amp;quot; These save money, get staff to their required destinations, whatever.&lt;p&gt;(B) Police enforcement is a required for these business practices to actually be practiced.&lt;p&gt;The only reason they can practically have this &lt;i&gt;involuntary removal by lottery&lt;/i&gt; policy is police are willing to enforce it. If police of any city&amp;#x2F;airport refused to execute these corporate polices, the policies would have to change.&lt;p&gt;That&amp;#x27;s ultimately who outrage should be directed at, the police. Why did they come in the first place? Had a crime been committed? Passenger safety endangered? Police were summoned by a &amp;quot;private&amp;quot; company. They were informed that corporate policy required them to drag a passenger of the plane. They said OK, I guess that&amp;#x27;s our job.&lt;p&gt;I&amp;#x27;m not as concerned  about United or anyone else having nasty policies. Many companies do. I care more about police enforcing those policies. There is no consumer protection against police action.</text><parent_chain><item><author>tuna-piano</author><text>I see this whole event kind of like the Rosa Parks situation. I&amp;#x27;m not comparing the magnitude of injustice, just that (a)There was an unjust system and (b)It took an individual to stick up for the just result, even though it was breaking the rules.&lt;p&gt;Also, the author is wrong in this passage:&lt;p&gt;From the article: &amp;quot;The gate agents offered offered $800 in airline scrip to anyone willing to deplane, which from past observation I think is the maximum that was allowed by United policy. That&amp;#x27;s an illegal cheapskate policy for which United fully deserves the condemnation it has received, and the fines it should be assessed for violating Department of Transportation regulations on denied boarding compensation. Obviously, the gate agents should have been allowed to offer more, and in cash, as Federal law requires. &amp;quot;&lt;p&gt;The truth:&lt;p&gt;The airline can try and get people to voluntary give up their seats with whatever method they would like.  They can offer free kittens, cash, vouchers, etc.  If no one accepts the airlines arbitrary amount, THEN DoT rules take effect, mandating the cash compensation amounts.  So Dr Dao and the other 3 passengers that left the plane are entitled to a completely separate amount from what United offered.&lt;p&gt;From the DoT website[1]:&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot;DOT has not mandated the form or amount of compensation that airlines offer to volunteers. DOT does, however, require airlines to advise any volunteer whether he or she might be involuntarily bumped and, if that were to occur, the amount of compensation that would be due. Carriers can negotiate with their passengers for mutually acceptable compensation.&amp;quot;&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https:&amp;#x2F;&amp;#x2F;www.transportation.gov&amp;#x2F;airconsumer&amp;#x2F;fly-rights&quot; rel=&quot;nofollow&quot;&gt;https:&amp;#x2F;&amp;#x2F;www.transportation.gov&amp;#x2F;airconsumer&amp;#x2F;fly-rights&lt;/a&gt;</text></item></parent_chain></comment><story><title>Analysis of the United Airlines passenger removal incident</title><url>https://hasbrouck.org/blog/archives/002292.html</url></story>
<instructions>Your goal is to analyze the following comment and estimate how highly it will be upvoted by the Hacker News community.</instructions><comment><author>dba7dba</author><text>&amp;gt; Carriers can negotiate with their passengers for mutually acceptable compensation.&amp;quot;&lt;p&gt;How do you negotiate with an entity that has the ability to call in the goons on you but you cannot?</text><parent_chain><item><author>tuna-piano</author><text>I see this whole event kind of like the Rosa Parks situation. I&amp;#x27;m not comparing the magnitude of injustice, just that (a)There was an unjust system and (b)It took an individual to stick up for the just result, even though it was breaking the rules.&lt;p&gt;Also, the author is wrong in this passage:&lt;p&gt;From the article: &amp;quot;The gate agents offered offered $800 in airline scrip to anyone willing to deplane, which from past observation I think is the maximum that was allowed by United policy. That&amp;#x27;s an illegal cheapskate policy for which United fully deserves the condemnation it has received, and the fines it should be assessed for violating Department of Transportation regulations on denied boarding compensation. Obviously, the gate agents should have been allowed to offer more, and in cash, as Federal law requires. &amp;quot;&lt;p&gt;The truth:&lt;p&gt;The airline can try and get people to voluntary give up their seats with whatever method they would like.  They can offer free kittens, cash, vouchers, etc.  If no one accepts the airlines arbitrary amount, THEN DoT rules take effect, mandating the cash compensation amounts.  So Dr Dao and the other 3 passengers that left the plane are entitled to a completely separate amount from what United offered.&lt;p&gt;From the DoT website[1]:&lt;p&gt;&amp;quot;DOT has not mandated the form or amount of compensation that airlines offer to volunteers. DOT does, however, require airlines to advise any volunteer whether he or she might be involuntarily bumped and, if that were to occur, the amount of compensation that would be due. Carriers can negotiate with their passengers for mutually acceptable compensation.&amp;quot;&lt;p&gt;&lt;a href=&quot;https:&amp;#x2F;&amp;#x2F;www.transportation.gov&amp;#x2F;airconsumer&amp;#x2F;fly-rights&quot; rel=&quot;nofollow&quot;&gt;https:&amp;#x2F;&amp;#x2F;www.transportation.gov&amp;#x2F;airconsumer&amp;#x2F;fly-rights&lt;/a&gt;</text></item></parent_chain></comment><story><title>Analysis of the United Airlines passenger removal incident</title><url>https://hasbrouck.org/blog/archives/002292.html</url></story>