You are provided with the abstract of a scientific paper and the abstracts of the papers it references. Your task is to write a Related Work section for the main paper. This section should concisely summarize and integrate the key points from the cited abstracts, reflecting how they relate to the main paper's contributions and context. In your summary, use numerical citation markers like [1], [2], etc., to refer to the corresponding papers.

Main Abstract:
Exploiting the temporal dependency among video frames or subshots is very important for the task of video summarization. Practically, RNN is good at temporal dependency modeling, and has achieved overwhelming performance in many video-based tasks, such as video captioning and classification. However, RNN is not capable enough to handle the video summarization task, since traditional RNNs, including LSTM, can only deal with short videos, while the videos in the summarization task are usually in longer duration. To address this problem, we propose a hierarchical recurrent neural network for video summarization, called H-RNN in this paper. Specifically, it has two layers, where the first layer is utilized to encode short video subshots cut from the original video, and the final hidden state of each subshot is input to the second layer for calculating its confidence to be a key subshot. Compared to traditional RNNs, H-RNN is more suitable to video summarization, since it can exploit long temporal dependency among frames, meanwhile, the computation operations are significantly lessened. The results on two popular datasets, including the Combined dataset and VTW dataset, have demonstrated that the proposed H-RNN outperforms the state-of-the-arts.

Cited Abstract(s):
[1]: We present an approach for compact video summaries that allows fast and direct access to video data. The video is segmented into shots and, in appropriate video genres, into scenes, using previously proposed methods. A new concept that supports the hierarchical representation of video is presented, and is based on physical setting and camera locations. We use mosaics to represent and cluster shots, and detect appropriate mosaics to represent scenes. In contrast to approaches to video indexing which are based on key-frames, our efficient mosaic-based scene representation allows fast clustering of scenes into physical settings, as well as further comparison of physical settings across videos. This enables us to detect plots of different episodes in situation comedies and serves as a basis for indexing whole video sequences. In sports videos where settings are not as well defined, our approachallo ws classifying shots for characteristic event detection. We use a novel method for mosaic comparison and create a highly compact non-temporal representation of video. This representation allows accurate comparison of scenes across different videos and serves as a basis for indexing video libraries.

[2]: We present video co-summarization, a novel perspective to video summarization that exploits visual co-occurrence across multiple videos. Motivated by the observation that important visual concepts tend to appear repeatedly across videos of the same topic, we propose to summarize a video by finding shots that co-occur most frequently across videos collected using a topic keyword. The main technical challenge is dealing with the sparsity of co-occurring patterns, out of hundreds to possibly thousands of irrelevant shots in videos being considered. To deal with this challenge, we developed a Maximal Biclique Finding (MBF) algorithm that is optimized to find sparsely co-occurring patterns, discarding less co-occurring patterns even if they are dominant in one video. Our algorithm is parallelizable with closed-form updates, thus can easily scale up to handle a large number of videos simultaneously. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on motion capture and self-compiled YouTube datasets. Our results suggest that summaries generated by visual co-occurrence tend to match more closely with human generated summaries, when compared to several popular unsupervised techniques.

[3]: Key frame extraction has been recognized as one of the important research issues in video information retrieval. Although progress has been made in key frame extraction, the existing approaches are either computationally expensive or ineffective in capturing salient visual content. We first discuss the importance of key frame selection; and then review and evaluate the existing approaches. To overcome the shortcomings of the existing approaches, we introduce a new algorithm for key frame extraction based on unsupervised clustering. The proposed algorithm is both computationally simple and able to adapt to the visual content. The efficiency and effectiveness are validated by large amount of real-world videos.

[4]: We propose a unified approach for summarization based on the analysis of video structures and video highlights. Our approach emphasizes both the content balance and perceptual quality of a summary. Normalized cut algorithm is employed to globally and optimally partition a video into clusters. A motion attention model based on human perception is employed to compute the perceptual quality of shots and clusters. The clusters, together with the computed attention values, form a temporal graph similar to Markov chain that inherently describes the evolution and perceptual importance of video clusters. In our application, the flow of a temporal graph is utilized to group similar clusters into scenes, while the attention values are used as guidelines to select appropriate subshots in scenes for summarization.

[5]: Recent advances in technology have made tremendous amounts of multimedia information available to the general population. An efficient way of dealing with this new development is to develop browsing tools that distill multimedia data as information oriented summaries. Such an approach will not only suit resource poor environments such as wireless and mobile, but also enhance browsing on the wired side for applications like digital libraries and repositories. Automatic summarization and indexing techniques will give users an opportunity to browse and select multimedia document of their choice for complete viewing later. In this paper, we present a technique by which we can automatically gather the frames of interest in a video for purposes of summarization. Our proposed technique is based on using Delaunay Triangulation for clustering the frames in videos. We represent the frame contents as multi-dimensional point data and use Delaunay Triangulation for clustering them. We propose a novel video summarization technique by using Delaunay clusters that generates good quality summaries with fewer frames and less redundancy when compared to other schemes. In contrast to many of the other clustering techniques, the Delaunay clustering algorithm is fully automatic with no user specified parameters and is well suited for batch processing. We demonstrate these and other desirable properties of the proposed algorithm by testing it on a collection of videos from Open Video Project. We provide a meaningful comparison between results of the proposed summarization technique with Open Video storyboard and K-means clustering. We evaluate the results in terms of metrics that measure the content representational value of the proposed technique.

[6]: With the widespread availability of video cameras, we are facing an ever-growing enormous collection of unedited and unstructured video data. Due to lack of an automatic way to generate summaries from this large collection of consumer videos, they can be tedious and time consuming to index or search. In this work, we propose online video highlighting, a principled way of generating short video summarizing the most important and interesting contents of an unedited and unstructured video, costly both time-wise and financially for manual processing. Specifically, our method learns a dictionary from given video using group sparse coding, and updates atoms in the dictionary on-the-fly. A summary video is then generated by combining segments that cannot be sparsely reconstructed using the learned dictionary. The online fashion of our proposed method enables it to process arbitrarily long videos and start generating summaries before seeing the end of the video. Moreover, the processing time required by our proposed method is close to the original video length, achieving quasi real-time summarization speed. Theoretical analysis, together with experimental results on more than 12 hours of surveillance and YouTube videos are provided, demonstrating the effectiveness of online video highlighting.

[7]: The fast evolution of digital video has brought many new multimedia applications and, as a consequence, has increased the amount of research into new technologies that aim at improving the effectiveness and efficiency of video acquisition, archiving, cataloging and indexing, as well as increasing the usability of stored videos. Among possible research areas, video summarization is an important topic that potentially enables faster browsing of large video collections and also more efficient content indexing and access. Essentially, this research area consists of automatically generating a short summary of a video, which can either be a static summary or a dynamic summary. In this paper, we present VSUMM, a methodology for the production of static video summaries. The method is based on color feature extraction from video frames and k-means clustering algorithm. As an additional contribution, we also develop a novel approach for the evaluation of video static summaries. In this evaluation methodology, video summaries are manually created by users. Then, several user-created summaries are compared both to our approach and also to a number of different techniques in the literature. Experimental results show - with a confidence level of 98 - that the proposed solution provided static video summaries with superior quality relative to the approaches to which it was compared.

[8]: In this paper, we propose a video summarization algorithm by multiple extractions of key frames in each shot. This algorithm is based on the k-medoid clustering algorithms to find the best representative frame for each video shot. This algorithm, which is applicable to all types of descriptors, consists of extracting key frames by similarity clustering according to the given index. In our proposal, the distance between frames is calculated using a fast full search block matching algorithm based on the frequency domain. The proposed approach is computationally tractable and robust with respect to sudden changes in mean intensity within a shot. Additionally, this approach produces different key frames even in the presence of large motion. The experiments results show that our algorithm extracts multiple representatives frames in each video shot without visual redundancy, and thus it is an effective tool for video indexing and retrieval.

[9]: This paper presents a novel optimization-based approach for video key frame selection. We define key frames to be a temporally ordered subsequence of the original video sequence, and the optimal k key frames are the subsequence of length k that optimizes an energy function we define on all subsequences. These optimal key subsequences form a hierarchy, with one such subsequence for every k less than the length of the video n, and this hierarchy can be retrieved all at once using a dynamic programming process with polynomial (O(n3)) computation time. To further reduce computation, an approximate solution based on a greedy algorithm can compute the key frame hierarchy in O(n?log(n)). We also present a hybrid method, which flexibly captures the virtues of both approaches. Our empirical comparisons between the optimal and greedy solutions indicate their results are very close. We show that the greedy algorithm is more appropriate for video streaming and network applications where compression ratios may change dynamically, and provide a method to compute the appropriate times to advance through key frames during video playback of the compressed stream. Additionally, we exploit the results of the greedy algorithm to devise an interactive video content browser. To quantify our algorithms' effectiveness, we propose a new evaluation measure, called "well-distributed" key frames. Our experimental results on several videos show that both the optimal and the greedy algorithms outperform several popular existing algorithms in terms of summarization quality, computational time, and guaranteed convergence.
Unsupervised approaches select key subshots according to manually designed criteria [6] [4] [9] [5] , such as representative to the video content and diverse with each other, etc. Clustering is one of the most popular unsupervised summarization approaches [5] [1] [7] . Practically, with hand-crafted features, similar frames are grouped into the same cluster, and the cluster centers are taken as the most representative elements and selected into the summary. Earlier works apply clustering algorithms to video summarization directly [3] [8] . Later, more works integrate the domain knowledge of video data into clustering algorithms [7] [5] . As in [7] , the frames are initially clustered in sequential order, as consecutive frames are similar and more probably to be allocated to the same cluster. Other works construct more comprehensive models based on the idea of clustering [4] [2] . As in [4] , the video is transformed into an undirected graph, and the summary is generated by partitioning this graph into clusters. More recently, a co-clustering approach is proposed to simultaneously summarize several videos with the same topic by their co-occurrence, i.e., similar subshots shared by these videos are selected into the summary [2] .