You are presented with multiple paper abstracts, alongside the associated literature review and chapter titles. Given the provided information, you are going to do a literature review. Please generate a coherent literature review that synthesizes the content, draws connections between different works, highlights major findings, and identifies any gaps in the existing research.

Literature Review Title: Auto-Scaling Web Applications in Clouds: A Taxonomy and Survey 
Chapter Title:  Multitier 
1. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB001):  Dynamic capacity provisioning is a useful technique for handling the multi-time-scale variations seen in Internet workloads. In this article, we propose a novel dynamic provisioning technique for multi-tier Internet applications that employs (1) a flexible queuing model to determine how much of the resources to allocate to each tier of the application, and (2) a combination of predictive and reactive methods that determine when to provision these resources, both at large and small time scales. We propose a novel data center architecture based on virtual machine monitors to reduce provisioning overheads. Our experiments on a forty-machine Xen/Linux-based hosting platform demonstrate the responsiveness of our technique in handling dynamic workloads. In one scenario where a flash crowd caused the workload of a three-tier application to double, our technique was able to double the application capacity within five minutes, thus maintaining response-time targets. Our technique also reduced the overhead of switching servers across applications from several minutes to less than a second, while meeting the performance targets of residual sessions. 
2. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB002):  Creating good adaptation policies is critical to building complex autonomic systems since it is such policies that define the system configuration used in any given situation. While online approaches based on control theory and rule- based expert systems are possible solutions, each has its disadvantages. Here, a hybrid approach is described that uses modeling and optimization offline to generate suitable configurations, which are then encoded as policies that are used at runtime. The approach is demonstrated on the problem of providing dynamic management in virtualized consolidated server environments that host multiple multi-tier applications. Contributions include layered queuing models for Xen-based virtual machine environments, a novel optimization technique that uses a combination of bin packing and gradient search, and experimental results that show that automatic offline policy generation is viable and can be accurate even with modest computational effort. 
3. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB003):  Virtualized data centers enable sharing of resources among hosted applications. However, it is difficult to satisfy service-level objectives(SLOs) of applications on shared infrastructure, as application workloads and resource consumption patterns change over time. In this paper, we present AutoControl, a resource control system that automatically adapts to dynamic workload changes to achieve application SLOs. AutoControl is a combination of an online model estimator and a novel multi-input, multi-output (MIMO) resource controller. The model estimator captures the complex relationship between application performance and resource allocations, while the MIMO controller allocates the right amount of multiple virtualized resources to achieve application SLOs. Our experimental evaluation with RUBiS and TPC-W benchmarks along with production-trace-driven workloads indicates that AutoControl can detect and mitigate CPU and disk I/O bottlenecks that occur over time and across multiple nodes by allocating each resource accordingly. We also show that AutoControl can be used to provide service differentiation according to the application priorities during resource contention. 
4. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB004):  Dynamic server provisioning is critical to quality-of-service assurance for multi-tier Internet applications. In this paper, we address three important and challenging problems. First, we propose an efficient server provisioning approach on multi-tier clusters based on an end-to-end resource allocation optimization model. It is to minimize the number of servers allocated to the system while the average end-to-end delay guarantee is satisfied. Second, we design a model-independent fuzzy controller for bounding an important performance metric, the 90 th -percentile delay of requests flowing through the multi-tier architecture. Third, to compensate for the latency due to the dynamic addition of servers, we design a self-tuning component that adaptively adjusts the output scaling factor of the fuzzy controller according to the transient behavior of the end-to-end delay. Extensive simulation results, using one representative customer behavior model in a typical three-tier web cluster, demonstrate that the provisioning approach is able to significantly reduce the server utilization compared to an existing representative approach. The approach integrated with the model-independent self-tuning fuzzy controller can efficiently assure the average and the 90 th -percentile end-to-end delay guarantees on multi-tier server clusters. 
5. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB005):  Online Internet applications see dynamic workloads that fluctuate over multiple time scales. This paper argues that the non-stationarity in Internet application workloads, which causes the request mix to change over time, can have a significant impact on the overall processing demands imposed on data center servers. We propose a novel mix-aware dynamic provisioning technique that handles both the non-stationarity in the workload as well as changes in request volumes when allocating server capacity in Internet data centers. Our technique employs the k-means clustering algorithm to automatically determine the workload mix and a queuing model to predict the server capacity for a given workload mix. We implement a prototype provisioning system that incorporates our technique and experimentally evaluate its efficacy on a laboratory Linux data center running the TPC-W web benchmark. Our results show that our k-means clustering technique accurately captures workload mix changes in Internet applications. We also demonstrate that mix-aware dynamic provisioning eliminates SLA violations due to under-provisioning with non-stationary web workloads, and that it offers a better resource usage by reducing over-provisioning when compared to a baseline provisioning approach that only reacts to workload volume changes. We also present a case study of our provisioning approach on Amazon's EC2 cloud platform. 
6. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB006):  Autonomic server provisioning for performance assurance is a critical issue in data centers. It is important but challenging to guarantee an important performance metric, percentile-based end-to-end delay of requests flowing through a virtualized multi-tier server cluster. It is mainly due to dynamically varying workload and the lack of an accurate system performance model. In this paper, we propose a novel autonomic server allocation approach based on a model-independent and self-adaptive neural fuzzy control. There are model-independent fuzzy controllers that utilize heuristic knowledge in the form of rule base for performance assurance. Those controllers are designed manually on trial and error basis, often not effective in the face of highly dynamic workloads. We design the neural fuzzy controller as a hybrid of control theoretical and machine learning techniques. It is capable of self-constructing its structure and adapting its parameters through fast online learning. Unlike other supervised machine learning techniques, it does not require off-line training. We further enhance the neural fuzzy controller to compensate for the effect of server switching delays. Extensive simulations demonstrate the effectiveness of our new approach in achieving the percentile-based end-to-end delay guarantees. Compared to a rule-based fuzzy controller enabled server allocation approach, the new approach delivers superior performance in the face of highly dynamic workloads. It is robust to workload variation, change in delay target and server switching delays. 
7. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB007):  A Service-Level Agreement (SLA) provides surety for specific quality attributes to the consumers of services. However, current SLAs offered by cloud infrastructure providers do not address response time, which, from the user's point of view, is the most important quality attribute for Web applications. Satisfying a maximum average response time guarantee for Web applications is difficult for two main reasons: first, traffic patterns are highly dynamic and difficult to predict accurately; second, the complex nature of multi-tier Web applications increases the difficulty of identifying bottlenecks and resolving them automatically. This paper proposes a methodology and presents a working prototype system for automatic detection and resolution of bottlenecks in a multi-tier Web application hosted on a cloud in order to satisfy specific maximum response time requirements. It also proposes a method for identifying and retracting over-provisioned resources in multi-tier cloud-hosted Web applications. We demonstrate the feasibility of the approach in an experimental evaluation with a testbed EUCALYPTUS-based cloud and a synthetic workload. Automatic bottleneck detection and resolution under dynamic resource management has the potential to enable cloud infrastructure providers to provide SLAs for Web applications that guarantee specific response time requirements while minimizing resource utilization. 
8. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB008):  Elastic n-tier applications have non-stationary workloads that require adaptive control of resources allocated to them. This presents not only an opportunity in pay-as-you-use clouds, but also a challenge to dynamically allocate virtual machines appropriately. Previous approaches based on control theory, queuing networks, and machine learning work well for some situations, but each model has its own limitations due to inaccuracies in performance prediction. In this paper we propose a multi-model controller, which integrates adaptation decisions from several models, choosing the best. The focus of our work is an empirical model, based on detailed measurement data from previous application runs. The main advantage of the empirical model is that it returns high quality performance predictions based on measured data. For new application scenarios, we use other models or heuristics as a starting point, and all performance data are continuously incorporated into the empirical model's knowledge base. Using a prototype implementation of the multi-model controller, a cloud testbed, and an n-tier benchmark (RUBBoS), we evaluated and validated the advantages of the empirical model. For example, measured data show that it is more effective to add two nodes as a group, one for each tier, when two tiers approach saturation simultaneously. 
9. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB009):  In this paper we present Kingfisher, a {\em cost-aware} system that provides efficient support for elasticity in the cloud by (i) leveraging multiple mechanisms to reduce the time to transition to new configurations, and (ii) optimizing the selection of a virtual server configuration that minimizes the cost. We have implemented a prototype of Kingfisher and have evaluated its efficacy on a laboratory cloud platform. Our experiments with varying application workloads demonstrate that Kingfisher is able to (i) decrease the cost of virtual server resources by as much as $24\%$ compared to the current cost-unaware approach, (ii) reduce by an order of magnitude the time to transition to a new configuration through multiple elasticity mechanisms in the cloud, and (iii), illustrate the opportunity for design alternatives which trade-off the cost of server resources with the time required to scale the application. 
10. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB010):  In this paper we present a simple and effective approach for resource provisioning to achieve a percentile bound on the end to end response time of a multi-tier application. We, at first, model the multi-tier application as an open tandem network of M/G/1-PS queues and develop a method that produces a near optimal application configuration, i.e, number of servers at each tier, to meet the percentile bound in a homogeneous server environment -- using a single type of server. We then extend our solution to a K-server case and our technique demonstrates a good accuracy, independent of the variability of service-times. Our approach demonstrates a provisioning error of no more than 3% compared to a 140% worst case provisioning error obtained by techniques based on an M/M/1-FCFS queue model. In addition, we extend our approach to handle a heterogenous server environment, i.e., with multiple types of servers. We find that fewer high-capacity servers are preferable for high percentile provisioning. Finally, we extend our approach to account for the rental cost of each server-type and compute a cost efficient application configuration with savings of over 80%. We demonstrate the applicability of our approach in a real world system by employing it to provision the two tiers of the java implementation of TPC-W -- a multi-tier transactional web benchmark that represents an e-commerce web application, i.e. an online bookstore. 
11. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB011):  In this paper, we introduce a decentralized autonomic architecture for multi-tier applications deployed in cloud environments. The architecture maintains the application's service level objective at a predefined level and, implicitly, reduces the cost. The architecture uses a series of autonomic controllers, in which each controller independently regulates a tier of the application. The architecture utilizes feedback loops and implements Proportional, Integrative and Derivative control laws at each autonomic controller. A prototype is described and an initial set of experiments is conducted on a public commercial cloud. The experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach at maintaining a service level objective through the decomposition of an application's aggregate performance into its set of discretely managed component tiers. 
12. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB012):  Elasticity (on-demand scaling) of applications is one of the most important features of cloud computing. This elasticity is the ability to adaptively scale resources up and down in order to meet varying application demands. To date, most existing scaling techniques can maintain applications' Quality of Service (QoS) but do not adequately address issues relating to minimizing the costs of using the service. In this paper, we propose an elastic scaling approach that makes use of cost-aware criteria to detect and analyse the bottlenecks within multi-tier cloud-based applications. We present an adaptive scaling algorithm that reduces the costs incurred by users of cloud infrastructure services, allowing them to scale their applications only at bottleneck tiers, and present the design of an intelligent platform that automates the scaling process. Our approach is generic for a wide class of multi-tier applications, and we demonstrate its effectiveness against other approaches by studying the behaviour of an example e-commerce application using a standard workload benchmark. 
13. Abstract of Cited Paper (BIB013):  Abstract Cloud infrastructures consisting of heterogeneous resources are increasingly being utilized for hosting large-scale distributed applications from diverse users with discrete needs. The multifarious cloud applications impose varied demands for computational resources along with multitude of performance implications. Successful hosting of cloud applications necessitates service providers to take into account the heterogeneity existing in the behavior of users, applications and system resources while respecting the user’s agreed Quality of Service (QoS) criteria. In this work, we propose a QoS-Aware Resource Elasticity (QRE) framework that allows service providers to make an assessment of the application behavior and develop mechanisms that enable dynamic scalability of cloud resources hosting the application components. Experimental results conducted on the Amazon EC2 cloud clearly demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach while complying with the agreed QoS attributes of users.

Literature Review:
Multitier applications, as introduced, are composed of sequentially connected tiers. At each tier, the request either relies on the downstream tier to complete its processing or is returned to the upstream tier and finally to the user. A widely adopted architecture of this type usually consists of three tiers: one front-end, one application logic, and one database tier. The database tier is often considered dynamically unscalable and ignored by auto-scalers. Many works have targeted multitier applications. Some of them employ the divide-and-conquer approach that breaks overall SLA into SLA of each tier, such as the works conducted by Urgaonkar et al. BIB002 , Singh et al. BIB006 , Iqbal et al. BIB008 , Malkowski et al. BIB009 , Upendra et al. BIB010 , and Gergin et al. BIB012 . Others consider SLA of the whole application and provision resources to each tier holistically. This strategy requires more effort in modeling and estimating resource consumption using sophisticated queuing networks and machine-learning techniques as discussed in Section 8, and the resulting auto-scalers are only applicable to multitier applications. Important works of this category include approaches proposed by Zhang et al. BIB001 , Jung et al. BIB003 , Padala et al. BIB004 , Lama et al. BIB005 BIB007 , Sharma et al. BIB011 , Han et al. BIB013 , and Kaur et al. BIB014 .