Effect of Chronic Changes in Heart Rate on Congestive Heart Failure
Effect of Chronic Changes in Heart Rate on Congestive Heart Failure
This will be a double blind randomized crossover study of patients with congestive heart
 failure and a heart rate dependent upon a permanent pacemaker. Thus, at all times the heart
 rate can be maintained at a set rate by adjusting the settings of the pacemaker. Acute and
 chronic effects of heart rates of 60, 75, and 90 beats per minute will be evaluated. The
 effect of heart rate will be determined by measuring ejection fraction by nuclear
 ventriculography, six minute walk distance, and peak oxygen consumption on a maximal exercise
 test.
This study is a double-blind, randomized, cross-over study of patients with congestive heart
 failure and a heart rate dependent on a permanent pacemaker. Thus, at all times the heart
 rate can be maintained at a set rate by adjusting the settings of the pacemaker. Acute and
 chronic effects of heart rates of 60, 75, and 90 beats per minute will be evaluated by
 primarily comparing cardiopulmonary exercise tests and radionuclide ventriculography scans.

 Inclusion Criteria:

 Patients must have symptomatic congestive heart failure, NYHA Class II to IV symptoms and an
 ejection fraction < 40% by nuclear ventriculography within the previous 6 months. Patients
 must be stable with no change in dosage on conventional therapy (including digoxin,
 diuretics, ACE inhibitors, hydralazine, nitrates, angiotensin II receptor blockers and/or
 beta blocker) for at least 4 weeks. Because only heart rate is being evaluated, stable
 treatment with beta blockade should not prevent evaluation of the effects of changing heart
 rate.

 Patients must have an intrinsic cardiac rate < 60 beats per minute and a functioning
 permanent pacemaker.

 Exclusion Criteria:

 1. active alcohol or illicit drug use

 2. myocardial infarction or unstable angina within the previous 3 months

 3. obstructive valvular disease

 4. exercise induced sustained arrhythmias or symptomatic myocardial ischemia

 5. pregnancy

 6. psychiatric disorder

 7. non-compliance with medical regimen

 Assessment for eligibility:

 Patients who appear eligible based upon the prior inclusion and exclusion criteria will be
 further evaluated for eligibility as follows:

 After signing a consent form but prior to randomization and enrollment, the pacemaker rate
 will be set at 60 and then a 24 hour assessment by Holter monitor will be obtained. Patients
 will be eligible for the study if they are paced at least 75% of the time. For rate
 responsive pacemakers, the pacemaker will be set at a lower rate of 60 and an upper rate of
 80. Patients will need to be paced at a rate of 60 beats per minute at least 75% of the time
 for these patients as well.

 A symptom limited maximal exercise tolerance with measurement of peak oxygen consumption
 (VO2) will be performed to assess patient's maximal aerobic capacity. The Naughton protocol
 will be used. Exercise will continue until limiting symptoms are present, but will be stopped
 if patient develops sustained arrhythmia, cyanosis, dizziness, decrease in blood pressure or
 an ataxic gait. Patients who develop angina or claudication limiting exercise capacity will
 be excluded from further evaluation or participation. Peak oxygen consumption on this test
 must be < 20 ml/kg/min for a patient to be eligible for this study.

 Chronic Study

 Randomization:

 This study will be a three period crossover study. Patients initially will be randomly
 assigned to be paced at a rate of 60, 75, or 90 BPM for 2 consecutive months. Patients with
 rate responsive pacemakers will be set at an upper limit of 20 beats above their assigned
 rate. At the end of this period, patients will have end point measurements obtained and then
 will be randomized to one of the other heart rates for another 2 consecutive months.
 Following repeat end point measurements at the end of this period, patients will then be
 randomized to the final heart rate for 2 consecutive months with repeat measurements at the
 end.

 End Point Measurements:

 The following tests will be done at the end of each of the three two month periods to assess
 the effect of heart rate on ventricular function, functional status and exercise capacity.

 1. Nuclear ventriculography (MUGA): Equilibrium gated blood pool will be completed
 according to standard protocol, under the supervision of Dr. Eliot Siegel. Ejection
 fraction will be calculated.

 2. Six minute walk: All patients will have their submaximal exercise capacity evaluated by
 a 6 minute walk. This test is performed on a 100 foot hallway. Patients are instructed
 to walk from end to end repeatedly at a comfortable pace while attempting to cover as
 much ground as possible. After 6 minutes the distance covered is measured to the nearest
 foot.

 3. Maximal exercise tolerance and peak oxygen consumption: This will be assessed in all
 patients at baseline and at the end of each 2 month period. Patients will be exercised
 to exhaustion on a motorized treadmill using a Naughton Protocol. Heart rate and rhythm
 will be monitored continuously while blood pressure will be measured every 2 minutes.
 Oxygen consumption, C02 production and respiratory quotient will be calculated every 20
 seconds using breath by breath analysis.

 Acute Studies Effect of Heart Rate on Ejection Fraction Acute studies will be performed to
 help differentiate the effect of changes in heart rate on left ventricular ejection fraction
 from changes in cardiac performance and contractility. Acutely, ejection fraction might
 change because of alterations in preload and afterload, which might not reflect the long term
 effects on contractility.

 At the end of the first 2 month period, the patient will have nuclear ventriculography (as
 detailed above) to evaluate ejection fraction. At that time the pacemaker rate will be
 changed in a random manner to the two other heart rates. Ten minutes after each adjustment,
 an ejection fraction will be calculated.

 Effect of Heart Rate on Exercise Performance:

 The purpose of this study is to look at the acute effect of changes in heart rate on exercise
 performance. This will differentiate exercise effects induced by the change in heart rate on
 contractility from the acute effects of changing heart rate. Twenty four hours following
 randomization of patients to the first heart rate, they will have an exercise tolerance test.
 As previously indicated, the effect of a chronic change in heart rate ill be evaluated
 following each 2 month period. Subsequently, when patients are crossed over to another heart
 rate, they will have an exercise tolerance test 24 hours later. This will follow the chronic
 exercise test of the previous period by at least 24 hours.
Inclusion Criteria:

 -  Patients must have symptomatic congestive heart failure, NYHA Class II to IV symptoms
 and an ejection fraction < 40% by nuclear ventriculography within the previous 6
 months. Patients must be stable with no change in dosage on conventional therapy
 (including digoxin, diuretics, ACE inhibitors, hydralazine, nitrates, angiotensin II
 receptor blockers and/or beta blocker) for at least 4 weeks

 Exclusion Criteria:

 -  active alcohol or illicit drug use

 -  myocardial infarction or unstable angina within the previous 3 months

 -  obstructive valvular disease

 -  exercise induced sustained arrhythmias or symptomatic myocardial ischemia

 -  pregnancy

 -  psychiatric disorder

 -  non-compliance with medical regimen