text:
humanities and social sciences communications
Counterfactual analysis of the impact of the first two waves of the COVID-19 pandemic on the reporting and registration of missing people in India
Kandaswamy Paramasivan1,
Brinda Subramani2 &
Nandan Sudarsanam3,4
Humanities and Social Sciences Communications volume 9, Article number: 408 (2022) Cite this article
The primary duty of law enforcement agencies is to ensure that a victim has the necessary information and access to the relevant tools required to seek justice. In India, complex cases such as bodily offences and property crimes capture the work and efforts of many agencies involved; however, cases related to missing persons are not often accorded similar priority or seriousness. The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent lockdowns have added further challenges to this scenario. The government-mandated lockdowns in Tamil Nadu generally exacerbated difficult socio-economic and living conditions, thereby directly or indirectly contributing to an increased load of missing person cases. This study aims to assess and identify the impact of mobility on reporting and registration of missing persons. By adopting an auto-regressive neural networks method, this study uses a counterfactual analysis of registered missing person cases during the government-mandated lockdowns in response to the global pandemic in 2020 and 2021. The registered cases are calculated based on the daily count of cases for eleven years in Tamil Nadu, India. The lockdowns identify eight different time windows to determine the impact of mobility on the registration of cases. While there has been no significant or drastic change over the pre-pandemic period, during the pandemic, especially during the restrictive phases of the pandemic, there was a sharp fall in cases compared to the counterfactual predicted (effect sizes: −0.981 and −0.74 in 2020 and 2021), signalling towards a choked mechanism of reporting. In contrast, when most mobility restrictions were removed, an increase in cases (effect sizes of +0.931 and 0.834 in 2020 and 2021) pointed to restored and enabled reporting channels. The research findings emphasise the significance of mobility as a factor in influencing the reporting and registration of missing persons and the need to ensure this continues to help families find redress.
Understanding the problem of missing persons during the pre-pandemic period
Crime is ubiquitous across most societies and nation-states. The plight of victims, for whose remedy the criminal justice system has been institutionalised, is sometimes overlooked in the system. However, police act as the first responders in most instances to work towards restoring normalcy. This is nevertheless determined by situational factors such as the victims' ability, accessibility, and earnestness to reach out to the agencies for relief and redressal.
While cases related to missing persons are not considered crimes by law, the causes leading to missing persons and the consequences thereafter could potentially be criminal. Moreover, the agony that the kith and kin of missing persons undergo demands that justice be served. Missing persons cases are often a protracted battle, unlike violent cases of crime such as murder and other heinous crimes such as rape and dacoity, that are solved reasonably promptly. The missing person's family and friends live in hope of the return of their loved ones, their grief and vulnerability intensifying with each passing day as they continue to remain unfound. Moreover, several law enforcement agencies suggest that the longer it takes to find the person, the lower the chances are of finding him or her. The impact on the family and the psychological distress that they experience present a challenge to the police system.
The cases of missing persons are unique in several ways when compared to other criminal cases, not only in incidence but also in reporting such instances for tracing and locating the missing person. These cases are a bigger problem and challenge to law enforcement, and they deserve greater attention and a more effective response from organisations and governments. There is emotional grief for the kith and kin of the missing person, particularly if the missing person happens to be the breadwinner of the family (Testoni et al., 2020). It is widely acknowledged that the police have adopted many innovative methods worldwide to locate missing persons (Ferguson and Soave, 2020; Pier et al., 2021). For example, UK police have begun assessing risk factors for missing persons, assisting in the implementation of appropriate operational activities. Additionally, they have been using publicity methods to invoke community participation in finding the missing person. (Greene, 2020). One may think that, with the advancement of technology, the penetration of social media, and greater awareness among individuals, the number of missing persons reported would dwindle, and the number of missing persons traced by law enforcement or others would increase. However, data from 2017, 2018, and 2019 points to the contrary, indicating an increase in reported cases of missing persons in India. (See Fig. 1).
Fig. 1: Plot of the number of missing person cases in India during the years 2016–2020.
x-axis: year. y-axis: number of cases of missing persons. Source: National Crime Records Bureau, New Delhi.
Additionally, research points out that "there is an exceedingly complex web of behaviours and responses surrounding the phenomenon of missing persons." (Nicholas et al., 2015). Locating a missing person is one of the most challenging tasks for the police force due to the number of resources required, the psychological distress of the family, and the often limited information available. The search process for a missing person, whether alive or dead, is an overarching concept with an integrated, multidisciplinary, and multi-agency approach seeking committed cooperation by all the stakeholders involved (Salado Puerto et al., 2021). Further, tracing and locating missing persons is more difficult for police in terms of effort, resources, time, and strain involved as compared to investigating property crimes or violent crimes (Shalev and Pakes, 2014).
The aforementioned discussion is a post-mortem analysis of what was done in the aftermath of an individual found missing. The present paper is primarily concerned with the factors that prevent complainants from reporting cases of missing persons to the police. In order to understand the challenges related to the reporting of missing persons, there needs to be an understanding of the conditions under which individuals go missing in the first place. The following section provides details of the causes behind missing persons, both in India and in other countries, during regular situations or pre-pandemic times as well as pandemic times, to help appreciate the results of this study.
Major reasons for missing persons in India during the pre-pandemic period
A deeper look at cases related to missing persons provides a broad categorisation of reasons for individuals to go missing. Analysis of the data consisting of the First Information Report (basic crime record for investigation) and other information available with the district crime records bureau in Tamil Nadu suggests that individuals go missing for various reasons that are often related to socio-economic factors as well as cultural factors. The cases can be broadly categorised as follows: (a) unintentional absence: the missing people who had become disoriented or drifted; as well as those who have been forced to be absent, such as children or the elderly who were separated from their guardians in fairs or large gatherings such as festivals or religious conferences, and were unable to communicate with them; or those who have been kidnapped; (b) intentional absence: those who have voluntarily left for a variety of reasons, such as elopement or academic failure in order to escape. Those who voluntarily go missing do not wish to be found, thus making these cases much more difficult to resolve. The number of missing cases due to elopement is rampant given the continued practice of forced arranged marriages, where factors beyond the mutual liking of the partners play a role. Elopement, at times, is the only way to save the lives of individuals who otherwise stand a very high chance of being killed on account of the inter-caste or inter-religion nuptial knot they get involved in. Also in recent times, academic failure as a reason behind missing cases is fast rising in India as peer pressure and societal expectations are paramount over an individuals' calibre, likes, and dislikes.
When discussing intentional absence, examples such as individuals escaping abuse from a care home or an assisted living facility, come to mind. These individuals want to disappear from their places of residence on their own volition. This is a common category of missing persons in India; a significant chunk are those who willingly leave their regular place of residence. Bankruptcy and suicide are other examples and forms of intentional absence. (Laura van, 2013). These individuals have control and clarity over their actions, they choose and plan the design that suits their needs. Disorientation caused by substance abuse also falls under this category.
Certain scenarios of missing persons are also considered an involuntary phenomenon. These include missing persons cases influenced by of a third person or party; immoral trafficking, possible abduction or kidnapping. This category primarily includes those who are missing against their will; such as the cases of women missing, which suggests yet another dimension—that of continuing gender-based violence in society. (Ambler, 2014). Amartya Sen, for instance, in one of his works, mentioned that the skewed sex ratio in the country can be attributed to gender discrimination and disadvantage. (Sen, 1990). This category is often absent from society's sociological imaginations, let alone law enforcement agencies. The last scenario includes individuals lost due to injury or mental illness such as Parkinson's or unfortunate accidents (Greene, 2020). Whatever the reason might be, in the pre-pandemic times, law enforcement agencies were intimated, and a suitable response was taken in the form of registration of the case at the least.
Missing persons in other parts of the world during the pre-pandemic period
Many individuals go missing in the war-torn areas of Western Asian countries such as Syria, Iran, and Iraq; the civil strife areas of Africa, the border areas of Mexico-US or North and South Korea mainly because of the illegal migrants' issues. In a similar situation, the Uighur Muslims and Tibetan Buddhists in China and the political dissidents in Russia are prone to criminal detentions and exterminations. However, the cases in India are relatively crime-free. That does not mean that there is no crime associated with the missing people. Nevertheless, before delving into the Indian scenario, a brief mention of the circumstances in each of the aforementioned instances is made in the following section.
Countries facing constant turmoil like Syria, Afghanistan, Iran, and Iraq witness multiple situations of missing persons. For instance, the U.N. estimates that over 100,000 individuals are missing from Syria, primarily due to "summary executions, arbitrary and incommunicado detention, kidnapping and abduction, as well as combatants and civilians missing as a direct result of fighting and the day-to-day ravages of war and war crimes." (ICMP Syria, 2021). These apply to other war-torn and civil war-affected areas as well. It is important to note that the missing person phenomenon is also rampant in developed countries like the USA (FBI, 2019) and Europe (AMBER Alert Europe, 2022).
These reports suggest that around 600,000 individuals go missing in each region. Moreover, in autocratic countries like China, there are unique cases of disappearances related to political dissidents and/or the extermination of individuals and cultures that are not seen as being oriented towards the existing government. A case in point is Uighur Muslims (APNews, 2020).
Cases of missing persons during the pandemic period
Numerous studies have been conducted to understand the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on various aspects of our lives. However, there seems to be a lack of data regarding the impact of the pandemic on the reporting and tracking of missing persons (Calderon-Anyosa et al., 2021). Another aspect that has been understudied relates to the challenges faced by law enforcement agencies in dealing with cases related to missing persons. The absence of witnesses and public transport are reasons individuals are restrained from asking for help, which is a significant factor in such instances (Marks, 2021). The United Kingdom's National Crime Agency's Missing Persons Unit report suggests relationship issues and mental worries as primary reasons for individuals missing during the pandemic. The report also suggested increasing domestic violence against women and children, which led to them going missing (Krubiner et al., 2021). The various lockdowns in Tamil Nadu might have resulted in safer conditions for children in general as the chances of being exposed to potential harm such as abduction and human trafficking were very low. On the other hand, adults continued to be at high risk given the COVID-induced forced migrations and loss of livelihoods and depressing economic affairs, thereby making them more vulnerable (Freya O'Brien et al., 2021). The reasons for missing individuals are plenty. However, the present study aims to study how an unprecedented pandemic as well as factors independent of a pandemic situation can affect the reporting of a case.
The role of situational factors in the reporting and registration of missing persons cases during the pandemic period
The lockdowns, which resulted in restricted mobility, mass exodus of migrants, and a general maintenance of curfew measures, increased demands on law enforcement agencies. Law enforcement authorities remained overstretched and therefore unable to effectively support victims of crime, which made the reporting of crime more challenging overall. The severe restrictions on vehicles, both public and private, comprised a vital hurdle for complainants wanting to file complaints at the police station. In addition, the general fear of contracting COVID-19 also posed a challenge. Such exceptional circumstances during the pandemic brought considerable challenges to the complainants' ability to reach relief centres. This was also a time which critically affected the overstretched first responders, whose resources were largely redeployed to address the pandemic. Adjusting for mobility during the pandemic-induced lockdowns illustrates mixed results of increasing and decreasing cases related to missing persons when compared with the counterfactuals—primarily due to the operational efficiency and effectiveness of the reporting mechanism during normal periods. The escalation of registered cases could be attributed to the improved channels of reporting missing persons cases during the relevant period. In contrast, a decline in recorded case levels indicates a clogged reporting medium, including the shared commitment of police, non-profit organisations, and other agencies involved in work relating to exceptional circumstances. The empirical study setup, which is made up of eight time windows with different levels of pandemic severity and restrictions, gives us a chance to look at the recorded levels in the context of enabling and impeding crime reporting mechanisms after mobility has been taken into account.
Motivation for the research
Descriptive statistical tools and conventional forecasting methods such as auto-regressive integrated moving average (ARIMA), Holt-winters, and exponential smoothing have been very popular with practitioners and researchers in criminal justice administration, police science, criminology, and related fields. Though these methods have been in vogue for a few decades, there are certain shortcomings, such as the models' instability when the data is volatile and has rapid fluctuations. Further, there is a need for manual intervention by the modeller to specify the functional form. With the advent of massive advancements in computing power, besides easy accessibility and availability, the landscape of time-series forecasting has changed to newer arenas of deep learning, such as the usage of recurrent neural networks from the early domain of conventional statistical forecasting techniques.
The most important advantages of an auto-regressive neural network (ARNN) are its accuracy in prediction, its capability to work with sparse data with missing values, and its ability to predict even with little past data as it learns from other similar time series.
Furthermore, very few studies cover the longer span of two pandemic waves, giving it a longitudinal approach. Notably, there are no research articles based on field-level actual primary data in peer-reviewed journals studying the effect of the pandemic waves on the reporting of crimes in general and missing persons in particular in the Indian context. Research findings borne out of studies on other high-income countries may not necessarily apply to India's social-political-economic and cultural milieu. Hence, an investigation of data specific to India would be relevant to addressing current challenges and informing future policies.
The pandemic and lockdown greatly impacted the cases of missing persons in India. Given the extent of circular migration and migrant labour as well as the geographical vastness of the land, the pandemic aggravated the case for this group of individuals.(Khanna, 2020) Many guest workers (migrant labourers) in India who tried to return to their domicile state were found missing but were not reported (Jesline et al., 2021; Irudaya Rajan et al., 2020). Interestingly, a discussion of missing persons case shapes up as a case of double jeopardy. Unlike other criminal cases, the victim is unheard of and underrepresented in this case. This becomes a more complex issue when those trying to file a complaint are further restricted by an external restriction to report, resulting in primary and secondary instances of victimisation of the missing individual during the pandemic-induced lockdowns. It is imperative to acknowledge the pivotal role of the police in India in this context, more so because police are the first responders to missing individuals. Unlike in other nations, where Interpol databases or non-state organisations aid in such cases, the police in India assumes a singularly vital role.
In supposedly normal circumstances, one cannot study the factors that would have otherwise determined crime reporting and FIR registration, thereby setting the law into motion. The pandemic and the lockdowns provide a natural experiment setting to understand the latent factors that enable crime registration, which are not easily decipherable in normal times. However, the unprecedented pandemic-induced changes in mobility and a host of other exceptional conditions provided an opportunity for a natural experiment in the registration of missing persons' cases, particularly in the context of the inhibiting mechanism of reporting such cases, in varying mobility trends over eight time windows covering both waves of the pandemic.
Material—natural experiment
The lockdowns brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic significantly impacted mobility. In this context, this paper explores the "registration of crime" and analyses the influence of various mobility trends on the agents that facilitate and obstruct the reporting of crime. The study focused on the state of Tamil Nadu, which is the sixth most populous state in India with an estimated 80 million residents and a land area of about 130,000 square kilometres. The police station is the central point of contact for crime victims, who can come in and file complaints and grievances, primarily using the First Information Report (FIR). Section 154 of the Indian Criminal Procedure Code gives FIRs legal standing, and it is the station house officer's duty to document any information the complainant provides to the police in writing in order to register all cognisable offences. Although Section 154 claims that it is only for cognizable offences and, as previously stated, missing persons cases are not crimes by themselves, a FIR is still filed in cases involving missing persons in the same way as in other crimes. In 2019, 1356 police stations across 200 police subdivisions, 38 police districts, and 9 commissionerates handled a total of 168116 FIRs related to all IPC-related offences. 16238 cases of missing persons were reported, representing 9.65 percent of all crimes, making it a significant category (NCRB 2020).
The growing number of missing persons (traced and untraced) during the last decade is perhaps attributed to improved channels of reporting missing persons. A very similar trend to the registered cases of unidentified dead bodies is also seen (see Figs. 2 and 3). The crucial initiatives that paved the way for such a substantial upward climb in the decade ending in 2015 include the opening of the option of online filing of complaints related to missing persons and the sharing of information in the public domain.
Fig. 2: Number of missing person cases (traced and not traced) in Tamil Nadu during the decade 2010–2021.
x-axis: year. y-axis: number of missing person cases in Tamil Nadu.
Fig. 3: Number of unidentified dead body (UIDB) cases (traced and not traced) in Tamil Nadu during the decade 2010–2021.
x-axis: year. y-axis: number of UIDB cases in Tamil Nadu.
The Crime and Criminal Tracking Network and Systems (CCTNS), a police website that stores all crime data, was adopted nationwide. In Tamil Nadu, a host of services were made available to the public, and one of the most important ones that were launched in 2015 pertains to direct access to databases for the public. The complainant could directly use the search option with some features of the person, such as gender, age, height range, complexion, other visible identification marks, and colour of the dress of the person when last seen, to look for the missing person.
The present study focuses on the pandemic times to understand how the number of FIRs, in the cases of missing persons, is affected during the different phases of lockdown and the preceding and subsequent periods, given the constraints on mobility. In this context, the periods are divided into the following categories: Complete Lockdown (CL) and Partial Lockdown (PL), based on the movement restrictions imposed by the government. These restrictive orders were in place during both the pandemic waves in 2020 and 2021 but differed in length. While the partial lockdown witnessed partial and periodic relaxations in mobility and allowed specific services, goods, individuals, and business establishments to operate, complete lockdowns were severe in the restrictions imposed (see Fig. 4). Figure 4 clearly illustrates the phases of CLs and PLs. It is essential to note this categorisation as it plays a crucial role in this study, through ARNN, of how the mobility restrictions and relaxations impacted the registration of cases.
Fig. 4: Timeline of the first two waves of COVID-19 lockdowns in Tamil Nadu, India.
Horizontal axis: discrete intervals—various lockdown phases in both waves in Tamil Nadu. Vertical axis: time period of various lockdown.
Wave one
The Government of India, and thereby the Government of Tamil Nadu, imposed Complete Lockdowns for a total of 38 days between March 23, 2020 and April 30, 2020. During partial lockdown in the period between May 1, 2020 and June 8, 2020, for 38 days, which equals the same number of days as CL, certain restrictions were lifted on the movement of people and vehicles. The post-lockdown phase can be considered September 1, 2020 onwards, when most of the mobility curbs were lifted.
Wave two
As the COVID-19 cases saw an upsurge, so did the return of the lockdown phase. During the second wave, with knowledge of hindsight, the government initially launched a mildly restrictive order with Partial Lockdown (one) between April 10, 2021 and May 5, 2021. However, with a massive increase in caseload and the ensuing need to curtail the spread of the virus, a complete lockdown with strict stay-at-home orders was enforced between May 6, 2021 and June 7, 2021, which was followed by a period of relaxation in mobility, in the form of Partial Lockdown (two), which was implemented between June 8, 2021 and July 6, 2021. Hence, the complete lockdown was sandwiched between the two partial lockdowns on either side of the timeline. Finally, between September 1, 2021 and September 30, 2021, there was a post-lockdown phase when almost all the curbs were lifted off.
Method for time-series forecast
This study employs the DeepAR forecasting algorithm, a recurrent neural network (RNN) based model, to forecast the daily count of missing persons and unidentified dead bodies. It consists of an RNN architecture that is ideal for modelling sequential data and a likelihood function that is used to generate a probabilistic forecast (Salinas et al., 2020). This model presents four main advantages over the other models used to forecast crime. First, ARNN makes it possible to model complex time-series processes with no assumptions about the data or any assistance from the modeller in choosing the parameters for the model. This is unlike conventional models, such as the ARIMA, which need the order of the process to be specified. Second, the probabilistic forecast provided by the likelihood function improves the reliability and confidence in its predictions. Third, deepAR models can employ likelihood functions specific to positive count data (crime data falls under this category), like negative binomial distribution, which augments accuracy. Fourth, conventional time-series forecasting techniques like auto-regressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) and exponential smoothing have been used consistently to get stable forecasts for different time-series data. However, these methods are unsuitable when rapid changes, moving holidays, and seasonality factors are in the data. Finally, the model can identify the significant trend and seasonal components and create new features, making it superior in forecasting to conventional statistical models. This model is implemented in Python using the gluonTS package (Alexandrov et al., 2019).
In model building in machine learning and deep learning, three data sets are involved: training, validation, and actual forecast (test). Usually, the training data is large, where the model's parameters are estimated. The estimation of the appropriate parameters is done in such a manner that the difference between the actual and predicted is the least. These parameters are used in the validation phase, where unseen data is shown to the model for prediction. The error is calculated to check prediction accuracy using an appropriate error metric. Some modellers do the tuning of the parameters to enhance the accuracy and avoid overfitting the model with the data. Finally, the model developed after validation is used for the prediction data.
Training phase
Consider a time series i with a total of t0 time steps, where t0 represents the last observation for the time series i or the training range, and T represents the last time step till which forecasting is done, or the prediction range. The input to the RNN at time step t is the value of the time series and the output from the RNN in the previous time step t – 1, are represented by zi, t − 1 and hi, t − 1, respectively. These inputs, along with the parameters of the RNN, can be used to produce the output of the RNN at the current time step t. Subsequently, this output from the RNN and its parameters are used to parametrise the negative binomial likelihood function (see Fig. 5).
Schematic diagram of DeepAR architecture.
Validation phase
During the validation phase, the model is used to forecast from the time step next to the end of training data. The quality of these forecasts is evaluated using an appropriate error metric. This validation of the models' forecast is possible as the observed values of the time series during the validation phase are known. The forecasts from Auto-regressive Recurrent Neural Network are compared with the predictions from different state-of-the-art forecasting models, such as Auto-regressive Integrated Moving Average (ARIMA), Generalised Additive Model (GAM), Bayesian Structural Time Series (BSTS), and Holt-Winters, and were found to be the most accurate, recording the least error. Weighted Mean Absolute Percentage Error (WMAPE) is used as the performance metric as it is unit-free and can be interpreted easily. Furthermore, WMAPE is more appropriate than the commonly used measure MAPE because the number of missing person cases on certain days may be zero, resulting in an infinite value for MAPE, whereas WMAPE remains finite.
Prediction phase
Once the model parameters are estimated, a sample is drawn from the likelihood function for time steps t > to. This represents the prediction at that time step, which is in turn used to calculate the prediction of the neural network at the next time step. This process is repeated for n times (specified by the modeller), producing n different traces, each representing a forecast from time step: T. These n traces of forecast are used to calculate the confidence interval for the predictions.
In this study, a 95% confidence interval is constructed using 0.025 and 0.975 quantiles that were calculated using the values of n traces at each time step t. Also, as the value of n increases, the median of the forecast becomes more reliable.
Quantifying the effect of lockdown
The counterfactual forecasted daily count of registered cases of missing persons is the predicted value, with the assumption being that there will be no lockdowns in 2020 and 2021. The model provides the confidence interval for the counterfactual prediction of the response time series, which, when subtracted from the actual, provides the confidence interval estimate of the causal impact on the response variable. So, the model shows both the predicted (the counterfactual) and actual (or daily count) distributions of crime.
Using the Shapiro–Wilk test, we verify the normality assumption for the distribution of the counterfactual time series and the actual registered cases of missing persons. The null hypothesis of this test is that the population is normally distributed. As a result, if the p-value is less than the selected alpha level, the null hypothesis is rejected, and evidence that the data being tested is not normally distributed is provided. A t-test is used to find out if the difference was statistically significant if the normality requirements are met.
However, a Wilcoxon sign-rank test is used in place of a t-test for non-normal distribution. The Wilcoxon test determines whether there is a significant difference between the means of two groups. Since the Wilcoxon test is non-parametric, it is subject to far fewer assumptions than tests that are parametric, like t-tests.
We use Cliff's Delta measure to figure out the size of these effects instead of just assuming that the pandemic had an effect on registered missing person cases. This is because Cliff's Delta measure is more reliable if the parametric assumptions are not met (Li, 2016).
Method of measurement of mobility
One of the immediate and direct consequences of movement restrictions was its effect on the mobility of people and vehicles, which was measured using Google's COVID-19 community mobility reports (CMR).The CMR gathers data from both handheld devices and public domain, particularly from those allowing recording of location history, thereby importantly giving two sets of information—a user's activity in terms of location and time spent, which is critical as a mobility tracking tool. This information can be categorised into six community spaces: retail and recreation; parks; groceries and pharmacies; workplaces; transit stations; and residential areas. (Sulyok and Walker, 2020) The mobility assessment can be done by understanding the relative changes in visitors at each community space, which is calculated by comparing the percentage change in the number of visitors at each of these community spaces in comparison to the baseline period.
Due diligence has been taken in the comparison of individuals on each particular day of the week, given the fact that the daily routine of individuals is different on weekdays and weekends. The period between January 3, 2020 and February 6, 2020, spread over 5 weeks, with the median value, is the baseline period. It also provides baseline days, which indicate the normal value on each particular day of the week and allow the study of mobility changes in subsequent lockdown phases.
The main intent of this mobility assessment is to compare the percentage change in mobility from the pre-pandemic baseline, across the six spatial dimensions, in the state of Tamil Nadu between the phases of lockdown. The eight time windows have mobility distribution for each community space. We compare the mobility distribution between time periods and initially check for normality assumptions by adopting the Shapiro–Wilk test. Most distributions are non-normal, and a statistically significant difference is found using the Wilcoxon test. Finally, the measure of effect size, Cliff's delta, is computed as it is robust when the distributions are non-Gaussian.
Descriptive statistical analysis
The following paper has two periods of interest: the pre-pandemic period from January 1, 2010 to March 22, 2020, and the pandemic period from March 23, 2020 to December 31, 2021. The descriptive statistics of the daily count of missing person cases registered in Tamil Nadu such as mean, median, mode, and standard deviation are 32, 32, 18, 14 and 55, 67, 63, and 21 for the pre-pandemic and pandemic periods, respectively (see Table 1). It would not be prudent to straightaway infer that the pandemic period witnessed a massive jump in the recorded level of missing person cases. It is essential to consider the trend, seasonality, and holiday effects of the time-series data before coming to any conclusion regarding the impact of the pandemic. A general increasing trend of cases related to missing persons can be seen across the years in Fig. 2. The counterfactual prediction shows the daily count of cases registered if lockdown had not been imposed. The actual or observed daily count of cases is available as well. It is reiterated that the difference between the two is the magnitude of the causal impact of lockdown.
Table 1 Descriptive statistics: central tendencies for all crimes in both pre-pandemic and pandemic periods.
Results of mobility trends in Tamil Nadu and Chennai
Given the methodology adopted, mobility trends in Tamil Nadu in general and Chennai in particular have been analysed. The results are discussed below.
The imposition of lockdowns by the government aimed to contain the infection and prevent its spread to newer areas. These orders impacted the mobility levels of individuals across various activity zones, as well as the movement of goods and services and vehicles. The Google Community Mobility database was used for both Tamil Nadu as a whole and also Chennai, the largest metropolitan city in the state, separately, for the relevant time periods of waves one and two to assess mobility patterns. With the stay-at-home lockdown orders, a massive spike in terms of percentage change in relation to the baseline value in the mobility levels in the residential neighbourhoods can be observed. However, significant declines in percentage change in mobility in comparison to the baseline values in all other spheres of activities like grocery and pharmacy, retail and recreation, transit stations, workplaces, and parks can also be observed. Table 2 shows that the reduction levels seem to be higher in the complete and partial lockdowns of the first wave than in the second wave.
Table 2 Descriptive statistics of the changes in mobility (in %) from baseline during various lockdown phases in both waves in Tamil Nadu in the six spheres of activity.
The mobility trends were primarily similar in the comparative analysis between Chennai and Tamil Nadu. The differential impact in Chennai on mobility was more pronounced than in Tamil Nadu. In both waves, in all phases and across all spatial domains, Chennai witnessed a more significant percentage change in mobility. See Table 3.
Table 3 Descriptive statistics of the changes in mobility (in %) from baseline during various lockdown phases in both waves in Chennai in the six spheres of activity.
The mobility levels are assessed across the six spatial domains in eight windows of the lockdown period. The research is based on the lockdown phases; the missing person cases registered during these time intervals are analysed when mobility is significantly affected. The inferences are drawn in terms of the factors affecting the registration of missing person cases and unidentified dead bodies (UIDB). Besides, Cliff's delta is utilised as a measure of the effect size (E.S.) to interpret the differences in mobility in these comparative periods (Paramasivan et al., 2022). The results were as anticipated; there was a significant spike in the percentage change from the baseline value concerning residential neighbourhoods due to stay-at-home orders. However, in Tamil Nadu, there was a steep decline in the percentage change in mobility from the baseline of all other spheres of activities like retail and recreation, grocery and pharmacy, parks, transit stations, and workplaces (see Fig. 6). Notably, the quantum of such reduction was greater for complete lockdown and partial lockdown in the first wave than in the second wave, as shown in Table 4.
Fig. 6: Percentage changes in mobility from baseline—six spatial domains—Tamil Nadu—various phases—both waves.
x-axis—dates various lockdown phases—Tamil Nadu—both waves in 2020 and 2021. y-axis: percentage change in mobility for six spatial domains from baseline. The vertical bars space out the different lockdown phases such as CL—complete lockdown, PL—partial lockdown and Post-L—post lockdown. Source: Google Community Mobility Reports.
Table 4 Effect size for various group comparisons among various phases of lockdown during first and second waves of COVID-19 in the state of Tamil Nadu and city of Chennai.
Results of counterfactual analysis of time series
In accordance with the study's assumption regarding the effect of mobility on the reporting of cases involving missing persons in Tamil Nadu, there was a substantial decline in registered cases when compared to the counterfactual during the complete lockdowns of both waves, with a more significant decline in CL-2020 (−74% and E.S.-0.981) and a moderate decline in CL-2021 (−36% and E.S. 0.74). The number of registered cases of unidentified dead bodies (UIDB) followed a similar pattern, albeit with a lesser magnitude of decline (see Fig. 7). When compared with the counterfactual, the recorded instances of UIDB decline of −26% E.S.-0.68 in CL 2020 and a minor dip of −6.12% ES-0.22 in CL 2021. In the phases of PLs during wave one in 2020 and wave two in 2021, there was an increase in mobility from CL to PL. However, the declining trend of missing persons and UIDB cases continued in waves one and two of PLs. Though smaller than what was observed during CLs, the decline in registration remained significant, with a reported large effect size in wave one (−0.84 in PL-2020) and a small one in wave two (−0.20 in PL-Two-2021) (see Fig. 8). In wave two, when curbs were removed, the number of registered cases of missing persons increased by 40% (ES + 0.78) and the number of UIDB cases increased by 18% (ES + 0.39). Chennai City underwent the same analysis again. Chennai experienced a similar pattern to what was observed in Tamil Nadu, in the missing person reports during all phases of both pandemic waves. However, the magnitudes of decline and increase during CLs and PLs were greater in Chennai City than in Tamil Nadu. (please refer to Tables 5 and 6).
Fig. 7: Plot of actual and predicted number of missing person cases using an auto-regressive neural network.
x-axis—timeline of various lockdown phases in both waves in Tamil Nadu. y-axis—daily count of missing person cases registered (actual and predicted). The vertical bars space out the different lockdown phases such as CL—complete lockdown, PL—partial lockdown and Post-L—post lockdown.
Fig. 8: Plot of actual and predicted number of unidentified dead body (UIDB) cases using an auto-regressive neural network.
x-axis—timeline of various lockdown phases in both waves in Tamil Nadu. y-axis—daily count of unidentified dead body (UIDB) cases registered (actual and predicted). The vertical bars space out the different lockdown phases such as CL—complete lockdown, PL—partial lockdown and Post-L—post lockdown.
Table 5 Actual and predicted weekly counts of violent crimes during various phases of lockdowns in waves one and two in Tamil Nadu in 2020–21.
Table 6 Actual and predicted weekly counts of violent crimes during various phases of lockdowns in waves one and two in chennai in 2020–21.
The results above clearly show that there was a drastic reduction in registered cases of missing persons during periods of decreased mobility. This trend is clearly discerned during the transition phases from complete lockdown to partial lockdown in both waves. When all curbs or restrictions on mobility were removed, especially during the second wave in the post-lockdown phase, there was a spike in the number of cases reported. This could be attributed to improved reporting channels. The study thoroughly examines changes in the six spatial domains to note the impact on situational factors for both Tamil Nadu and Chennai City (see Fig. 9).
Fig. 9: Impact of mobility on registered cases of missing person during pandemic.
Relationship between mean percentage change in mobility from baseline and difference between actual and predicted of missing person cases (effect size-Cliffs Delta)—six spatial domains—Tamil Nadu and Chennai. Panel (left): a, c, e Workplace, Transit stations and parks (Mobility vs. effect size (difference between actual cases registered and predicted, expressed as Cliffs delta). Panel (right): b, d, f Retail and recreation, grocery and pharmacy, residential (Mobility vs. effect size (difference between actual cases registered and predicted, expressed as Cliffs delta). x-axis—discrete intervals showing various lockdown phases (CL is complete Lockdown, PL is partial lockdown, and Post-L is post-lockdown). y-axis (left)—shows the mean percentage change in mobility from baseline in different community spaces. y-axis (right)—shows the Cliffs delta, a measure of effect size (difference between the actual and predicted cases of registered missing person cases in Tamil Nadu and Chennai) across all spaces and in various lockdown phases.
The mobility trends and changes in registered missing person cases were analysed to check for urban-rural consistency. In the five spatial domains, namely, "retail and recreation", "grocery and pharmacy", "workplace", "transit stations", and "parks", and across all the lockdown periods, there was a greater percentage reduction in mobility with baseline in Chennai than in Tamil Nadu. Within the spatial domains, a more pronounced differential impact was noticed in "workplace", "transit stations", and "parks" than in "retail and recreation" and "grocery and pharmacy". In the same way, as expected, there was a bigger rise in mobility in "residential" areas of Chennai than in Tamil Nadu.
The reporting channels of missing persons are primarily dependent on the availability of transport, restrictions enforced, and the accessibility of police officers. This directly relates to mobility in the six spatial domains discussed above. The six graphs in the figure indicate that increasing trends in mobility are strongly associated with escalated registered cases of missing persons compared with the counterfactual. The contra-trend of decreasing mobility in residential areas, meaning when fewer individuals are at home, with surging cases of missing persons, is along the same lines. The pandemic-induced lockdown may have impacted only mobility directly, but its reverberations were felt in almost all the situational factors that determine the registration of missing person cases. The crucial situational factor that influences reporting and registration of missing person cases is the ability of complainants to access the relief centres, including the police. Faster, quicker, and easier modes of transportation and their availability to the complainant and the police are likely to result in a higher number of registered cases.
Situational factors came to the fore during stricter phases of lockdowns, during post-lockdown phases, and in the period between the two waves, where more enabling channels of reporting resulted in a significantly higher number of cases registered.
As stated above, upon investigation, the cases of missing persons may turn out to be homicide, abduction, kidnapping, and human trafficking. While these were not crimes at the time of registration, they must be included in the analysis because the restrictive orders caused large-scale dislocation of people, particularly in the context of the labour class, which included guest workers from northern Indian states who had come in search of work in Tamil Nadu. Besides the closure of many institutions, a new culture of working from home has also contributed to the dislocation of individuals from their earlier places of living. In the cases registered as missing persons, there was a drastic decline of −73.87 and −35.29% during CL-2020 and CL-2021 and, similarly, a sharp escalation of 35.40 and 39.98% during PL-2020 and PL-2021. During PL-2020, PL-One-2021, and PL-Two-2021, the changes in percentages were −39.66, +9.14, and −14.63, respectively. It is noticed that there is a decline in the recorded levels of missing persons during CLs and PLs in both the waves, whereas there was a very sharp escalation during the post-lockdown phases of both waves. It is a general practise that the kith and kin do not immediately report instances of missing persons as they usually hope and wait for the missing person to return. This delayed lodging of complaints has always been present, even in the pre-pandemic period. The increased level of reporting and registration of cases during the post-lockdown periods of both waves points to the inability of complainants to reach out to agencies to locate the missing persons during both periods of complete as well as partial lockdowns. This delayed lodging of complaints further highlights the inadequacy of existing registration channels.
Missing persons and UIDB
In fact, the cases of missing persons, where the kith and kin are involved in reporting and following up on the resolution of these cases, present an important study not just to understand them in isolation, but also to trace the correlation they bear with cases of unidentified dead bodies, which remain unresolved for ages, given that there are no immediate kith and kin to report to. In fact, as policing experiences show, the cases of missing persons and unidentified dead bodies are related in several ways. A dead body found in a place whose identity is not known is registered as a case of an unidentified dead body in the jurisdictional police station. This case may have provenance to a case of a missing person registered at some other police station. Furthermore, the origin, cause, or reason for a missing person's case may not always be the same as that of an unidentified dead body. However, for a given place, such as a district or state, over some time, the case trends for the missing person and the unidentified dead body seem to be very similar. The case of a missing person could be viewed as the first and foremost instance where the police take cognisance of a problem. This could manifest and result in a case of homicide, suicide, or accident, and the deceased's identity has not been established at the other police station. The resultant case is registered as a case of an unidentified dead body.
Policy implications
The problems encountered in resolving cases related to missing persons are numerous. As suggested by this study, the issues surrounding the resolution of missing persons are not just related to the filing of the cases, but also to issues of general access to reporting. The panic-driven and lockdown-induced migration during the pandemic led to the forced dislocation of many individuals (Mishra, 2021). The trauma associated with the loss of lives during the pandemic, the loss of livelihood due to job losses, and the enhanced isolation due to forced lockdowns could all be possible reasons for "missing persons" cases. These may not be relevant during non-pandemic times, or indeed could be, but given that the registration of cases and ability to investigate is smoother in non-pandemic times, the emphasis on the investigative aspect is given more impetus rather than the pre-investigative aspects. The pandemic provides a natural setting to examine the pre-investigative reasons and hence the factors that rarely come into focus during regular times. Hence, this study allows for a closer examination of the importance of mobility in various spatial scenarios in the registration of cases, which can thereby help solve missing persons cases better in the future.
As has already been enunciated, finding ways to resolve these issues has to be one of the police force's most important tasks at hand. It is in line with this thought that this study has been conducted. Conclusions have been provided to generate a separate body of literature to support the analysis of the factors affecting the registration of cases of missing persons, factors which pertain not just to pandemic times but also to non-pandemic times, when they would otherwise not be noticed but are nonetheless equally relevant in missing person cases.
With the possibility of exceptional circumstances, it is essential to be well prepared, given that everyday lives cannot be affected for long. As the world witnessed, lockdowns cannot be imposed indefinitely, nor can normal life be hindered for too long. Further, in the context of this paper, relaxation in individuals' movements saw an upsurge in the filing of missing cases, which goes on to emphasise that during the panic-stricken pandemic times, with regulations in place, individuals are deprived of accessing agencies, such as the police, and seeking appropriate remedies. This situation requires amendment, and citizens should have access to justice at all times, where there are pandemics or any other circumstances that affect mobility. Hence, this paper recommends policy reorientation and dynamic changes at multiple levels, including coordination between state and central agencies, proactive participation of non-profit organisations, support mechanisms for victims, etc., to ensure that during times of hardship, the mechanism is in place for individuals to have adequate access to criminal justice agencies.
"Missing persons" is a sensitive issue for family members, given the protracted agony that they may face in the absence of any knowledge about the whereabouts and situation of their loved ones. (Holmes, 2016) Hence, police personnel need to be sensitised as to how to handle these cases, trained to follow Standard Operating Procedures and handle the issue swiftly, given that most of the studies highlight the importance of acting within the first 48 hours or so following the FIR (Briones and Chhabra, 2022; Pierzchala et al., 2021), in order to maximise the chances of tracing the missing person. Often the focus of the missing individual is "body centred" and less on forensic investigative principles. A higher reporting requirement, alongside ensuring prompt action, also facilitates clear roles and responsibilities of all stakeholders involved, through an integrated, multidisciplinary, and multi-agency approach (Salado Puerto et al., 2021).
Technological intervention is inevitable as it helps to identify and analyse challenges that could prevent registration, such as mobility, as demonstrated by this paper. This then results in delays in the process of filing and investigation. Mobility can thus also be enhanced by augmenting technology and engaging communities at various levels. As a result, in addition to the intervention of Crime Criminal Tracking Network Systems (CCTNS), a centralised pool of data on the missing people and a repeated release of missing persons list may be needed. A profiling tool can be created and stored as a database. This will serve as a ready reckoner in adverse situations. Registers have to be produced with a standardised operating procedure and a proper understanding of the spatial features of the police division topography. This must include awareness of age and gender diversity; socio-economic profiles of the individuals in these locations, such as the awareness of the diversity of the population in terms of school and college students and marginal classes; awareness of the dark alleys of the cities and crowded places; and search techniques linking the probable locations based on age, gender, and occupational diversity of the missing persons. Many reports from around the world (Parr and Fyfe, 2013) have emphasised this kind of evidence-based policing. A case in point is the success that the Australian Police met with, in utilising the media to assist in the location and recovery of absent people (Siddiqui and Wayland, 2022).
Missing persons, either voluntary or involuntary, can ultimately be linked to the psycho-social-cultural elements of society, as with any abnormality or crime. Repeated missing is a case wherein the person missing runs away on more than one occasion, given the pressures at home, or mental health issues. In order to stop missing cases of this nature from happening again, it is important to raise awareness about mental health within the community.
In the short run, socio-economic resources play a vital role in individuals going missing. Hence, keeping crime in check and focusing policing on specific potentially problematic sections of the society, such as the youth, unemployed, and illness-prone individuals, is crucial. This will help the police keep ears to the ground, as will special awareness camps on the problems and rights of individuals, to ensure the police has close access to individuals, which in turn can keep the "missing person phenomenon" both voluntary and involuntary, in check. Moreover, governance-related interventions are integral to solving issues of policing. In particular, governance reforms in terms of enhancing police resources, both human and infrastructural, are integral to ensure that adequate focus is placed on all forms of crime, including missing persons.
The pandemic witnessed one of the largest migrations of individuals in India after the partition of India in 1947. Owing to the cessation of public transport during certain critical phases of the lockdowns, individuals were displaced and dislocated, contributing to higher missing person cases. In absolute numbers, the daily count of the mean number of missing person cases rose by 61%, that is, from 32 in the pre-pandemic period (Jan 1, 2010 to March 22, 2020) to 55 in the pandemic years (March 23, 2020 to December 31, 2021). The daily count of the mode number of cases during the corresponding periods was 18 and 63, which also highlights the huge upsurge of cases.
The case of missing persons has been a testimony to the significance of mobility, thus highlighting the indispensable role of registration of crimes and setting the law in motion. The study clearly suggests that during CL, there was a decline of 74% and 36% of missing person cases in the actual case when compared with the counterfactual, during the first and second waves, respectively. There was a corresponding escalation of 35% and 40% in the post-lockdown phases. The only exception was that when there were no restrictions during the two years, the actual number of registered cases was consistently higher than predicted in all other periods. While we acknowledge that the pandemic has adversely impacted the reporting channels of all crimes, it is more acute in the cases of missing persons as locating them gets more challenging with the passage of time on account of delayed reporting. Hence, there is a dire need to provide better physical access for these complainants, provide adequate relief centres, and involve all stakeholders to jointly work towards a quick redressal of grievances by promptly locating and tracing the missing persons.
The data that support the study's findings are available from the State Crime Records Bureau of the Tamil Nadu Police Department. The author does not have permission to share the data for public use. However, upon a reasonable request, the data can be made available for research purposes after the researchers get consent from the Tamil Nadu State Crime Records Bureau.
Alexandrov A, Benidis K, Bohlke-Schneider M, Flunkert V, Gasthaus J, Januschowski T, Gluon TS, et al. (2019) Probabilistic time series models in python. [preprint]. Jun. Available from: https://arxiv.org/abs/1906.05264
AMBER Alert Europe (2022) AMBER Alert Europe. (https://www.amberalert.eu/)
Ambler S (2014) Invisible women a call to action; a report on missing and murdered indigenous women in Canada; 41st Parliament First Session. House of Commons Special Committee on Violence Against Indigenous Women, Ottawa Ontario. http://www.parl.gc.ca/content/hoc/Committee/412/IWFA/Reports/RP6469851/IWFArp01/IWFArp01-e.pdf
Briones JL, Chhabra T (2022) Navigation mesh for missing persons search: student mobile application competition: smart cities and internet of things category. In the 23rd International Conference on Distributed Computing and Networking (ICDCN 2022). Association for Computing Machinery, New York, NY, USA, 252–253. https://doi.org/10.1145/3491003.3500927
Calderon-Anyosa R, Bilal U, Kaufman JS (2021) Variation in non-external and external causes of death in Peru in relation to the COVID-19 lockdown.Yale J Biol Med 94(1):23–40
Ferguson L, Soave V (2020) #Missing to #Found: exploring police Twitter use for missing persons investigations. Police Pract Res 22:869–885
Freya O, Collie C, Greene KS, Giles S (2021) The impact of COVID-19 lockdown restrictions on missing person reports. Polic Soc https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2021.1999448
Greene KS (2020) The independent civilian review into missing persons investigation missing persons: identifying best practice, Training and Research Needs
Holmes L (2016) Missing someone: exploring the experiences of family members. In: Morewitz S, Sturdy Colls C (eds) Handbook of missing persons. Springer, Cham, pp. 105–126
ICMP Syria. (2021) Icmp.Int. (https://www.icmp.int/where-we-work/middle-east-and-north-africa/syria/)
Irudaya Rajan S, Sivakumar P, Srinivasan A (2020) The COVID-19 pandemic and internal labour migration in India: a 'crisis of mobility'. Indian J Labour Econ 63(4):1021–1039. https://doi.org/10.1007/s41027-020-00293-8
Jesline J, Romate J, Rajkumar E et al. (2021) The plight of migrants during COVID-19 and the impact of circular migration in India: a systematic review. Humanit Soc Sci Commun 8:231. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-021-00915-6
Khanna A (2020) Impact of migration of labour force due to global COVID-19 pandemic with reference to India. J Health Manag 22(2):181–191. https://doi.org/10.1177/0972063420935542
Krubiner C, O'Donnell M, Kaufman J, Bourgault S (2021) What do we know about the indirect impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, global recession, and associated policy measures on women's and girls' health? In: Addressing the COVID-19 crisis's indirect health impacts for women and girls. Centre for Global Development. 7–17 http://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep30883.5
Laura van D (2013) Missing persons and social exclusion https://uwspace.uwaterloo.ca/bitstream/handle/10012/7678/van_Dongen_Laura.pdf?sequence=1
Li JCH (2016) Effect size measures in a two-independent-samples case with non-normal and nonhomogeneous data. Behav Res [Internet] 48:1560–1574. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13428-015-0667-z
Marks T (2021) Why a year of lockdown has made searching for the missing so hard, The Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/apr/11/why-a-year-of-lockdown-has-made-searching-for-the-missing-so-hard
Mishra DK (2021) Migrant labour during the Pandemic: a political economy perspective. Indian Econ J 69(3):410–424. https://doi.org/10.1177/00194662211021209
FBI (2019) NCIC missing person and unidentified person statistics. Federal Bureau of Investigation. Retrieved April 3, 2022 (https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/2019-ncic-missing-person-and-unidentified-person-statistics.pdf/view)
Nicholas RF, Stevenson O, Woolnough P (2015) Missing persons: the processes and challenges of police investigation. Polic Soc 25(4):409–425. https://doi.org/10.1080/10439463.2014.881812
Paramasivan K, Subburaj R, Jaiswal S et al. (2022) Empirical evidence of the impact of mobility on property crimes during the first two waves of the COVID-19 pandemic. Humanit Soc Sci Commun 9:373. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-022-01393-0
Parr H, Fyfe N (2013) Missing geographies. Prog Hum Geogr 37(5):615–638. https://doi.org/10.1177/0309132512465919
Pier MB, Di Maggio RM, Mesturini S (2021) Materials for the study of the locus Operandi in the search for missing persons in Italy, Forensic Sci Res, https://doi.org/10.1080/20961790.2020.1854501
Pierzchała D, Antkiewicz R, Czuba P, Gutowski T (2021) Prediction of Missing Persons' Disappearance Reason Using Machine Learning Methods. Paper presented at the 36th International Business Information Management Association (IBIMA) at Granada, Spain January 2021
Salado Puerto M, Abboud D, Baraybar JP, Carracedo A, Fonseca S, Goodwin W, Guyomarc'h P, Jimenez A, Krenzer U, Morcillo Mendez MD, Prieto JL, Rodriguez Gonzalez J, Ruiz Orozco Y, Taylor J, Tennakoon A, Winter K, Finegan O (2021) The search process: Integrating the investigation and identification of missing and unidentified persons. Forensic Sci Int. Synergy 3:100154. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fsisyn.2021.100154
Salinas D, Flunkert V, Gasthuas J, Januschowski T (2020). DeepAR: probabilistic forecasting with autoregressive recurrent networks. Int J Force [Internet]. 36(3):1181–1191
Sen A (1990) More than 100 million women are missing. The New York Review of Books
Shalev Greene K, Pakes F(2014) The cost of missing person investigations: implications for current debates Policing 8(1):27–34. https://doi.org/10.1093/police/pat036
Sulyok M, Walker M (2020) Community movement and COVID-19: a global study using Google's Community Mobility Reports. Epid Infec [Internet]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1017/S0950268820002757
Testoni I, Franco C, Palazzo L, Iacona E, Zamperini A, Wieser, MA (2020) The endless grief in waiting: a qualitative study of the relationship between ambiguous loss and anticipatory mourning amongst the relatives of missing persons in Italy. Behav. Sci. 10(7):110.
The Associated Press. (2021) China cuts uighur births with IUDs, abortion, sterilization. Associated Press. Retrieved April 3, 2022 (https://apnews.com/article/ap-top-news-international-news-weekend-reads-china-health269b3de1af34e17c1941a514f78d764c)
Siddiqui A, Wayland S (2022) Lost from the conversation: missing people, and the role of Police media in shaping community awareness. Police J 95(2):296–313. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032258X20984502
The authors are extremely grateful to the State Crime Records Bureau of the Tamil Nadu Police Department in India for providing the data required for this study. The authors also thank the Indian Robert Bosch Centre for Data Science and Artificial Intelligence (RBCDSAI) and the Indian Institute of Technology Madras (SB20210605MSRBCX008658). Additionally, the authors appreciate the help with data collection and compilation from Mr. Raghuraman, Inspector of Police, and Mrs. Shanthi, Sub-Inspector of Police, Technical Services, Tamil Nadu Police. The study's overall presentation, including the graphs, received valuable contributions from Mr. Shahul Hameed and Mr. Nagarajan, for which the authors are grateful. Finally, the assistance with language editing provided by Ms. Thaenpaavai Kannan is greatly appreciated.
Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-corruption, Government of Tamil Nadu, Chennai, India
Kandaswamy Paramasivan
Tamil Nadu Police Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, Chennai, India
Brinda Subramani
Department of Management Studies, Indian Institute of Technology, Madras, Chennai, India
Nandan Sudarsanam
Robert Bosch Centre for Data Science and AI, Indian Institute of Technology, Madras, Chennai, India
Correspondence to Kandaswamy Paramasivan.
Ethical approval
This article does not contain any studies with human participants performed by any of the authors.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Paramasivan, K., Subramani, B. & Sudarsanam, N. Counterfactual analysis of the impact of the first two waves of the COVID-19 pandemic on the reporting and registration of missing people in India. Humanit Soc Sci Commun 9, 408 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-022-01426-8
COVID-19: humanities and social sciences perspectives
Referee instructions
Humanities and Social Sciences Communications (Humanit Soc Sci Commun) ISSN 2662-9992 (online)


Playing a game can be very beneficial in different ways. This is especially considering that there are online games that can play as well as the physical games. However, one important thing left relatively is that through betting on different games you can also make a lot of money. In case you are looking at ways of making money, then this can be one of the best alternatives for you to take because many other people have succeeded this way by playing different lottery numbers. All you need to do is master the art of picking the best winning lottery numbers and you can stand a better chance of winning like many other billionaires in the world right now. There are different ways to go about picking the best and winning lottery numbers and can read more below to understand how.
If you are beginning playing the game, then it is very important that you keep yourself especially when it comes to the process of winning. This is because as long as you are not even fully acquainted with the system, it becomes very hard for you to also analyze and pick winning lottery numbers. This is why you need to keep yourself with the rules of playing the game and also understand the regulations within your country because they change from one state to another. Another thing you cannot ignore it comes to picking winning lottery numbers is learning from other people that have been here for long. You need to be curious about what other people are doing all that they are using to pick winning lottery numbers because it helps you a lot. This is not hard because you can get lottery results for all 50 states lottery companies. The amazing thing is that there's more info that you can look at especially of the previous winning lottery numbers so that you can use them to your advantage as you also read what other people are saying. However, when you are looking at different sources of information such as michigan lottery results ensure that you can trust website.
Another thing you need to be very sure about is that analyzing is a skill that you have to learn but you can develop it over time as you do this over and over again. For example, need to know how to play around with the odd number and so on. There is no doubt that can become rich therefore if you are using various strategies which you should learn.
We all know what a dice is, it is a small cube having different numbers on each side which are represented by dots. Dice can be used for gaming. Did you know that dice can also be used for teaching? They make any learning experience fun and interactive. You can find many dice varying from different colors and sizes. Which is the reason why you may have a hard time selecting a store to purchase your dice from. Purchasing dice must be thought carefully since it provides more benefit than you think. That being said, here is a useful guide to help you know more info. on how you are able to select the best store to purchase dice.
It is important that you have a vision of your ideal dice. In order to make it easier for you to find a dice store, identify what design you want it to have, how colorful you want your dice to be, and how big you want your dice to be. You can get inspiration from the dices sold by Easy Roller Dice.
If you are looking for dice stores online, make sure to read the comments and review section of their website or page. This will help you learn more about the store since you will get a first-hand opinion from their previous and current customers. Skim through and check if there are any complaints resolved by the seller such as late delivery. A reliable dice store would listen to each customers sentiments. Also make sure that the seller is legitimate and that the information you will give them is secured and will be kept confidential.
See to it their price range is affordable and worth the commitment of paying with.
You can ask for a piece of advice from a friend or neighbor who has recently purchased a new dice. You will be sure that their recommendation is honest and has been tried and tested.
Check out what other products and dice for sale they offer. Find out if they have a polyhedral dice set available. It is a must-have dice. You can find them on Easy Roller Dice.
The last tip is that it is important that the seller is someone you trust. The staff must be easy to talk to and can easily answer any questions you may have.
The game of using dice sets never gets obsolete because the experience is new every day. No one can be discriminated from playing dice, irrespective of their age or gender. There are many reasons as to why people play dice depending on the value they attach to the game. Dice games are played everywhere around you. All the dice sets available give you the basics needed to play the game. They also come in different shapes and colors. You will be able to find your dice from a dice making company. Before making the decision of purchasing your dice, keep the following points in mind.
It will be wise to approach a manufacturer that produces customized dice sets. Such a company will not give you variety when it comes to dice sets. You, therefore, need to do your research before going to buy a dice set. Asking for reference can be a great way to start.
Easy Roller Dice company produces highly rated dice sets. You will be a satisfied customer if the dice you buy works efficiently. Do not fall victim of poor quality dice sets by going to Easy Roller Dice. You need to find out about this by looking at customer review on the best products.
The rates of dice sets given by that manufacturer should also be among your considerations. Do not buy them from a company that overprices them. You should not expect to find a flat rate for all dice sets since the quality differs. It will be ideal to shun manufactures that do not care about your financial welfare.
It will be wise for you to visit Easy Roller Dice because they have been in the business for long and have been giving customers great value by producing quality dice. You should know that experience is what makes a company great. Find out if it has an established brand that is trusted by most people.
Additionally, find a dice manufacturer that offers a wide selection of dice sets so that you view options. You will have to worry less if you can find all you need under one roof. You also need to find a company that provides after sales services like shipping your dice to the required destination. You can have the confidence to refer your friends to check it out!
Choosing an outstanding plastic surgeon is one of the best decisions that you can make. This plastic surgery expert is able to correct you defects as well as enhancing the way in which you feel or even see yourself. It is hectic to find the best plastic surgeon expert that you can trust within your area. Time is required for research and harnessing of data before you can choose the best one. Examples of plastic surgeon doctors that I can recommend you to include Dr Joseph Rizk, who has played a vital role in changing the entire face of the industry. Here are some of the hints that you ought to consider when choosing a plastic surgeon Sydney.
One of the many hints to consider when selecting a good plastic surgeon within your area is requesting for referrals. You may need to contact your personal doctor of any plastic surgeon they know within your area. You may go ahead to ask for the advice of your friends, relatives, as well as healthcare staff within your home for any recommendations that they may have about a plastic surgeon. Out of all the suggested names of the plastic surgeon, you have to take your time and find out more about their experience as well as their credentials before opting to work with them. You may organize an interview and meet your plastic surgeon of choice over a number of issues. This company can also aid you to discover more plastic surgery experts that you can consult for your medication purpose.
The next factor that you ought to consider when selecting a plastic surgeon is ascertaining their credentials. An example of a mandatory credential that you must consider when looking for a plastic surgeon is board certification. This homepage contains some of the necessary skills, training as well as experience that the best plastics surgeon must possess. It good if you can ascertain that the plastic surgery expert that you want to hire is clean and does not face any cases of indiscipline or malpractice. You are free to click for more attributes that the best plastic surgeon Sydney can possess before you can hire their services.
The third tip that you must consider when selecting an outstanding plastic surgeon in your area is their level of experience. Assessing the length of experience that your plastic surgeon of choice has must be considered before settling on any expert. Your breast surgeons Sydney or a plastic surgeon of choice has to have more than 5 years of experience in plastic surgery. You are advised to see this page in case you want to find some of the top plastic surgeons that you can work within the treatment process.


WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind. — Every single one of the 5,000 VIP All Sports cards that were allocated to Purdue students for the 2009-10 school year have been sold.
Selling out the VIP All Sports cards could be interpreted as a vote of confidence by the students in the new head coach, and an auspicious beginning to a new era in Boilermaker football.
Purdue students may still purchase a football season ticket for $119. The season ticket includes general admission seating in the student section at all seven home football games, which includes Notre Dame and Ohio State. This price represents a savings of nearly 50 percent compared with purchasing student single-game tickets.
Hope and the Boilermakers open the 2009 season Sept. 5 against Toledo at Ross-Ade.


I LOVE all thing pink in my world! Using a special ingredient in your staple chocolate chip cookie recipe satisfies me in making a pink chocolate chip cookie. These cherry chocolate chip cookies taste amazing!
Let's get to making these goodies so you know the exact thing I used to make these cookies Cherry flavored without changing anything else in a recipe.
Start by mixing the butter, vanilla and sugars together.
Did you spot the special ingredient in the list above?? It's CHERRY JELLO! After your sugars and butters are mixed thoroughly, add one 3 ounce box of cherry jello. This will give your dough the pink color as well as flavor. SCORE!!
Next up, add all of your dry ingredients and mix thoroughly.
Gently mix in your white chocolate chips. You can use all white or mix in some brown. It's a personal preference in what your family likes.
At this point, if you bake the cookies, they will flatten. In order to prevent that from happening, you will want to refrigerate your cookie dough for at least 30 minutes. That will harden the butter back up so that the cookies bake nice and fluffy. Side note – my husband loves thin cookies, so I tend to bake him a small batch before I refrigerate.
Using a small cookie scoop, place them 5 inches apart on a cookie sheet. You can also add some extra sprinkles before cookies to dress them up a little bit.
Bake at 350 degree for 10-12 minutes and let cool on a cooling rack.
Tie or package them up and they're ready to go to a school party or to give as a gift to a neighbor or friend.
I mean everyone loves cookies, so why not! Unless your family enjoys them so much and you don't have any left to give. That's what happens in my house.
Did you like these Cherry Chocolate Chip Cookies? I'd love for you to share it with your friends on social media and PIN it so you have it for later! If you like what you see on this page, I'd love for you to join my mailing list HERE! When you join, I'll send you my FREE Home Decor Holiday Printables that you can immediately download. Just my way of saying "thank you" and encouraging you to live your best life!!


text:
Multiple Sclerosis Incapacitates District Sales Manager
"Alison" was the District Sales Manager for a major insurance company. Unfortunately, she had been struggling with Multiple Sclerosis for many years. After working for almost 30 years for this company and achieving significant professional success, she was denied long term disability benefits under both a group policy and an individual policy issued by her employer.
In addition to the heartbreaking effects of her own illness, Alison had to deal with the cruel fact that the very company to which she had devoted almost three decades of her life did not feel that she 'deserved' long term disability benefits. Indeed, the insurance company denied Alison's claim solely on the basis of a hired doctor's opinion that Alison was capable of "sedentary" work.
How could Alison's own employer forget that her job was in no sense of the word "sedentary?"
Alison hired Riemer Hess to appeal her denial. The Firm gathered all of Alison's available medical evidence, obtained detailed reports from Alison's treating physicians supporting her disability, and prepared a comprehensive appeal letter attacking each reason raised by the insurance company in its denial, including its erroneous conclusion that Alison's job was "sedentary."
The insurance company reversed itself, paid Alison all past benefits owed, and placed Alison on long term disability with full benefits. Riemer Hess continues to work with Alison to ensure that her benefits are not interrupted.

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


Reciprocal Clubs | The Bendigo Club | The Friendliest Club!
Being a member of The Bendigo Club also entitles you to many great member's benefits at these other Clubs.
The Celtic Club, located in central Melbourne, is Australia's first Irish Club and has a reputation for providing a warm and hearty welcome since 1887.
Irish and other Celtic groups at the club continue to grow. Music sessions are a regular feature at the Celtic Club as well as cultural and heritage events.
Restaurant and function facilities are also available.


text:
Jany with vocation and capacity to preside over a polling station
Traducción: Ramón Cabezas
Photos Idania Pupo
Jany Reina Alcántara can be found at the polling station number two of constituency nine, in the city of Ciego de Ávila, in every democratic exercise that involves voting by the citizenry.
She has the vocation and capacity to work in favor of the processes to elect representatives of the population before government agencies or to validate laws, decrees and even the Constitution of the Republic or the Family Code.
The young Avilanian has experience in secretarial work and has even been president of a poll station in recent years.
Jany, always friendly and communicative, attends to the voters to clarify their doubts and explain the procedure that ends with the deposit of the ballot in the ballot box.
In addition, she transmits her vocation of service to society to her son Roberto de Jesús Companioni, 14 years old, who has accompanied his mother Jany in the work of the polling station, as custodian of the ballot box since he was a child.
A legal advisor by profession and a woman involved in every social task, Jany Reina feels the satisfaction of contributing to the legality of the country and the work of the governing body.
Artículo anteriorJany con vocación y capacidad para presidir un colegio electoral
Artículo siguienteYoung creators commemorate the execution of the eight medical students
Productive actions intensified in the Ciro Redondo sugar industry in Ciego de Ávila
Provincial act for the 84th anniversary of the CTC carried out (+ Photos)
National Youth Club Directorate congratulates the specialists from Ciego de Ávila


text:
Chevelle sunt o formație de rock/metal alternativ  din Chicago, Illinois fondată în 1994 de către Pete Loeffler și Sam Loeffler, Joe Loeffler alăturându-li-se în 1996 (care a fost înlocuit de către cumnatul Loeffler-ilor, Dean Bernardini). Numele formației se referă la mașina preferată a tatălui fraților Loeffler. Inspirat din secvențele muzicale ale celor de la Helmet și de stilul Tool, formația americană Chevelle s-a impus în lumea artiștilor prin sunetul agresiv, tensionat al chitarelor. Format în 1995, în Chicago, trupa era alcatuită din Sam (tobe), Pete (voce, chitară) și Joe (bas) Loeffler. Cariera lor a început cu mici spectacole la petreceri și la evenimente locale.

Istoria formației

Point #1
Colaborând cu producătorul Steve Albini, Chevelle și-au lansat albumul de debut Point#1 prin casa de discuri Squint Entertainment în mai 1999. Deși albumul a fost criticat datorită structurii repetititve a melodiilor, a fost în general bine primit de public. În această perioadă formația a fost etichetată drept o formație rock creștină, deși ei nu se prezintă astfel. Piesa care dă numele albumului Point No. 1, ca de altfel și Mia au fost lansate ca single-uri. Videoclipuri au fost produse pentru ambele, și fiecare a câștigat un premiu Dove Award pentru Hard Music Song: Mia în 2000 și Point #1 anul următor. Albumul a castigat si un  premiu "Hard Music Album" in 2000.

Wonder What's Next
Au dobândit faimă în 2002 cu albumul Wonder What's Next. Formația a ales să semneze un contract cu casa de discuri Epic după ce au auzit albumul trupei Mudvayne L.D. 50. Albumul Wonder What's Next a lansat hituri precum The Red, Closure, și Send the Pain Below, care au ajuns în fruntea topurilor Mainstream Rock Chart și Modern Rock Tracks chart. Albumul a fost în cele din urmă recompensat cu discul de platină în iunie. Succesul trupei a rezultat în concertarea lor în Ozzfest și îmbarcarea în turul Europei împreună cu Audioslave.

This Type of Thinking (Could Do Us In)
Cel de-al treile album, This Type of Thinking (Could Do Us In) a fost lansat în septembrie 2004 și a produs 3 single-uri, Vitamin R (Leading Us Along), The Clincher, and Panic Prone. Vitamin R (Leading Us Along) a ajuns pe locul 1 în Mainstream Rock Chart și a beneficiat de multă difuzare pe MTV și MTV2. The Clincher' a fost inclus în jocul video Madden NFL 2005. Albumul a fost recompensat cu discul de aur de RIAA. Trupa și-a promovat albumul cu un tur ce includea trupele Taproot și 30 Seconds to Mars, cântând în deschidere. Chevelle au încheiat anul cu un tur de arenă, deschizând pentru Nickelback.

Vena Sera
Albumul numărul patru a celor de la Chevelle, Vena Sera a fost lansat pe 3 aprilie 2007, vânzându-se  în 62.000 de exemplare în prima săptămână, debutând pe locul 12 în topul Billboard Hot 200 Albums. Well Enough Alone a fost primul single și a beneficiat de succes mediu la radio, împreună cu propriul videoclip care a câștigat într-un concurs de selectare videclipuri pe MTV. Chevelle au plecat în turneu împreună cu  Evanescence, Finger Eleven și Strata în martie și  aprilie 2007, urmat de un alt tur doar cu Finger Eleven și Strata în mai și iunie. Cel de-al doilea single de pe album, I Get It a fost lansat în 12 iunie 2007. Trupa și-a petrecut luna iulie 2007 în turneu în Australia cu trupa The Butterfly Effect.

Albume

Demo-uri

DVDLive from the Norva, 2003 (Epic)This Type of Thinking (Could Do Us In) DualDisc, 2005 (Epic)

Single-uri

Membri
Schimbari
Deși trupa a fost inițial formată din cei 3 frati Loeffler, Joe Loeffler a fost elibert din funcția sa de chitarist-bass la data de 10 iulie 2005 datorită unor diferențe ireconciliabile. A fost înlocuit de Geno Lenardo, pentru puțin timp, pentru restul turului de vară al anului 2005. În 20 august 2005, Lenardo a fost înlocuit de Dean Bernadini, cumnatul fraților Loeffler.

Contribuții-coloană sonoră
 Road Rash: Jail Break(1999) – "Mia"
 Daredevil: The Album (2003) – "Until You're Reformed"
 The Punisher: The Album (2004) '' – "Still Running" (Alternative Version)

Videografie

Chevelle a produs 9 videoclipuri:
 "Point #1" (1999)
 "MIA" (2000)
 "The Red" (2002)
 "Send the Pain Below" (2003)
 "Closure" (2003)
 "Vitamin R (Leading Us Along)" (2004)
 "The Clincher" (2005)
 "Well Enough Alone" (2007)
 "I Get It" (2007)
 "The Fad" (2008)

Note

Formații muzicale

Formații rock americane

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaWikipedia


Welcome to the Portrait of America competition. Following are the terms and conditions that govern your use of this site. THESE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF USE CONSTITUTE A LEGAL AGREEMENT BETWEEN YOU AND FABRIK MEDIA, INC., THE ORGANIZER OF PORTRAIT OF AMERICA ("THE ORGANIZERS," "WE" OR "OUR"). PLEASE READ THIS AGREEMENT ("AGREEMENT") IN ITS ENTIRETY BEFORE YOU CONTINUE TO USE THIS WEBSITE OR UPLOAD ANY IMAGE. BY USING THIS WEBSITE, YOU AGREE TO BE BOUND BY THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS AGREEMENT. IF YOU DO NOT AGREE, DISCONTINUE USING THE SITE.
The Portrait of America competition's Early Bird Deadline is 11:59 p.m. Pacific Standard Time (PST) March 31, 2018.
Entrants must be at least 18 years of age as of the date of entry. CONTEST IS VOID WHERE PROHIBITED.
The submission fee can be found on the How to Enter page of this website. There is no limit to the number of images you can submit.
Photographs must be in digital format. Video entries must be submitted as a working URL link to Vimeo video that allows embedding. If the video is "private" you must provide a password so jurors are able to view the video. Only online entries will be eligible. No print submissions will be accepted for entry into this Contest. All types of digital images are acceptable, including but not limited to scans of negatives, scans of transparencies, and scans of photographic prints. All digital files must be 4 megabytes or smaller, must be in JPEG, JPG, or PNG format, and must be no more than 1,280 pixels wide (if a horizontal image) or 1,280 pixels tall (if a vertical image). All digital files should be set to color profile: RGB or sRGB.
Photographs that include sculptures, statues, paintings, digital and other works of art will be accepted as long as they do not constitute copyright infringement or fraud; provided entrants must be prepared to provide a release form as described below in "ENTRANT LICENSES/RELEASES". When photographing the work of others, it must be as an object in its environment and not a full-frame close-up of another person's art.
By entering the Contest, entrant represents, acknowledges, and warrants that the submitted photograph is an original work created solely by the entrant, that the photograph does not infringe on the copyrights, trademarks, moral rights, rights of privacy/publicity or intellectual property rights of any person or entity, and that no other party has any right, title, claim, or interest in the photograph. The photograph must not, in the sole and unfettered discretion of the Portrait of America, contain obscene, provocative, defamatory, sexually explicit, or otherwise objectionable or inappropriate content. In the case of minors (persons under 18) parental or guardian consent must be obtained.
Upon request, each entrant must be prepared to provide (within fourteen (14) calendar days of receipt of said request) a signed release from all persons who appear in the photograph submitted, and/or from the owner of any material that appears in the photograph entry, authorizing the Portrait of America to reproduce, distribute, and display the entry in connection with the Contest and promotion of the Contest, in any media now or hereafter known. Failure to provide such releases upon request may result in disqualification at any time during the Contest and selection of an alternate winner.
Similarly, upon the organizers' request, each entrant must be prepared to provide (within fourteen (14) calendar days of receipt of the organizers' request) a signed written license from the copyright owner of any sculpture, artwork, other copyrighted material, or private property that appears in the photograph entry, authorizing the Portrait of America to reproduce, distribute, and display the entry in connection with the Contest and promotion of the Contest, in any media now or hereafter known. Failure to provide such releases upon request may result in disqualification and selection of an alternate winner.
Entries may be published by Fabrik Media, Inc. and the Portrait of America, and any of the Portrait of America affiliated Sponsors and/or their designees, licensees or affiliates (the "Authorized Parties") in magazines or books, on websites, or in any other medium, at Authorized Parties' discretion. Such use will be restricted to promotion, publicity, news, or informational education, or awareness of the Portrait of America. By participating, all entrants grant a license in the Entries to the Authorized Parties, and acknowledge that any Authorized Party may use the entries and a name credit in any media now or hereafter known, without restriction in relation to the uses stated above. Authorized Parties will not be required to pay any additional consideration or seek any additional approval in connection with such use. Copyright over all submissions remain the property of their respective entrants.
By participating, entrants agree to release, discharge, and hold harmless Fabrik Media, Inc., the Portrait of America and each of their respective partners, affiliates, subsidiaries, advertising agencies, agents and their employees, officers, directors, and representatives from any claims, losses, and damages arising out of their participation in this Contest or any Contest-related activities and the acceptance and use, misuse, or possession of any prize awarded hereunder.
The Organizers assume no responsibility for any error, omission, interruption, deletion, defect, or delay in operation or transmission; communications line failure; theft or destruction of or unauthorized access to Contest entries or entry forms; or alteration of entries or entry forms. The Organizers are not responsible for any problems with or technical malfunction of any telephone network or lines, computer online systems, servers or providers, computer equipment, software, failure of any e-mail entry to be received on account of technical problems or traffic congestion on the Internet or at any website, human errors of any kind, or any combination thereof, including any injury or damage to entrants' or any other persons' computers related to or resulting from participation, uploading, or downloading of any materials related to this Contest.
THIS CONTEST IS VOID WHERE PROHIBITED. This Contest is subject to federal, state, and local laws and regulations. Certain restrictions may apply. Sponsor is not responsible for late, lost, incomplete or misdirected entries. Entries void if the Sponsor determines the entry to not be an original, or if the entries are illegible, incomplete, damaged, irregular, altered, counterfeit, produced in error or obtained through fraud or theft.
Participants also agree (a) to be bound by these Official Rules; (b) that the decisions of the Judges are final on all matters relating to the Contest; and (c) if he/she wins, that Sponsor may use the winning photographs and each winner's name and photograph in any publicity or advertising relating to the Contest or future promotions without compensation or approval (except in Tennessee and where prohibited by law). All federal, state and local taxes, fees and surcharges on prizes are the sole responsibility of the prize winners. In the event that the selected winner(s) of any prize is/are ineligible or refuses the prize, the prize will be forfeited and the Organizers, in their sole discretion, may choose whether to award the prize to another entrant.
If for any reason the Contest is not capable of running as planned, due to infection by computer virus, bugs, worms, trojan horses, denial of service attacks, tampering, unauthorized intervention, fraud, technical failures, or any other causes beyond the control of the Organizers that corrupt or affect the administration, security, fairness, integrity, or proper conduct of this Contest, the Organizers reserve the right, at their sole discretion, to disqualify any individual(s) who tamper with the entry process, and/or to cancel, terminate, modify, or suspend the Contest. If the Organizers elect to cancel or terminate the Contest, the Organizers will not retain any rights in the submitted photographs and will return the entry fees.
A list of Winners in the competition and their winning entries will be available online at portraitofamerica.net after September 3, 2018.
Any claim relating to Portrait of America shall be governed by the laws of the State of California without regard to its conflict of law provisions.


of durable materials with adjustable straps, these bags are going to be a hit for your everyday adventures!
Bewakoof's Latest Introduction in the range of Accessories is an exciting range of Bags.
touch on your smartphone and just sit, relax while the good folks at our company ready the bag of your choice with utmost care and love and make sure it is delivered to you and you are good to go and use it for the often multi-functional use our bags have been specially designed and built for.
Now be a trendsetter with these and buy bags online with Bewakoof!
What is the Bewakoof Collection of Cool Bags Like?
It's style meet convenience! We know how important it is to have the right accessories and find them is just your element of style, well now you don't need to go on a wild goose chase to find trendy bags for men and women. Because we've got them in a variety of colors, combinations and material and they also are value for money with a tried and tested quality check to make sure they don't just look good, but also fulfill its purpose. The straps on these college bags are made to endure rough and tough on the go usage. So stop worrying, start shopping!
recommend buying bags online from us to your friends and family alike.