text:
Volume 5, Issue 12
District-level health system strengthening for universal health coverage: evidence from a longitudinal cohort study in rural Madagascar, 2014-2018
http://orcid.org/0000-0001-6225-5226Andres Garchitorena1,2,
Ann C Miller2,3,
Laura F Cordier2,
Marius Randriamanambintsoa4,
Hery-Tiana R Razanadrakato4,
Mauricianot Randriamihaja2,
Benedicte Razafinjato2,
Karen E Finnegan2,3,
Justin Haruna2,
Luc Rakotonirina2,
Germain Rakotozafy5,
Laliarisoa Raharimamonjy5,
Sidney Atwood6,
Megan B Murray3,
Michael Rich3,
Tara Loyd2,
Gaêtan Duval Solofomalala5,
http://orcid.org/0000-0002-3055-4237Matthew H Bonds2,3
1MIVEGEC, Univ. Montpellier, CNRS, IRD, Montpellier, France
2PIVOT, Ifanadiana, Madagascar
3Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
4Direction de la Démographie et des Statistiques Sociales, Institut National de la Statistique, Antananarivo, Madagascar
5Ministère de la Santé Publique, Antananarivo, Madagascar
6Division of Global Health Equity, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Correspondence to Dr Andres Garchitorena; andres.garchitorena{at}gmail.com
Introduction Despite renewed commitment to universal health coverage and health system strengthening (HSS) to improve access to primary care, there is insufficient evidence to guide their design and implementation. To address this, we conducted an impact evaluation of an ongoing HSS initiative in rural Madagascar, combining data from a longitudinal cohort and primary health centres.
Methods We carried out a district representative household survey at the start of the HSS intervention in 2014 in over 1500 households in Ifanadiana district, and conducted follow-up surveys at 2 and 4 years. At each time point, we estimated maternal, newborn and child health coverage; economic and geographical inequalities in coverage; and child mortality rates; both in the HSS intervention and control catchments. We used logistic regression models to evaluate changes associated with exposure to the HSS intervention. We also estimated changes in health centre per capita utilisation during 2013 to 2018.
Results Child mortality rates decreased faster in the HSS than in the control catchment. We observed significant improvements in care seeking for children under 5 years of age (OR 1.23; 95% CI 1.05 to 1.44) and individuals of all ages (OR 1.37, 95% CI 1.19 to 1.58), but no significant differences in maternal care coverage. Economic inequalities in most coverage indicators were reduced, while geographical inequalities worsened in nearly half of the indicators.
Conclusion The results demonstrate improvements in care seeking and economic inequalities linked to the early stages of a HSS intervention in rural Madagascar. Additional improvements in this context of persistent geographical inequalities will require a stronger focus on community health.
cohort study
What is already known?
Low- and middle-income countries require substantial investments in health system strengthening (HSS) and universal health coverage (UHC) to reach the health-related Sustainable Development Goals.
There is a major gap in the evidence to inform HSS and UHC policies due to challenges in the assessment of such complex interventions, with cross-benefits at the population level.
After 4 years of integrating HSS activities across all levels of care within a government district, coverage increased by more than 4% per year for all recommended vaccines, for care seeking in children and adults, and for facility birth deliveries.
We also observed overall improvements in maternal care coverage and child mortality rates in the HSS catchment, but differences with the control catchment were modest and not statistically significant.
While economic inequalities in the coverage of most child and maternal health indicators were reduced, geographical inequalities worsened in nearly half of the indicators evaluated.
What do the new findings imply?
HSS interventions can have positive population-level effects by increasing care seeking and reducing economic inequalities, both central goals of UHC policies.
Important gaps in geographical access to care can persist unless public health systems adequately strengthen community health programmes in remote, rural areas.
Our study highlights the value of iterative learning between HSS implementation and impact evaluation, based on the dynamic integration of data and analytics at multiple levels of a health district.
As the world mobilises to develop vaccines and treatments for COVID-19, half of the global population lacks access to the essential health services necessary for preventing and treating the burden of illnesses that have been with us for far longer.1 2 To address this, most countries have renewed their commitment to universal health coverage (UHC) to achieve access to quality primary care for all,3 through policies that tend to focus on demand-side financial coverage; that is, reducing financial barriers to care. Achieving UHC also requires health system strengthening (HSS) to ensure that supply-side factors (eg, staffing, equipment and supplies) are consistently available for the provision of healthcare. The WHO has estimated that nearly three-quarters of all additional investments for low- and middle-income countries between 2015 and 2030 should be allocated to HSS, UHC and other sector-wide approaches, amounting to up to 300 billion US$ (US dollars) per year.4 Though such investments could prevent 97 million premature deaths by 2030,4 there is insufficient evidence to guide the design of national policies aimed to achieve both the demand and supply side of UHC.5–7
A key challenge for generating evidence is that these policies are complex, span multiple levels of the health system and have cross-cutting benefits for population health, especially for vulnerable groups. To account for this, a major focus in global health evaluation involves the follow-up of a comprehensive set of coverage and mortality indicators to measure progress on flagship sector-wide initiatives linked to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).1 8 9 Key priorities of these initiatives are to improve aggregate health outcomes while reducing health inequalities.10–13 Multilateral health organisations such as the WHO and UNICEF have developed toolkits (eg, HEAT and EQUIST) to promote the adoption of equity analyses into national health planning and evaluation.14 15 These macro-level approaches allow progress across countries to be compared, providing insights into which policies may affect change. However, indicators are generally aggregated at the national level and available only every 5 years, creating challenges for inferring causality.16
Local HSS initiatives can offer opportunities to measure changes at more granular temporal and spatial resolutions in better controlled environments. Yet, most assessments of local health system performance still rely on facility-based data about service delivery, which are not representative of coverage at the population level,17 and few initiatives measure their impact on health equity.18–20 Given the complex nature of HSS and UHC, the health district is a key unit of analysis and implementation, but district-level evaluations are still scarce.16 21–24 Even experimental trials that successfully demonstrate impact locally using robust evaluation methods generally fail to scale because the data and information loops necessary to continuously inform scale-up are not integrated with policy.25–28 We accordingly lack evidence from data that are representative at the population level and sufficiently comprehensive to capture the cross-cutting benefits of HSS and UHC initiatives, while simultaneously being granular enough to inform policy and implementation. In this sense, adding adaptive evaluation designs that use robust data collection and analytics (eg, observational and quasi-experimental) in parallel to HSS interventions being implemented across the developing world can generate rigorous evidence while informing the implementation process via dynamic information loops and iterative learning.
Here, we take advantage of an HSS initiative in a rural district of Madagascar, a country with one of the least-funded health systems in the world.29 Starting in 2014, the non-governmental organisation, PIVOT, partnered with the government of Madagascar to establish a model health system in the southeastern district of Ifanadiana. A range of HSS programmes were initiated in a third of the district, ensuring health system readiness, improving clinical programmes and supporting integrated information systems at all levels of care. The first 2 years showed improved quality and coverage of primary care services,30 and declines in child mortality rates.31 The scope of the programmes and geographical footprint are being progressively scaled, and the government of Madagascar has designated Ifanadiana among the districts for piloting the national UHC strategy. Combining surveys from a district-representative longitudinal cohort32 with routine health system data, the goal of this study was to demonstrate how the dynamic integration of granular data and analytics at multiple levels of a health district can be used to evaluate the impact of local HSS initiatives, providing a platform for adaptive implementation. We assessed changes in health system coverage associated with the HSS intervention, with special attention to the evolution of economic and geographical inequity. Explicit information loops between research and implementation via a web-based interface make cohort results accessible to programme managers for operational use throughout the scale-up phase.
Study site and HSS intervention
Ifanadiana is a rural health district of approximately 180 000 people located in the region of Vatovavy-Fitovinany, in southeastern Madagascar. Per Ministry of Public Health (MoPH) norms, Ifanadiana district has one reference hospital, one main primary care health centre (CSB2) for each of its 15 communes (subdivision of a district with ~15 000 people; two additional CSB2s were built in 2016 and 2018), six additional basic health centres for larger communes (CSB1) and one community health site with two community health workers (CHW) for each of its 195 fokontany (subdivision of a commune with ~1000 population). The integrated district-level health system strengthening intervention (referred to as idHSS) carried out by the MoPH-PIVOT partnership is guided by existing MoPH policies and is implemented across all three levels of care in the district (community, health centre and hospital). This intervention (summarised in table 1 and online supplemental table S1) is structured through the integration of clinical programmes, health system 'readiness' and information systems. The clinical programmes include child health, with a focus on malnutrition and integrated management of child illness; maternal and reproductive health; social support; and infectious disease programmes, with a focus on tuberculosis, malaria and emerging diseases. Clinical programmes are implemented throughout community health sites, primary healthcare centres and district hospital (details can be found in33). Readiness includes infrastructure and sanitation, staffing and equipment to improve the quality of care; procurement systems; an ambulance network; trainings, frequent supervision and coaching of health staff. As part of the vision for UHC to increase healthcare access and reduce financial vulnerability, user fees are removed at all levels of care via payments from PIVOT to health facilities on behalf of patients (Section S1 and online supplemental table S2), and social support is provided to vulnerable patients. The core activities in the first 3 years (2014 to 2016) covered four communes with approximately one-third of the population of Ifanadiana (referred to as 'idHSS catchment'). In 2017, idHSS activities expanded to a fifth commune. Some activities such as medical staff recruitments and strengthened information systems spanned the whole district (online supplemental table S1). The idHSS intervention, initially modelled after an earlier experience in HSS in Rwanda,34 35 is being tailored over time in collaboration with the government to respond to coverage gaps and intervention deficiencies identified through an iterative learning process that uses health system and population-level data (online supplemental table S1).
[bmjgh-2020-003647supp001.pdf]
Summary of HSS interventions implemented in Ifanadiana district between 2014 and 2017, classified by building block of HSS* affected
In addition to the idHSS intervention, during this period, the population of Ifanadiana benefited from two other notable programmes that covered both the idHSS catchment area and the rest of the district (referred to as 'control catchment'). The PAUSENS project, funded by the World Bank, provided a basic package of services free of charge in all 13 CSB2 through a voucher system for every woman attending the health centre for antenatal, delivery or postnatal care (first 6 weeks) and children under age 5 with any illness (see Appendix, Section S1).36 The project also included training, support for child vaccination in remote areas and some equipment to health centres. The Mikolo project, funded by USAID, provided support to a network of 150 CHWs in the fokontany further than 5 km from a health centre in eight communes in Ifanadiana, four of which were in the idHSS catchment and four in the control catchment. The project organised annual trainings and periodic supervision, provided some equipment, supplies and an initial stock of medicines to each CHW. For more details, see online supplemental table S1. The main difference between the idHSS catchment and the control catchment was the implementation of the idHSS intervention by the MoPH-PIVOT partnership.
Patient and public involvement
Patients or the public were not involved in the design, conduct, reporting or dissemination plans of our research.
Population survey data: the IHOPE cohort
A longitudinal cohort study known as the Ifanadiana Health Outcomes and Prosperity longitudinal Evaluation (IHOPE), or IHOPE cohort, was initiated in 2014 to obtain demographic, health and socio-economic information from a representative sample of 1600 households in Ifanadiana district over time.32 Questionnaires were mostly adapted from the Demographic and Health Survey (DHS).37 The Madagascar National Institute of Statistics (INSTAT), which implements all major national health surveys in the country, was responsible for data collection, survey coordination, training and oversight. A two-stage sample was used, which stratified the district by the initial idHSS and control catchments. Eighty clusters, half from each stratum, were selected at random from enumeration areas mapped during the 2009 census, and households were then mapped within each cluster. Twenty households were selected at random from each cluster.
The first wave of data collection was conducted between April and May of 2014. Individual face-to-face interviews were conducted with women aged 15 to 49 years and men aged 15 to 59 years (usual residents or visitors) in 1522 of the sampled households (95.1% response rate). The original 1600 households were revisited between August and September of 2016 and again between April and May of 2018; any missing or refused households were replaced with others from the same cluster using a predefined random replacement list. Overall, 1514 households were interviewed during the first follow-up survey in 2016 (94.6% response rate) and 1512 during the second in 2018 (94.5% response rate). All residents, including children, had weight and height measured (or length in the case of infants). Data collected in the questionnaires included, among others, household composition (size, genders and ages); indicators of socio-economic status (education, employment and household durable assets); illness in last 30 days for all household members and care seeking for illness; preventive behaviour (bed net ownership, access to water and sanitation); women's reproductive history and care seeking behaviour for reproductive health; children's health, development and care seeking for illness; adult, maternal and child mortality.
French and Malagasy questionnaires used in the cohort, as well as data collection protocols, were standardised and validated for Madagascar during previous national surveys carried out by INSTAT. All adults (≥15 years) provided verbal consent for the in-person interview and anthropometric measurements. Parents or guardians provided consent for children ≤5 years of age. INSTAT provided survey data to the investigators with all individual identifiers removed and with geographical information at the cluster level. Spatial boundaries of each cluster were made available to the investigators and are stored separately; this information will not be published or shared publicly. Further details on data collection and survey design are available in.32
Health system utilisation data
We obtained data for the period of January 2013 to December 2018 from the MoPH for 13 CSB2 in Ifanadiana district on the number of new individuals per month attending each health centre for outpatient consultations or maternal care. We excluded two CSBs that did not exist for this 6-year period (built in November 2016 and April 2018), as well as the six CSB1 in the district because these lack medical doctors and provide a more limited number of health services. Given that the idHSS intervention started in early 2014 (shortly after the baseline survey) and affected utilisation rates that year, we included health system utilisation data since 2013 in order to have a true baseline before the idHSS intervention. These data were available from the health centres' monthly reports to the district (RMA), which are aggregated from the health centres' registers every month by MoPH staff. As a component of the idHSS intervention, data quality was maintained through joint MoPH-PIVOT supervisions carried out every 3 months at a subset of health centres to compare RMA values with registry data (see38 for more details). Starting in May 2015, the MoPH changed the estimation and reporting of outpatient utilisation rates. Thus, all subsequent utilisation data were gathered directly from the registers to ensure consistent estimates throughout the 2013 to 2018 period. Information on total catchment population for each health centre was obtained from official MoPH records. Consistent with MoPH estimates, catchment population of children under 5 years of age, expected number of pregnant women and expected number of deliveries were set at 18%, 4.5% and 4% of the total catchment population, respectively. Although official population data are sometimes deemed inaccurate, we previously showed that estimating catchment populations using available data for our district from other recognised sources such as WorldPop39 did not change the results of per capita utilisation rates analyses.38
Analysis of coverage and mortality rates from IHOPE cohort data
Under-five mortality at the population-level was estimated using the synthetic life-table method for DHS surveys.40 Under-five mortality was defined as the probability of death before age 60 months per 1000 children born alive. For each survey wave, we used information from the 5 years prior to the survey, which comprised a sample of 4063 children for 2014, 4037 children for 2016 and 3788 children for 2018. From these estimates, absolute and relative changes per year for each indicator and catchment area were estimated in univariate linear models, and these were used to estimate the difference over time between the two areas. In addition to these cross-sectional estimates, the difference in under-five mortality for the 2514 children followed-up over the 4 years was also assessed in each area. From this longitudinal analysis, incidence rates of death per person-year in children under 5 years of age were calculated using a Poisson regression.
Coverage indicators (see list in table 2 and online supplemental table S3) were estimated using standard definitions for DHS surveys.40 Vaccination coverage was defined as the proportion of children aged 12 to 23 months who received all recommended vaccines (three doses of polio and DTP, one dose of BCG and measles). Access to treatment was estimated as the proportion of children under 5 years of age who were ill with fever, acute respiratory infection or diarrhoea in the 2 weeks prior to the survey and sought medical treatment (at a hospital, health centre or community health worker). In order to measure the effect of the idHSS intervention on maternal health service coverage, indicators were estimated for the last pregnancy during the 2 years preceding the survey. In addition, to track a summary indicator of maternal, newborn and child health (MNCH) coverage, we estimated co-coverage indices (three interventions or less; five interventions or more) for women and children under 5 years of age and a modified version of the composite coverage index (CCI)41 that included all standard maternal and child interventions except for family planning, which was not available in the 2014 survey.
Model predictions of annual change in coverage associated with the idHSS intervention and in the rest of Ifanadiana district (control), 2014 to 2018
Coverage and mortality indicators were calculated for 2014, 2016 and 2018 both in the idHSS catchment (which changed over time) and in the control catchment (the rest of the district). Yearly changes in coverage between the idHSS and control catchments were modelled from individual-level data using multivariate logistic mixed regressions that included a random intercept at the cluster level, using the following formula:
Where Yij is the average coverage for yeari and clusterj; catchment reflects whether the household of the individual was part of the initial idHSS catchment to account for baseline differences in these two areas; exposure reflects the number of years of exposure of the cluster to the idHSS intervention to account for the expanding idHSS catchment; β1 is the yearly change in the control catchment, β2 is the baseline difference in utilisation between the initial intervention catchment and the control catchment and β3 is the yearly change associated with the idHSS intervention; bj and εj are the random intercept and error associated with each cluster, respectively. Results were reported as adjusted OR, and as predicted yearly change (using only the model's fixed effects). The 95% CIs for yearly changes were estimated through parametric bootstrap (400 simulations per indicator). Data were entered into CSPro and all analyses were done using R statistical software, V.3.1.242 and R-package lme4 with the exception of population-level mortality rates and associated 95% CIs, which were calculated with SAS 9.3,43 and the observed under-five mortality incidence rate ratios, which were calculated with Stata, V.15.44 Changes of coverage in the initial idHSS catchment area (four communes) and in the control catchment were also estimated and compared using difference-in-difference analyses (online supplemental table S4) for consistency with analyses in our previous 2-year impact evaluation.31 Sampling weights that adjusted for unequal probability of selection due to stratification and non-response were calculated for household, women's and men's surveys. Estimates were obtained using survey commands available in R-package survey and applicable sampling weights.45
Analysis of geographical and economic inequalities in healthcare coverage from IHOPE cohort data
First, changes in the geographical distribution of coverage over time in Ifanadiana were assessed for each indicator. For this, average values for the 80 geographical clusters in the IHOPE cohort were estimated, each of which included 20 households and approximately 100 individuals. Then, given the spatial location of each cluster, a raster surface of the whole district was obtained to improve visualisation of results. This was done through inverse distance weighted interpolation on the empirical Bayes estimates of each cluster, using R-packages spdep and gstat.
Second, trends in economic and geographical inequalities in the idHSS catchment were assessed for each coverage indicator. To estimate economic inequalities, a household wealth index was calculated through a principal components analysis of household assets following standard DHS methods.40 To estimate geographical inequalities, the Open Source Routing Machine (OSRM) engine was used to accurately estimate the shortest path distance between the villages in each cluster and the nearest health centre. For this, we had previously mapped the entire district of Ifanadiana on OpenStreetMap, resulting in over 23 000 km of footpaths and 5000 residential areas mapped (see46 for details). For each indicator, we estimated wealth-specific and geographic-specific averages (bottom two quantiles vs top three quantiles) as well as composite indicators of inequality, such as relative concentration index and slope index of inequality.47 The relative concentration index (RCI) is a measure of relative inequality based on the concentration curve, a plot of the cumulative distribution of each coverage indicator (y-axis) in the population ranked by wealth or geography (x-axis) and adjusted by survey weights.47 The RCI is defined as twice the area between the line of equality (45° diagonal line) and the indicator's concentration curve, and was calculated using R-package decomp.48 The slope index of inequality (SII) is a measure of absolute inequality that represents the difference in coverage between the highest and the lowest values of the wealth or geography rank (normalised between 0 and 1). It was estimated at the individual level as the slope of the health outcome on the individual wealth or geography ranks in a logistic regression, adjusted by survey weights.47 49
Third, trends in self-reported barriers to seek care were estimated in the idHSS and control catchments. For this, individuals of all ages who reported being ill but not seeking care at a healthcare facility in the IHOPE cohort surveys were asked to provide the primary and secondary reason for why they did not seek care. This information was added to the surveys from 2016 onwards, but was not available for 2014. Reasons were classified as no barrier ('not severe enough' or no reason reported), knowledge barrier ('did not think they could help me' and 'did not know that a treatment existed'), health system barrier ('lack of confidence in health staff' and 'health staff often absent'), financial barrier ('impossible to stop work' and 'too expensive') and geographical barrier ('too far away or hard to reach'). Percentages of each barrier reported were estimated out of all primary and secondary reasons.
Analysis of healthcare utilisation from health centre data
For each health centre, we calculated the annual average in per capita utilisation rates for maternal health services (antenatal care, first and fourth visit; deliveries, and postnatal care) and outpatient care for any illness (all patients and children under 5 years of age). We estimated annual changes during the 2013 to 2018 period for health centres in the idHSS and control catchments using mixed logistic regression models equivalent to the analyses of survey data described above (with a random intercept for each health centre).
Development of a web interface for operational use of cohort results
In order to build explicit information feedback loops between the impact evaluation and programme implementation, we developed a user-friendly online application to facilitate use of the IHOPE cohort results by local health staff. It consists of a website interface that builds on the same data sources (ie, IHOPE cohort database) and methods for the estimation of changes in coverage and inequalities as presented in this manuscript, making the visualisation of results flexible and easily accessible by programme managers and decision-makers (in French and English). We used the package Shiny50 for R statistical software. This application is developed and maintained by the PIVOT research team, and hosted at the PIVOT dashboard website (http://research.pivot-dashboard.org/).
Changes in coverage indicators and mortality rates
After 4 years of intervention, under-five mortality decreased in the original idHSS catchment from 104 (95% CI 73 to 135) to 89 deaths (95% CI 57 to 120) per 1000 live births, an average annual relative reduction of 4% (table 3). Infant mortality decreased from 66 (95% CI 40 to 92) to 59 deaths (95% CI 38 to 81) per 1000 live births, an average annual relative reduction of 3%. Neonatal mortality decreased from 47 (95% CI 27 to 68) to 33 deaths (95% CI 16 to 51) per 1000 live births, an average annual relative reduction of 7%. In comparison, infant and neonatal mortality rates increased in the rest of the district, and under-five mortality decreased by an average of only 3%. All three mortality indicators in both areas were higher in 2018 than in 2016, but the gap in mortality rates between the original idHSS and control catchments consistently increased during this period. Differences in mortality rates over time between the two areas were not statistically significant. Complementary to results on 5-year population average mortality rates described above, analyses of incidence rates of death in the 2514 children under 5 years of age followed up between 2014 and 2018 revealed that the incidence rate was 2% per person-year in the idHSS catchment (47 deaths) and 3% per person-year in the control catchment (123 deaths). This represented an incidence rate ratio of 0.6 (95% CI 0.4 to 1.0), with a borderline statistically significantly lower incidence of deaths of children under 5 years of age in the idHSS catchment (p=0.05).
Changes in population-level child mortality rates* in the initial idHSS and control catchments, 2014 to 2018
Reductions in mortality rates were accompanied with improvements in coverage indicators during this period for maternal, child and individual care (figure 1, table 2). The co-coverage index (5+ interventions), a summary index of maternal and child interventions increased by 4% annually in the idHSS catchment, nearly double than in the control catchment (figure 1). Differences between the two areas were particularly large for child coverage indicators, with annual increases in the idHSS catchment 4 to 6 percentage points higher than in the control catchment (vaccine coverage, care seeking for illnesses, ORS (oral rehydration salts) for diarrhoea, care seeking for acute respiratory infection (ARI)), except for care seeking for fever. Improvements in maternal coverage indicators were similar in the two areas for antenatal care (1+ and 4+ visits, annual increase of 3% and 6%, respectively). However, in the idHSS catchment, the proportion of deliveries at health facilities and postnatal care within 48 hours with a skilled provider improved by 3 and 2 percentage points more than in the control catchment, respectively. Care seeking for illness in individuals of all ages increased by nearly 10% per year in the idHSS catchment, compared with only 2% in the control catchment. Despite these positive results, the uncertainty around most of these estimates was high (figure 1). After accounting for baseline differences between the two areas and the average change in the district during this period (table 2), we found that the intervention was only associated with a statistically significant yearly improvement for care seeking for child illness (OR=1.2; 95% CI 1.0 to 1.4), care seeking for child ARI (OR=1.3; 95% CI 1.0 to 1.7) and care seeking for illness in individuals of all ages (OR=1.4; 95% CI 1.2 to 1.6). Model results for the full set of 45 coverage indicators is available in online supplemental table S3, and comparisons between the initial idHSS and control catchments are available in online supplemental table S4.
Annual change in key coverage indicators in Ifanadiana district, 2014 to 2018. Dots represent predictions based on fixed effects of the models described in table 2. Whiskers represent 95% CIs based on 400 bootstrap simulations of the same model. *Estimations for individual care seeking were obtained using 2016 to 2018 data only. ARI,acute respiratory infection,
Changes in health centre utilisation
The evolution of health centre utilisation rates in these two areas (table 4) was consistent with population-coverage results. We observed an increase in utilisation for all primary care services evaluated over the study period. However, the yearly improvement in per capita utilisation associated with the idHSS intervention was larger for outpatient consultations of individuals of all ages (OR=1.31; 95% CI 1.30 to 1.31) and consultations of children under 5 years of age (OR=1.25; 95% CI 1.23 to 1.26) than for any maternal care indicator evaluated.
Model predictions of annual change in health centre utilisation associated with the idHSS intervention and in the rest of Ifanadiana district (control), 2013 to 2018
Changes in geographical and economic inequalities in MNCH coverage
The spatial distribution of coverage in Ifanadiana district improved over time, especially in the idHSS catchment, but significant spatial heterogeneities remained both in the idHSS and control catchments. For instance, healthcare seeking behaviours for childhood illnesses (figure 2) was below 50% everywhere in the idHSS catchment in 2014. Rates increased to 60% to 85% across the idHSS catchment in 2016 and 2018, except for a remote area in one of the intervention communes (centre-right of the map), where populations have to travel over 4 hours by foot each way to reach the nearest health facility.46 In the majority of the control catchment area, healthcare seeking behaviours for childhood illnesses remained consistently below 50% during the study period (figure 2).
Geographical distribution of healthcare seeking behaviours for child illness, 2014 to 2018. It displays for each wave of the cohort the mean proportion of children under 5 years of age who were brought to a public provider (health centre or community health worker) when reported illness in the previous 2 weeks. Administrative limits of the HSS intervention catchment each year are shown in red. Equivalent maps for each indicator evaluated in this study are available through the accompanying Shiny App. HSS, health system strengthening.
Annual change in inequalities for key coverage indicators in HSS intervention catchment, 2014 to 2018. Q1-Q2 and Q3-Q5 represent the change in the two worst-off and three best-off quantiles respectively. RCI and SII represent the change in relative concentration index (measure of relative inequality) and in slope index of inequality (measure of absolute inequality). Colour scale is based on scaled values for each variable, with red representing a worsening over time (reduction in quantile coverage, increase in inequalities) and green representing an improvement. Details are available in online supplemental tables S5 and S6). *Estimations for individual care seeking were obtained using 2016 to 2018 data only. ARI, acute respiratory infection; HSS, health system strengthening; ineq., inequalities; RCI, relative concentration index; SII, slope index of inequality.
The idHSS intervention implemented by the MoPH-PIVOT partnership was associated with reductions in economic and geographical inequalities for most indicators assessed (figure 3, online supplemental tables S5 and S6). Annual increase in coverage in the poorest two quantiles ranged from 0.6 to 12.4 percentage points. Both absolute and relative economic inequalities were reduced for all indicators except for antenatal care (1+ and 4+ visits). The largest reductions in absolute economic inequality were observed for child vaccination and care seeking for individuals of all ages (SII change of nearly −10 per year). Results for geographical inequalities were mixed. We observed a generalised improvement in coverage for populations living further from a health centre and an associated reduction in relative geographical inequalities. However, absolute improvements in coverage were larger in populations living close to a health centre for nearly half of the indicators assessed, leading to an increase in absolute geographical inequalities (SII), with annual changes ranging from −7.1 to +7.3. The indicators with the largest reductions in absolute geographical inequalities were child vaccination coverage, antenatal care (1+ visits) and birth delivered by C-section (SII change larger than +4 per year).
Analyses of inequalities were consistent with self-reported barriers to access health facilities by individuals who did not seek care following an illness (available only for 2016 to 2018). Reported financial barriers in the idHSS catchment more than halved (from 33% to 15%), while geographical barriers remained constant at 20% of responses (figure 4). Overall, reported barriers for not accessing care decreased by more than one-third in the idHSS catchment. In contrast, reported barriers only decreased by less than 15% in the control catchment, and the percentage of responses involving financial barriers barely changed during this period, remaining at about one-third of responses.
Reported reasons for not seeking care at a health facility, 2016 to 2018. It displays the percentage of responses out of all primary and secondary reasons that household members provided when they reported being ill in the previous 4 weeks but not seeking treatment at a health facility.
Information loops between impact evaluation and implementation: the IHOPE dashboard
Cohort results have been integral to the tailoring of the ongoing idHSS intervention, highlighting gaps in coverage or quality of care, insufficient progress in particular health programmes and potential solutions to address them. Though evaluation results are presented to managers and leadership of the MoPH-PIVOT partnership as they become available, there were inherent challenges in the routine use of this information. A user-friendly web interface is now accessible to programme managers in Ifanadiana district (figure 5), allowing visualisation of key information for over 40 coverage indicators from the IHOPE cohort for the planning and implementation of health interventions. These population-level results, available at granular temporal and spatial scales across Ifanadiana district, provide a breadth of information for iterative learning, complementary to more traditional dashboards of routine health system data. The IHOPE dashboard includes trends in coverage over time in Ifanadiana district, comparisons by intervention catchment and by commune; changes in economic and geographical inequalities; and spatial distribution of coverage over time. Information is updated every 2 years, and the number of indicators included will be progressively expanded to encompass most aspects of the idHSS intervention.
Web interface for operational use of cohort results by local health managers. Illustrative example of the interface available at http://research.pivot-dashboard.org/. It shows an analysis of child mortality indicators (under 5 years of age, infant and neonatal mortality) over time, in the idHSS catchment (solid line) and in the control catchment (dashed line). Top panels show trends in mortality between 2014 and 2018, while middle and bottom panels show absolute and relative change during the same period, respectively. HSS, health system strengthening; idHSS, integrated district-level health system strengthening; IHOPE, Ifanadiana Health Outcomes and Prosperity longitudinal Evaluation.
In the coming decades, low- and middle-income countries will need to allocate substantial investments to HSS and UHC in order to achieve the health-related SDGs.4 Yet, there is still a substantial gap in the evidence to inform this shift due to challenges in the assessment of such complex interventions, with cross-benefits at the population level.5 28 We analysed changes in healthcare utilisation, coverage and mortality in a district-representative longitudinal cohort to assess the impact of the first 4 years of an ongoing idHSS initiative in a rural district of Madagascar. Our results reveal improvements in care seeking and economic inequalities, both central goals of UHC policies. Coverage increased by more than 4% per year for all recommended vaccines, for care seeking in children and adults and for facility birth deliveries, even in the poorest economic groups. Despite improvements in all coverage and mortality indicators in the idHSS catchment, only care seeking for children and adults were statistically significantly associated with the idHSS intervention. Differences with the rest of the district for maternal care coverage and under-five mortality rates were modest and non-significant. The persistence of geographical inequalities in access to care observed in the idHSS catchment highlights potential solutions for optimising the impact of HSS interventions, such as substantial investments in outreach activities and community health. More broadly, our study highlights the value of iterative learning between HSS implementation and impact evaluation, based on the dynamic integration of data and analytics at multiple levels of a health district.
Ensuring universal access to essential maternal and child health services via UHC packages and HSS is a strategic priority of the United Nations' Every Woman Every Child Global Strategy.8 We show that in 4 years of intervention, coverage in the idHSS catchment improved faster than what has been observed globally, catching up with the global median coverage for most indicators of child care coverage (eg, ORS for diarrhoea, care seeking for acute respiratory infections, immunisations and so on).51 The idHSS intervention had the largest effects on care seeking for illness, not only for children but also for individuals of all ages, with annual relative improvements of 30% to 40%. This has led to an annual increase in health centre utilisation associated with the idHSS intervention of 25% in children and 31% in individuals of all ages, tripling utilisation rates in the control catchment by 2018. Yet, there remained substantial gaps for most maternal care indicators as compared with global trends. For instance, despite an annual increase of over 4 percentage points in recommended antenatal care visits (4+), coverage in 2018 was 20 percentage points lower than the 73% median global coverage.51 In addition, we observed significant district-level improvements over time in prenatal, delivery and postnatal care, but the idHSS intervention was not associated with an additional increase. Similarly, annual changes in maternal care visits at health centres in the idHSS intervention were consistently lower than improvements observed for outpatient visits. Implementation of a World Bank voucher programme targeting pregnant women in the whole district and a limited focus on maternal health activities in the idHSS catchment could partly explain these trends. As the World Bank programme ends and components of the idHSS intervention are expanded to the whole district in 2020 for the UHC pilot, changes in intervention coverage will be closely tracked through the IHOPE study to inform local implementation and national policies.
We observed increases in intervention coverage for the most vulnerable population groups and associated reductions in inequalities. Coverage of maternal and child services in the poorest two quantiles increased by 2 to 10 percentage points per year, substantially higher than the 0.5% to 1.5% median increase observed for low-income countries.52 This gap remains when comparing summary indices such as the CCI in worst-off groups, as the annual improvement in the idHSS catchment (2.9%; online supplemental table S5) was nearly three times higher than the average for low-income countries.53 Our local results provide a more positive picture than equivalent national analyses in countries undergoing UHC and other health reforms, which showed mixed results in addressing wealth inequalities.11–13 While Ghana observed progressive convergence between groups,12 inequalities persisted in Kenya and Rwanda.11 13 Among all the indicators assessed in our setting, antenatal care (4+ visits) was the only one for which both economic and geographical inequalities increased. This is consistent with a recent analysis of 84 national surveys, showing that wealth inequalities for recommended antenatal care visits (4+) still persist across geographical regions.10
Our study highlights the added value of integrating analyses of geographical inequalities into evaluations of UHC policies and HSS programmes to better assess their impact on remote populations. Although equity analyses are becoming commonplace, these have focussed so far on assessing inequalities in wealth, education and place of residence (rural vs urban).10–13 52 53 Impact evaluations rarely assess changes in geographical inequalities, even though it is well established that primary healthcare utilisation decreases exponentially for populations living at increasing distance of health facilities.54–58 In our setting, inequalities in geographical coverage were harder to address than economic inequalities, with half of indicators showing an increasing gap in absolute inequalities as a function of distance to a health facility. This is consistent with previous evidence suggesting that geographical barriers to primary healthcare can persist even in settings where user fees have been removed, making UHC policies insufficient to reach full population coverage of primary care services unless explicitly targeting remote populations.18–20 This type of analysis could be key in evaluating progress towards geographical equity as professionalised community health programmes and proactive community case management become part of broader HSS efforts.59 60
Despite improvements in health coverage and reductions in inequalities, child mortality trends observed in the idHSS catchment were lower than initially estimated in our 2-year evaluation.31 We observed annual reductions of under-five mortality rates comparable to national averages in the top 40% of countries tracked by the Countdown to 2015 initiative in 1990 to 2015.61 Decreases in neonatal mortality were larger, as the change in the idHSS catchment during this 4-year period (from 47 to 33 deaths per 1000 live births) was almost equivalent to the decrease observed in sub-Saharan Africa in nearly three decades (from 46 to 27 deaths per 1000 live births between 1990 and 2017).62 The gap between the idHSS catchment and the rest of the district increased for infant and neonatal mortality, as these rates increased from 2014 to 2018 in the control catchment. However, even the idHSS catchment experienced small increases in mortality rates from 2016 to 2018. It is possible that after an initial sudden impact in both coverage and mortality due to user-fee removals and other early programmes, further reductions in mortality rates may not be accomplished unless geographical coverage is improved. A pilot community health programme implementing proactive care is underway in one district's commune and will be scaled to the rest of the idHSS catchment if shown effective. This, among other programmes addressing persistent geographical barriers in Ifanadiana, could contribute to accelerating reductions in child mortality.
The modest impacts that we observed on maternal care and child mortality indicators could be due to a range of factors related to intrinsic effectiveness of the interventions, fidelity of implementation or persistent barriers for accessing care. A key component of this study was to build feedback mechanisms between research and implementation so that results are available to programme managers for operational use. This will ensure that any issues identified during the impact evaluation can be addressed in a timely manner. Typically, experimental trials provide insights on whether a pilot intervention works using randomised controlled designs, whereas implementation research explores how, when and why the intervention works, making use of a variety of study designs, from quantitative to qualitative research.63 64 Here, we use an intermediate approach by combining a quasi-experimental design with a comprehensive set of population-level analyses at very granular spatial and temporal resolutions. Insights generated through the IHOPE cohort have influenced the design and implementation of the idHSS intervention over time. For instance, while the idHSS intervention was initially focussed on facility-based care, results on geographical access to care led a substantial shift towards strengthening community health programmes, which is currently evolving towards proactive care delivery given persistent geographical inequalities. Similarly, lags in maternal care improvements in the idHSS catchment have pushed new efforts by the MoPH-PIVOT partnership ever since, including implementation of emergency neonatal and obstetric care trainings, distribution of equipment, incentives for pregnant women to deliver at facilities (eg, social kits and waiting homes) and outreach activities for the provision of antenatal care at the community level. Visualisation of impact evaluation results into e-health tools could help further decentralise and accelerate this process, allowing programme managers to prioritise and plan activities over time to optimise coverage of key indicators. This approach is increasingly used in global health, with prior applications for malaria surveillance and health equity.14 65 66
Although frequent waves of population-level data collection allow for better granularity and important programmatic insights, the short time interval since the beginning of the idHSS intervention in combination with limitations of our quasi-experimental study design could also have prevented us from detecting significant impacts at this point. First, estimations of population-level child mortality were based on 5-year estimates to attain adequate sample sizes, leading to overlap in the mortality results, which were reported at 2-year intervals. Despite this, CIs were still wide, which may explain the inconsistent trends observed in the 4-year period. Allowing for longer evaluation periods will lead to progressively better estimates of intervention impact on mortality rates, with long-term trends less sensitive to variability in particular years. Second, we used two slightly different idHSS catchment populations in our analyses, to accommodate limitations in the methodology. While analyses of coverage and utilisation indicators allowed for changes in the idHSS catchment over time to include an additional commune in 2017, this was not possible for estimating inequalities or child mortality; these used the initial idHSS versus control catchment comparison for the whole study period. Third, the effects of HSS programmes could be non-linear (online supplemental figure S2), but given the short time frame of the study we only studied annualised linear effects. Finally, the process of implementing the idHSS intervention is not discrete and immediate, it is gradually being implemented and involves many simultaneous programmes at different levels of the health system. As a result, while we can infer an overall intervention impact, it is not possible to accurately estimate the effect of particular components of the intervention, some of which could have effects district-wide.
In conclusion, we show how the combination of a district-representative longitudinal cohort and health system data can help assess complex HSS interventions. The results demonstrate improvements in care seeking behaviours and economic inequalities linked to the early stages of an idHSS intervention in a rural district of Madagascar. Additional improvements in intervention coverage and child mortality in this context of persistent geographical inequalities will likely require a stronger focus on community health and last mile interventions. As the district moves on to pilot the national UHC strategy, use of this granular evaluation results via accessible, interactive e-health tools can be key for informing national implementation of UHC policies throughout the scale-up process.
The authors acknowledge the contributions and support of Jim Herrnstein, Robin Herrnstein and Benjamin Andriamihaja. They are grateful to all of the staff at PIVOT for their field support and their remarkable work in strengthening the health system in Ifanadiana. Thanks are due to the Madagascar Ministry of Health, at both the district and the central levels, for their continuous support and valuable insights. The authors also thank the Institut National de la Statistique (INSTAT) field teams for their involvement in the district-wide population survey.
World Health Organization and the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development / The World Bank
. Tracking universal health coverage: 2017 global monitoring report, 2017.
GBD 2016 SDG Collaborators
. Measuring progress and projecting attainment on the basis of past trends of the health-related sustainable development goals in 188 countries: an analysis from the global burden of disease study 2016. Lancet 2017;390:1423–59.doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(17)32336-Xpmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28916366
. Declaration of Astana. Geneva, Switzerland, 2018.
Stenberg K,
Hanssen O,
Edejer TT-T, et al
. Financing transformative health systems towards achievement of the health sustainable development goals: a model for projected resource needs in 67 low-income and middle-income countries. Lancet Glob Health 2017;5:e875–87.doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(17)30263-2
Giedion U,
Alfonso EA,
Díaz Y
. The impact of universal coverage schemes in the developing world: a review of the existing evidence. Washington DC: UNICO Studies Series, 2013. siteresources.worldbank.org/./IMPACTofUHCSchemesinDevelopingCountries-ARev
Atun RA,
Bennett S,
Duran A
. When do vertical (stand-alone) programmes have a place in health systems? WHO Eur Minist Conf Heal Syst, 2008: 1–28. http://www.who.int/management/district/services/WhenDoVerticalProgrammesPlaceHealthSystems.pdf
Hatt L,
Johns B,
Connor C, et al
. Impact of health systems strengthening on health. Bethesda, MD: Health Finance and Governance Project, Abt Associates Inc, 2015.
WHO, UNAIDS, UNFPA, UNICEF, UNWomen TWBG
. Survive, Thrive, Transform. Global Strategy for Women's, Children's and Adolescents' Health: 2018 report on progress towards 2030 targets, 2018. Available: https://www.who.int/life-course/partners/global-strategy/gswcah-monitoring-report-2018.pdf?ua=1%0Ahttp://www.unaids.org/en/resources/documents/2018/EWECGSMonitoringReport2018
Hogan DR,
Stevens GA,
Hosseinpoor AR, et al
. Monitoring universal health coverage within the sustainable development goals: development and baseline data for an index of essential health services. Lancet Glob Health 2018;6:e152–68.doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(17)30472-2pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29248365
Sully EA,
Biddlecom AS,
Darroch JE
. Not all inequalities are equal: differences in coverage across the continuum of reproductive health services. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e001695–11.doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2019-001695pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31544002
Keats EC,
Akseer N,
Bhatti Z, et al
. Assessment of inequalities in coverage of essential reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health interventions in Kenya. JAMA Netw Open 2018;1:e185152. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2018.5152pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30646326
Zhang C,
Rahman MS,
Rahman MM, et al
. Trends and projections of universal health coverage indicators in Ghana, 1995-2030: a national and subnational study. PLoS One 2019;14:e0209126–19.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0209126pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31116754
Liu K,
Subramanian SV,
Lu C
. Assessing national and subnational inequalities in medical care utilization and financial risk protection in Rwanda. Int J Equity Health 2019;18:1–10.doi:10.1186/s12939-019-0953-y
Hosseinpoor AR,
Schlotheuber A,
Nambiar D, et al
. Health equity assessment toolkit plus (heat plus): software for exploring and comparing health inequalities using uploaded datasets. Glob Health Action 2018;11:20–30.doi:10.1080/16549716.2018.1440783pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29974823
Uneke CJ,
Sombie I,
Uro-Chukwu HC, et al
. Using equitable impact sensitive tool (EQUIST) to promote implementation of evidence informed policymaking to improve maternal and child health outcomes: a focus on six West African countries. Global Health 2018;14:1–16.doi:10.1186/s12992-018-0422-1
Victora CG,
Black RE,
Boerma JT, et al
. Measuring impact in the millennium development goal era and beyond: a new approach to large-scale effectiveness evaluations. Lancet 2011;377:85–95.doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(10)60810-0pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20619886
Bresick G,
Christians F,
Makwero M, et al
. Primary health care performance: a scoping review of the current state of measurement in Africa. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e001496. doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2019-001496
Nguyen HT,
Zombré D,
Ridde V, et al
. The impact of reducing and eliminating user fees on facility-based delivery: a controlled interrupted time series in Burkina Faso. Health Policy Plan 2018;33:948–56.doi:10.1093/heapol/czy077pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30256941
De Allegri M,
Ridde V,
Louis VR, et al
. Determinants of utilisation of maternal care services after the reduction of user fees: a case study from rural Burkina Faso. Health Policy 2011;99:210–8.doi:10.1016/j.healthpol.2010.10.010pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21056505
Mills S,
Williams JE,
Adjuik M, et al
. Use of health professionals for delivery following the availability of free obstetric care in northern Ghana. Matern Child Health J 2008;12:509–18.doi:10.1007/s10995-007-0288-ypmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17955355
Requejo JH,
Bryce J,
Barros AJD, et al
. Countdown to 2015 and beyond: fulfilling the health agenda for women and children. Lancet 2015;385:466–76.doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(14)60925-9pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/24990815
Reidy WJ,
Rabkin M,
Syowai M, et al
. Patient-Level and program-level monitoring and evaluation of differentiated service delivery for HIV: a pragmatic and parsimonious approach is needed. AIDS 2018;32:399–401.doi:10.1097/QAD.0000000000001723pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29239898
Verguet S,
Feldhaus I,
Jiang Kwete X,
Kwete J, et al
. Health system modelling research: towards a whole-health-system perspective for identifying good value for money investments in health system strengthening. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e001311–5.doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2018-001311pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31139448
Tumusiime P,
Kwamie A,
Akogun OB, et al
. Towards universal health coverage: reforming the neglected district health system in Africa. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e001498. doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2019-001498pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31681483
Phillips JF,
Awoonor-Williams JK,
Bawah AA, et al
. What do you do with success? the science of scaling up a health systems strengthening intervention in Ghana. BMC Health Serv Res 2018;18:1–10.doi:10.1186/s12913-018-3250-3
Meessen B,
Akhnif ELH,
Kiendrébéogo JA, et al
. Learning for universal health coverage. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e002059–6.doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2019-002059
Robert E,
Rajan D, et al
. Realist evaluation of the role of the universal health coverage partnership in strengthening policy dialogue for health planning and financing: a protocol. BMJ Open 2019;9:e022345–9.doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2018-022345
Witter S,
Palmer N,
Balabanova D, et al
. Health system strengthening-Reflections on its meaning, assessment, and our state of knowledge. Int J Health Plann Manage 2019;34:e1980–9.doi:10.1002/hpm.2882pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31386232
. World bank open data, 2019. Available: http://data.worldbank.org [Accessed 20 Dec 2019].
Ezran C,
Bonds MH,
Miller AC, et al
. Assessing trends in the content of maternal and child care following a health system strengthening initiative in rural Madagascar: a longitudinal cohort study. PLoS Med 2019;16:e1002869–23.doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1002869pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31430286
Garchitorena A,
Miller AC,
Cordier LF, et al
. Early changes in intervention coverage and mortality rates following the implementation of an integrated health system intervention in Madagascar. BMJ Glob Health 2018;3:e000762. doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2018-000762pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29915670
Rabeza V, et al
. Cohort profile: Ifanadiana health outcomes and prosperity longitudinal evaluation (IHOPE). Int J Epidemiol 2018;47:1394–5.doi:10.1093/ije/dyy099pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29939260
Cordier L, et al
. Advancing a science of sustaining health: a new platform for a model district in Madagascar. bioRxiv 2017.doi:10.1101/141549
Thomson DR,
Amoroso C,
Atwood S, et al
. Impact of a health system strengthening intervention on maternal and child health outputs and outcomes in rural Rwanda 2005–2010. BMJ Glob Health 2018;3:e000674. doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2017-000674
Rich ML
. Integrated health system strengthening can generate rapid population impacts that can be replicated: lessons from Rwanda to Madagascar. BMJ Glob Health 2018;3:e000976. doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2018-000976pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30294462
. Emergency support to critical education, health and nutrition services project, 2012.
International ICF
. Survey organization. Calverton, Maryland USA: Manual for Demographic and Health Surveys, 2012.
. In Madagascar, use of health care services increased when fees were removed: lessons for universal health coverage. Health Aff 2017;36:1443–51.doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2016.1419pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28784737
. Madagascar 100m population, version 2. University of Southampton, 2017.
Rutstein SO,
Rojas G
. Guide to DHS statistics. demographic and health surveys methodology. Calverton, Maryland USA, 2006.
Wehrmeister FC,
Restrepo-Mendez M-C,
Franca GV, et al
. Summary indices for monitoring universal coverage in maternal and child health care. Bull World Health Organ 2016;94:903–12.doi:10.2471/BLT.16.173138pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27994283
R Development Core Team
. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna, Austria: R Foundation for Statistical Computing, 2011. http://www.r-project.org/
SAS Institute
. Sas software: version 9.3. Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc, 2011.
StataCorp
. STATA statistical software: release 15. College Station, TX: StataCorp LP, 2015.
Lumley T
. Complex surveys : a guide to analysis using R. John Wiley, 2010.
Ihantamalala FA,
Herbreteau V,
Révillion C, et al
. Improving geographical accessibility modeling for operational use by local health actors. Int J Health Geogr 2020;19:27. doi:10.1186/s12942-020-00220-6pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32631348
Barros AJD,
Victora CG
. Measuring coverage in MNCH: determining and interpreting inequalities in coverage of maternal, newborn, and child health interventions. PLoS Med 2013;10:e1001390. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001390pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23667332
Konings P,
Speybroeck N
. decomp: various functions to quantify and decompose health inequalities. R package version 0.3/r6, 2009. Available: http://r-forge.r-project.org/projects/decomp/
Harper S,
Lynch J
. Methods for measuring cancer disparities: using data relevant to healthy people 2010 cancer-related objectives. NCI cancer surveillance monograph series, number 6. Bethesda, MD: National Cancer Institute, 2005. http://seer.cancer.gov/publications/disparities2/HealthDisparities2.pdf
Winston C,
Cheng J,
Allaire J, et al
. Shiny: web application framework for R, 2019.
Requejo J,
Diaz T,
Park L, et al
. Assessing coverage of interventions for reproductive, maternal, newborn, child, and adolescent health and nutrition. BMJ 2020;368:l6915.doi:10.1136/bmj.l6915pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31983681
. Global health Observatory (GHO) data. inequality in reproductive, maternal newborn and child health, 2020.
França GVA, et al
. The contribution of poor and rural populations to national trends in reproductive, maternal, newborn, and child health coverage: analyses of cross-sectional surveys from 64 countries. Lancet Glob Health 2017;5:e402–7.doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(17)30077-3pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28238719
Feikin DR,
Nguyen LM,
Adazu K, et al
. The impact of distance of residence from a peripheral health facility on pediatric health utilisation in rural Western Kenya. Trop Med Int Health 2009;14:54–61.doi:10.1111/j.1365-3156.2008.02193.xpmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19021892
McLaren ZM,
Ardington C,
Leibbrandt M
. Distance decay and persistent health care disparities in South Africa. BMC Health Serv Res 2014;14:1–9.doi:10.1186/s12913-014-0541-1pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/25367330
Gething PW,
Johnson FA,
Frempong-Ainguah F, et al
. Geographical access to care at birth in Ghana: a barrier to safe motherhood. BMC Public Health 2012;12:1. doi:10.1186/1471-2458-12-991
Noor AM,
Zurovac D,
Hay SI, et al
. Defining equity in physical access to clinical services using geographical information systems as part of malaria planning and monitoring in Kenya. Trop Med Int Health 2003;8:917–26.doi:10.1046/j.1365-3156.2003.01112.xpmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14516303
Stock R
. Distance and the utilization of health facilities in rural Nigeria. Soc Sci Med 1983;17:563–70.doi:10.1016/0277-9536(83)90298-8
. Who guideline on health policy and system support to optimize community health worker programmes. Geneva, 2018.
Whidden C,
Thwing J,
Gutman J, et al
. Proactive case detection of common childhood illnesses by community health workers: a systematic review. BMJ Glob Health 2019;4:e001799–18.doi:10.1136/bmjgh-2019-001799pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31908858
. Countdown to 2015: a decade of tracking progress for maternal, newborn, and child survival. Lancet 2016;387:2049–59.doi:10.1016/S0140-6736(15)00519-Xpmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26477328
Hug L,
Alexander M,
You D, et al
. National, regional, and global levels and trends in neonatal mortality between 1990 and 2017, with scenario-based projections to 2030: a systematic analysis. Lancet Glob Health 2019;7:e710–20.doi:10.1016/S2214-109X(19)30163-9pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31097275
Kruk ME,
Yamey G,
Angell SY, et al
. Transforming global health by improving the science of scale-up. PLoS Biol 2016;14:e1002360. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.1002360pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26934704
Bhattacharyya O,
Reeves S,
Zwarenstein M
. What is implementation research? Res Soc Work Pract 2009;19:491–502.doi:10.1177/1049731509335528
Girond F,
Randrianasolo L,
Randriamampionona L, et al
. Analysing trends and forecasting malaria epidemics in Madagascar using a sentinel surveillance network: a web-based application. Malar J 2017;16:72. doi:10.1186/s12936-017-1728-9pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28193215
Nambiar D,
Schlotheuber A, et al
. Health equity assessment toolkit (heat): software for exploring and comparing health inequalities in countries. BMC Med Res Methodol 2016;16:141. doi:10.1186/s12874-016-0229-9pmid:http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27760520
Handling editor Seye Abimbola
Contributors Conceived and designed the experiments: AG, ACM, MB. Performed the analysis: AG, ACM, MauR. Contributed reagents/materials/data/analysis tools: AG, ACM, MarR, H-TRR, BR. Wrote the initial draft of the manuscript: AG, ACM, KEF, MB. Revised the manuscript and accepted it in its final form: AG, ACM, LC, MarR, H-TRR, MauR, BR, KEF, JH, LuR, GR, LaR, SA, MBM, MLR, TL, GDS, MB.
Funding This study was funded by the Herrnstein Family Foundation.
Map disclaimer The depiction of boundaries on this map does not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of BMJ (or any member of its group) concerning the legal status of any country, territory, jurisdiction or area or of its authorities. This map is provided without any warranty of any kind, either express or implied.
Competing interests Some authors are current or former employees of institutions discussed in this article, including the non-governmental organisation PIVOT and the Government of Madagascar. These affiliations are explicitly listed in the article.
Patient consent for publication Not required.
Data availability statement Data are available upon request to the address research@pivotworks.org.


How can I earn free driving minutes with GoTo?
GoTo car sharing is offering a great opportunity to get driving minutes, whilst spreading the word about the new environmental-friendly car sharing service. It's a sure win-win for you, your friends and family.
So, how can you benefit from free car sharing minutes already?
First, you will need to be a registered car sharing member and user of GoTo cars. To register, you simply go to our website at www.join.goto.com.mt and fill in the registration form. You will be asked to submit a valid driving license, personal information and a credit/debit card details.
Once your details are verified and your license is validated, you will be given a GoTo car sharing account. The verification process might take up to 24 hours.
You will then be able to access this on-the-go using the GoTo app that all members can use to find and access the GoTo electric car fleet. Once you're up and running and start using the service, you can join our referral programme. This allows you to refer a friend to GoTo.
Then your friend will need to register as a GoTo member with a promo code you will share and get their license validated too. Once your friend makes their first paid drive, you and your friend will both get €10 credit for driving (if you are a Standard Plan user)!
Yes, a €10 credit for every person you convince to try our services. Start referring your friends now by logging into your GoTo app and clicking on the 'Get Free Rides' button. Just share a promo code via email, message or Whatsapp. Enjoy driving for free with the GoTo Referral Programme!


President Donald Trump overhauled the Department of Homeland Security this week, ousting - among others - the department's head, Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen. The changes Trump is making appear to stem from his ongoing frustration about the number of migrants seeking entry into the United States, a surge in recent months that Nielsen was unable to address.
With the administration's renewed focus on the issue, it's worth walking through how the process works, where increases in applicants have been seen and what comes next in the eyes of the law - and in the eyes of the president.
The immediate source of Trump's frustration is the increase in migrants arriving at the border with Mexico. When Trump first took office, the number of migrants dropped and so, therefore, did the number of migrants being apprehended at the border, a drop that Trump celebrated as a validation of his policies.
The number of migrants seeking asylum in the U.S. has increased in recent years, as data from the Department of Justice show. There are two types of application - one granted by Citizenship and Immigration Services, called "affirmative," and one made by a migrant otherwise facing deportation, "defensive." The spike has largely been in the number of defensive applications.
As The Post reported in 2018, to seek asylum in the United States, a migrant has to actually be on U.S. soil. So migrants enter the country either by crossing the border between established border checkpoints - an illegal crossing - or by showing up at one of those checkpoints, called a port of entry. Then, they announce their intent to seek asylum. The long-standing image of migrants entering illegally to surreptitiously make their way further into the country is somewhat outdated; now, migrants often turn themselves in immediately.
More of those removal orders have been issued in absentia - ordered by the judge without the migrant in attendance at the hearing. Few of those, however, are cases in which the process began with an approved credible-fear claim, according to Justice Department data.
But he went further, claiming that the "country is full" - which is neither literally nor figuratively true. In fact, Census Bureau data released last December showed that, since 2010, net immigration from outside the U.S. increased in every state by 2018.
The real threat is the specter of a sitting president wielding emergency powers to implement a public policy he can't persuade Congress, let alone the public, to support.


As part of our commitment to providing our members with educational and career growth opportunities, SMPS Boston is proud to offer a range of scholarship opportunities for members at different career levels.
SMPS Boston is proud to offer a scholarship to attend the SMPS National Conference. Known as the Build Business Conference, the national conference brings together A/E/C firm leaders, marketers, and business developers. The SMPS Boston Build Business Scholarship covers the full cost of registration.
Download the scholarship application here. Applications are due June 21, 2019. Scholarship recipients will be notified by June 28, 2019.
SMPS Boston is proud to offer need-based scholarships to help our members become Certified Professional Services Marketers (CPSM). If you are an SMPS Boston member, and your company does not cover the cost of the application and CPSM exam testing fees, SMPS Boston is here to help!
Download the scholarship application here; submissions are accepted on a rolling basis.
SMPS Boston is proud to offer need-based scholarships to help our Certified Professional Services Marketers (CPSMs) ascend to Fellows status (FSMPS). If you are an SMPS Boston member, and your company does not cover the cost of the Fellows application ($250.00), SMPS Boston is here to help!
Download the scholarship application here; submissions are accepted anytime prior to the Fellows application deadline established by SMPS.
SMPS Boston is committed to providing extreme value to our members. One way we do this is by offering up to three scholarships for SMPS Boston members to attend the SMPS Northeast Regional Conference (NERC). Apply today to join 350+ A/E/C firm leaders, marketers, and business developers for three days of learning, networking, and inspiration.
The scholarship application deadline for the 2019 SMPS NERC conference has passed. Check back in 2020 for 2020 SMPS NERC scholarship opportunities.


Crossovers and SUVs are making a comeback in America as fuel prices continue to hit new lows for this decade. SUVs are reliable, powerful, and, surprisingly, efficient—making them wonderful vehicles to own. Here are a few of the benefits of owning an SUV.
If you have a larger family or a more active lifestyle, you'll appreciate the extra space afforded by SUVs. Take the Kia Sorento, for instance, which offers up to 154.2 cubic feet of passenger volume and 122.3 cubic feet of cargo volume (seven-passenger models). This spaciousness makes long road trips with the kids a piece of cake.
SUVs, for their sheer size, already have a leg up on smaller cars in terms of safety. And thanks to advances in safety technology, visibility, which used to be a pain point for SUVs, is a thing of the past. Take for example the Kia Niro, which offers Kia Drive Wise, Kia's suite of available driver assist technologies. Active and passive safety features abound in SUVs, making them perfect for transporting your most precious cargo: your family.
Gas prices may be dropping, but you still don't want to have to shell out more than you need to. In recent years, crossovers and SUVs have become incredibly efficient as gas-powered models, but automakers are also offering hybrid and electric variants for improved efficiency. In Kia's lineup, you'll find the Kia Niro Hybrid and the Soul EV.
Are you in the market for a new SUV? Visit Evansville Kia today for a test drive.


Relax and enjoy the outstanding views and simplicity of a lakefront vacation. This delightful cottage offers a wonderful opportunity for a family summer getaway. Lake Bomoseen welcomes all sorts of recreation including boating, sailing, kayaking and hiking; with restaurants, shopping and golf all within minutes by land or water.
Just a short drive from Rutland, Burlington or Albany, Lake Bomoseen is sure to provide your family with a fun and memorable vacation. Measuring 9 miles long and 2 miles wide, Lake Bomoseen is more manageable than either Lake Champlain or Lake George. These camps are a wonderful blend of rustic tranquility and modern conveniences. I look forward to sharing this beautiful location with you and your family.


Sliquid Buck Angel's T-Lube is a water based lubricant created specifically for transsexual men, as a response to Buck's own experiences.
Sliquid Buck Angel's T-Lube is a water based lubricant created specifically for transsexual men as a response to Buck's own experiences. It is formulated to aid those suffering from regular or periodic dryness by providing a long-lasting natural glide that is designed to enhance your body's own natural lubrication. T-Lube is a proprietary blend of natural moisturizers and extracts, including organic aloe vera, Carrageenan, and vitamin E. T-Lube, like all Sliquid products, does not contain any glycerine, parabens, DEA, or sulfates. and is always 100% vegan-friendly. It is ideal for daily moisturizing.


text:
RD.COM Holidays & Observances Memorial Day
Here's Why the Poppy Is a Symbol of Memorial Day
Chloë NannestadUpdated: Aug. 11, 2021
Leonid Korchenko/Getty Images
Memorial Day poppies appear every year and raise funds for a great cause. But what is the history behind wearing one of these red flowers?
The red poppy, or Remembrance Poppy, has been a symbol of lives lost to war since World War I (1914–1918), and it plays a big part in the history of Memorial Day. Sales of red poppies benefit veterans associations and fund many charities and veterans causes. The poppy is worn in many of the countries that were Allied during World War I, including Great Britain, France, Belgium, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and the United States. In most of those other countries, the poppy is worn on and leading up to Armistice Day (also known as Remembrance Day) on November 11, which is Veterans Day in the United States, or on ANZAC Day (April 25) in New Zealand and Australia, which commemorates the Australian and New Zealand Army Corps troops who served in the 1915 Gallipoli Campaign. But in the United States, the poppy is worn on Memorial Day, not Veterans Day.
The history of the poppy
The poppy as a symbol of war casualties started with a poem. In the spring of 1915, a Canadian artillery unit brigade surgeon named Lieutenant Colonel John McCrae saw bright red poppies blooming on the war-torn fields where so many soldiers had lost their lives, and he was moved to write "In Flanders Fields."
The poem begins, "In Flanders fields the poppies blow / Between the crosses, row on row," and ends, "If ye break faith with us who die / We shall not sleep, though poppies grow / In Flanders fields." The poem was published in a London magazine and later syndicated to publications in other Allied countries, where it was seen by two separate (but important) women.
RELATED: 36 Memorial Day Quotes for Every American
Two women made the poppy significant
Two women in different countries saw the poem and were inspired in different ways. American University of Georgia professor Moïna Michael wrote a poem in response to McCrae's, titled "We Shall Keep Faith," in 1918. She also started wearing a red poppy in honor of the troops and came up with the idea of making and selling red poppies to raise money for veterans.
Meanwhile, in France, Anna Guérin organized large poppy drives, making and selling poppies to raise money for widows, orphans, and veterans, and to fund France's post-war restoration efforts. She championed her idea for an "Inter-Allied Poppy Day" and started Poppy Days worldwide, during which fundraising poppies were sold in many Allied countries. Poppy factories were set up, often employing disabled servicemen to make the silk and paper blooms.
James Osmond/Getty Images
What does the poppy mean on Memorial Day?
On Monday, May 31, 2021, many Americans will pin a bright red poppy to their shirts as a sign of respect. In the United States, the poppy is not traditionally worn on Veterans Day, but on the last Monday in May, Memorial Day, to commemorate the lives of those who died fighting for their country. The Friday before Memorial Day (May 28 this year) is National Poppy Day. The poppies are handmade by veterans as part of their therapeutic rehabilitation and distributed across the country by the American Legion Auxiliary in exchange for donations that assist disabled and hospitalized veterans.
RELATED: Memorial Day vs. Veterans Day: What's the Difference?
Where can I buy Memorial Day poppies?
You can participate in National Poppy Day (Friday May 28) in a variety of ways. Why not organize a Poppy Drive in your community, or simply purchase one to wear yourself? You may also see a member of the American Legion in your town distributing poppies and accepting donations. You can also donate directly to the American Legion (the wartime veterans service organization) or the American Legion Auxiliary (which coordinates volunteer programs for veterans causes). Both of these groups participate in and fundraise for countless worthy community projects and charities across the United States.
via emblem.legion.org
History.com: "The WWI Origins of the Poppy as a Remembrance Symbol"
American Legion Auxiliary: "ALA Poppy Program"
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs: "Veterans Day FAQs"
RobertDodge/Getty Images
Memorial Day Facts You Never Knew
rd.com
Patriotic Quotes to Honor America
NoDerog/Getty Images
Veterans Day Facts You Didn't Learn in School
99 Memorial Day Sales You Need to Shop This Year
Wayfair's Memorial Day Blowout Is Epic!

redpajama_set_name: RedPajamaCommonCrawl


text:
(+27) 11-704 3276info@marangmag.co.za
Transformation Shares
Marang Transformation Hub
B-BBEE Transformation South Africa
My South Africa
B-BBEE Consulting
Socio-Economic Development
Transformation Surveys
Transformation Directory
Opinion Articles/White Papers
Third Anniversary of Nelson Mandela's Death- Time for a United SA- 5 December 2016
Delivering a keynote address during the third anniversary of former President Nelson Mandela's death, which was held at the Nelson Mandela Foundation Centre of Memory, in Johannesburg, Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa has called for a united South Africa where all citizens work together to build a non-racial and non-sexist society.
"The unity that we must work with great urgency to build should be underpinned by the discipline and principles that leaders such as Madiba subscribed to as well as the values contained in our Constitution and the vision of a free, just and united nation that it describes," he said.
"The Constitution is not only the supreme law of the Republic. It also informs who we are and what we want to be. The unity that we must work to build must be founded on the principles of non-racialism and non-sexism.
"It requires that we grapple directly with the attitudes, practices, institutions and material circumstances that perpetuate racism and sexism. Fundamentally, we need to redress the economic inequality that underpins racial division in our society," said the Deputy President.
He said for as long as the natural state of the black South African is poor and the natural state of the white South African is privileged, South Africa will never succeed in building a non-racial society.
The Deputy President said for as long as the economic and social conditions of women are inferior to those of men, the country will never succeed in building a non-sexist society.
If South Africa is to be a united nation, the Deputy President said there is an urgent need to redistribute the wealth of the country.
"A united South Africa requires the restoration of the land to those who work it. It requires meaningful transfer of ownership and control over the country's natural resources, over the means of production, to the people as a whole."
Nelson Mandela Foundation Chief Executive Officer, Sello Hatang, also raised concern on a number of issues affecting South Africa economically and politically, including student protests. He asked the nation "what would Madiba say?"
Hatang said South Africans should ask themselves what was all that struggle (that Nelson Mandela, uMkhonto we Sizwe (MK), and other struggle stalwarts endured) about, if poor people remained poor or even worse.
"We are not leading the reality of Madiba's dreams," said Hatang.
Courtesy SAnews.gov.za,
Photo Credits- Power FM
President Ramaphosa meets SOE bosses
Limpopo Land Claimants Get Title Deeds 29 November 2018
Open The Gates And Register Your Farms – 07 November 2018
Prayer Against Women Abuse – 20 August 2018
More Than 270 Foreigners Receive SA Citizenship – 20 August 2018
Annan Was A Champion Of Peace – 20 August 2018
Voice Of Disability
B-BBEE Software
B-BBEE Training
B-BBEE Vendors Database
B-BBEE Verification Agencies
Be the first to hear about our offers and Announcements
Designed & Developed By lakoyweb
Copyright © 2016 Marang Transformation Hub PTY(LTD). All rights reserved.


text:
Review: Streets
Ed Theakston April 12, 2013 Off West EndReviews449 views
Streets, the newest production from the youthful Interval Productions, makes the bold claim to be "a new kind of musical". That sets up a huge amount of expectation in an audience; the show has to offer a fresh perspective as well as offering a new kind of style and aesthetic. That is a lot to ask for. Streets does not disappoint.
With writers Tori Allen-Martin and Sarah Henley, composer Finn Anderson has reworked his Edinburgh Fringe hit into a piece that takes place during the days leading up to, and in the immediate aftermath, of the London riots. Streets examines how environments shape people, how they influence them as they struggle with the same emotions that characters have done throughout history: young couples in love, desperate individuals trying to find a way to fit in, people addicted to power.
The piece is set just after the riots, when some of the central characters have been arrested. Danielle Watson (of This Is England) plays a police officer who interrogates the characters, and through a series of flashbacks they tell their own story. It is a slick device that doesn't feel clichéd, allowing for a gradual unravelling of a complex plot that could rival a Shakespearian tragedy; backstabbing, lying, sex, drugs, murder, and all entirely recognisable and relatable for the youth of today.
The central character, Robyn (Sian Louise), provides the emotional heart of the piece. Robyn is in love with drug addict Rick (Brandon Henry), but he gradually forces her away and she finds release in the arms of nice boy Jason (Ben Astle). Louise's performance is beautifully pitched; her relationship with Rick is tempestuous and strained, while the relationship with Jason is tender, loving. Brandon Henry's progressive descent into severe drug addiction is riveting to watch, particularly in the second half of the play when he loses all he has bit by bit.
James Eyres Kenward gives a stunning, witty performance as Skinner, a kind of narrator figure and the man who seems to run everything and everyone. He is quietly menacing and entirely in control. This blend is truly terrifying. Kamilah Beckles and Ryan-Lee Seager's choreography is an electrifying combination of contemporary and street dance styles. Jake Leigh stands out from the crowd and in one particular duet it is impossible to take your eyes off him.
Musically, the piece is more backed by the band than it is in a musical. In Streets, external vocalists sing on the behalf of the characters. This is surprisingly effective. Lead vocalists Tori Allen-Martin and Benedict both have remarkable voices. Allen-Martin is a startlingly emotional performer, really nailing the rawness of the lyrics. Finn Anderson's music is perfect for the piece; at times haunting, at times fierce, it is a powerful score. Juxtaposing the more traditionally 'musical theatre', lyrical numbers is beatboxing from Pikey Esquire and rap, written and performed by James Eyres Kenward. Musical Director Kris Rawlinson does well, leading the musicians from the keyboard.
Director Adam 'Bo' Boland has created a streamlined, emotionally raw piece of theatre. What could feel disjointed is held together by a strong through-line and Anderson's captivating score. The ends of both acts are incredibly climactic – a lot happens in a very short space of time, particularly in the conclusion, but this is done with such precision and clarity that the audience never feels lost.
Although some of the acting is a little presentational and there is an over-fondness for shouting, this is exciting musical theatre that deserves to be championed and developed further. Most of all, this is theatre for the younger generation that is fiercely creative and thrillingly fresh. It deserves to be seen by as many people as possible. Get yourself down to see Streets now, you don't want to miss this.
Streets is playing at the Cockpit Theatre until 21 April. For more information and tickets, see Cockpit Theatre website.
Adam 'Bo' BolandBen AstleBenedictBrandon HenryCockpit TheatreDanielle WatsonFinn AndersonInterval ProductionsJake LeighJames Eyres KenwardKamilah BecklesKris RawlinsonLondon RiotsPikey EsquireRyan-Lee SeagerSarah HenleySian LouiseStreetsThis Is EnglandTori Allen-Martin
Previous ArticleReview: My Perfect Mind
Next ArticleTicket Offer for 16 to 25s: £6 tickets to Axis Arts Emerging Artists Season
Ed Theakston
Ed has worked as an actor, director, lighting designer, and writer for a number of years. He is currently training at East 15 Acting School. He has a keen and diverse interest in theatre and has gained experience working in many different styles, from musical theatre to Stanislavski to devising. This year Ed has started writing reviews regularly for Fourthwall Magazine, and his blog 'Into Training' is available to read on the Fourthwall website.
Recently on AYT
Review: Here/Not Here, Southbank Centre
Review: Young Bloods, Royal Shakespeare Company
Leanna Benjamin: "I was losing my desire to write, but now I've found it again"
Review: Public Domain, Southwark Playhouse
Review: The Origin of Carmen Power, Southbank Centre
Copyright 2009-21 A Younger Theatre LTD ThemeTF -WordPress


text:
STATE OF SHOCK – Our MJ Tribute
It's up. It's a labor of love. Enjoy it. And if you're a member ofour minglemob site, please leave us a comment.
Rock on – The Perry Brothers
Still from the video... fun times!
July 17, 2009 The Perry Brothers	allen, brothers, dirty, jackson, jagger, jen, jenny, josh, leigh, man, michael, mick, music, perry, policeman, ponce, ponceman, quernzy, retarded, sap, scott, shock, state, thesap, valerie, video	1 Comment
A Few Words On Our Michael Jackson Tribute
There is a sad truth to this life we lead… we being humans, especially the ones who live in America. The sad truth is, if there is a way to make money on something there is no shortage of people to step up and take that money, regardless of how many lives it destroys. I will not name names and point fingers, but all you have to do is look at the guests who appeared at the MJ Staples Center tribute. It isn't hard to pick out who was there for exposure (exposure=career resurrection/money) and who was there because they truly cared.
I will point a positive finger at Magic Johnson, a game-changing legend in his own right, who was there ONLY to share his love of MJ. And a sweet new view of Brooke Shields has settled in my heart after hearing her talk about her relationship with Michael. It reminded me that Michael Jackson was not from this planet.
Michael Jackson was in the spotlight since he was 5 years old and had all the perks that go with that spotlight. It's like being born a king… a king who has to perform, has to produce something the people like, or you lose his crown. Michael Jackson performed better than anyone on this planet. He was never one of US.
US=you and me=U.S.=United States.
There are no more icons. The word itself will have no meaning soon, just like "Diva" before it. The American people, the ones who feed the tabloid media, the ones who thrive on watching celebrities torn apart to the point of death, have destroyed art, artists, and the spirit of creativity. There are no new Michael Jacksons out there because TALENT is no longer required for one to be a superstar. TALENT is a ghost of the past. Who needs TALENT when you have an endless supply of hot teens and pre-teens the entertainment business can dress up to prance around playing Rockstar. Rockstar… is that a drink or a video game? There's another world that has been castrated. There are no balls left in that word. Just an empty sack of use-to-be-testosterone-filled-power. All the "rockstars" of today are disposable, with shelf lives of 2 to 5 years… if they are lucky.
I am here to spill the harsh reality of life without art to the ones who have given power to the TALENTLESS. Nobody will care when today's "artists" die because the ones the entertainment business has promoted have created NO ART. When Lindsey Lohan leaves this life the only contribution that will be brought up is… I can't think of one. She was in a remake of The Parent Trap. And did a lot of drugs and showed her snatch and is/isn't a lesbian whenever the wind blows. There. That's her legacy. There will be no Staples Center memorial service for The Jonas Brothers either. Boo Fucking Hoo.
At least when Michael Jackson was torn apart by the media and rabid masses of our American culture, he had an actual legacy to protect. A legacy that was damaged beyond repair. But nothing can erase the impact Michael Jackson had on lives… human lives… lives of the people on this planet that he was never from. My life, the life of my brother, sister, my parents, friends, were all affected by Michael Jackson's talent. He was a performer that could unite the entire world, as he did on more than one occasion. We Are The World… If you don't know what it was, and I don't mean just the song, then google that shit.
Which brings us to our tribute video. It will NOT be in the YouTube partner program. That's one way that YouTubers can make money, they get a small percentage of the advertisements Google places on their video pages. Our video will not be part of that program. Why not? Because we did not make the video to make money. We made it because we love Michael Jackson and want to express it the best way we can. Imagine that; a Tribute video made to pay Tritbute. Tribute to MJ for all the reasons I've mentioned and many more. TRIBUTE… another word that will soon have no meaning. Maybe Coca Cola or McDonald's will sponsor the next big celebrity wake so we can all mourn and pump a McTurd buger into our bellies at the same time.
All the people in our tribute video have their own special connection to MJ and his music. Dirty Jenny, our friend who plays guitar in the video, played on the MJ Track Stranger In Moscow. She was mentored by David Williams whose guitars you hear on almost every Michael Jackson hit. Jenny was all set to do the big HBO live gig in 1995 that Michael had to cancel due to "health" issues. These issues happened to coincide with the return of child molestation charges and a new media hunger to tear him apart. That's what sold more papers, made more headlines, and made more people tune in so the advertising dollars could go higher and higher.
My brother, the mighty Ponceman, and I used to perform the song "State of Shock" off the Jackson's Victory album, duet with Michael and Mick Jagger. We'd perform it every time it came on the radio. We'd set up special performances of it for whatever audience we could assemble. I was 14, Ponce was 6. We grew closer to each other with every performance. Why? Because the music was that good. It made us move. It made us dance, sing, and feel like we could conquer the world. And we still perform it to this day. This video is the culmination of all those past performance.
So when we post our video on Friday, try to empty your minds of all the negatives this world has thrown at MJ and sit back and let the music take you away to a time when performers made news and got ratings, not because of a drug overdose or domestic abuse or some other scandal, but because of one simple little thing historians will soon attempt to explain to future generations who don't grasp the concept… a little thing known as TALENT. Michael Jackson had it and the business world of entertainment chiseled it away.
July 14, 2009 The Perry Brothers	allen, brothers, jackson, josh, legacy, man, memorial, michael, perry, policeman, ponce, ponceman, retarded, sap, scott, talent, thesap, tribute	1 Comment
Sneak Peek at our MJ Tribute
This video is gonna be funktabulicious! It hits the YouTube on Friday, July 17th. Dirty Jenny on GTR, Quernzy kickin' some sweet background vox, and, of course, SAP on the PonceKit.
Dirty Jenny ripping licks
SAP about to get juiced!
Ponce about to get juiced... and he likes it!
Find more photos like this on Perry Brothers Mingle Mob
July 9, 2009 The Perry Brothers	allen, brothers, dirty, jackson, jenny, josh, man, michael, music, perry, policeman, ponce, ponceman, quernz, quernzy, retarded, sap, scott, thesap, tribute, valerie, video	Leave a comment