 What wouldn't 10 and 11 critics agree on?
Egg auctions will produce designer babies. Alarmists, agreeing that Harris "can put you into your own designer baby by selling eggs," predict that his success will steer "the future of human breeding" toward "genetic engineering." 2. Egg auctions will fail to produce designer babies. "Not only is it ethically ludicrous, but the fact is, no kid's going to look like the model's picture," observes ethicist George Annas. First, the child of an ugly man and a pretty woman is just as likely to be ugly as to be pretty. Third, even if both parents are attractive, a child can combine their features unattractively. 3. Egg auctions will promote the survival of the fittest. This site simply mirrors our current society, in that beauty usually goes to the highest bidder." But this reply only fuels concern that gradually, society will separate into "genetic haves and have nots." 4. Egg auctions will promote the survival of the unfittest. Harris writes that only men with "substantial financial resources" are fit to give his models' offspring "a financially secure and stable life." But skeptics wonder whether women who sell their eggs to the highest bidder--and men who buy these eggs for the sole purpose of spawning good-looking children--may produce children just as dysfunctional as themselves. Egg auctions will fail to promote the survival of the unfittest. Many models, if not most, have had cosmetic surgery. Annas concludes that since there's "no way to know how much of their beauty is a product of their genes, plastic surgery, a makeup artist, or exercise," only a "naive" person would buy their eggs on the basis of the photographs displayed on the site. On this theory, children produced by the egg auction are likely to be the offspring of liars on one side and fools on the other. On his site, he writes, " 'Natural Selection' is choosing genes that are healthy and beautiful." Skeptics question this assumed equivalence, noting that traits men find attractive in women these days--thinness, for example--are often unhealthy. 7. Beauty is less meaningful than intelligence. Others, he notes, have sold sperm and solicited eggs on the basis of the donor's intelligence. This critique is usually offered by a blow-dried TV interviewer who, after thanking Harris for his time, urges viewers to stay tuned for the movie starlet who will join the program after a brief commercial break.
 Harris will make a lot of money from his website
 Harris will do anything to make money  Harris doesn't care about his donors  Harris has gotten attention because of this plan  Harris will make a lot of money from his website