 Did William kill the man?
For punishment, he locked me in a windowless room and told me to sit still until he came back. If you believe any of this at all, you'll see why it couldn't be me who did the stealing. It wouldn't go up, down, left or right. William, you are being punished for some great sin. "William, all I can tell you is that time means nothing in Heaven. "Well," I said, "I've had no personal experience—" "Of course you have, William!
 yes - he used the pipe and killed the man
 no - he watched the men do it, but William thought it was the spirits  yes, though he doesn't remember  yes - he used the pipe and killed the man  no - the two men did it when William's back was turned