Exploring Data Scaling Trends and Effects in Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
Wei Shen, Guanlin Liu, Yu Yue, Ruofei Zhu, Qingping Yang, Chao Xin, Lin Yan
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is essential for aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences and values. While recent research has primarily focused on algorithmic advancements—such as reducing computational overhead or strengthening reward models to mitigate reward hacking—the critical role of prompt-data construction and its scalability has received comparatively less attention. In this paper, we address this gap by systematically exploring data-driven bottlenecks that currently hinder RLHF performance scaling, focusing specifically on the challenges posed by reward hacking and decreasing response diversity.To mitigate reward hacking, we introduce a hybrid reward system combining reasoning task verifiers (RTV) and a generative reward model (GenRM). This approach not only exhibits enhanced resistance to reward hacking, but also enables accurate assessment of responses against clearly defined ground-truth solutions. Additionally, in order to ensure response diversity and enhance learning effectiveness, we propose a novel prompt-selection method named \textbf{Pre-PPO}, explicitly identifying training prompts that are inherently challenging and thus less prone to reward hacking. Furthermore, we find that \textbf{prioritizing mathematical and coding tasks during the early phases of RLHF training} significantly boosts performance, given that these tasks naturally encode fine-grained response distinctions and possess clearly defined ground truths.Through comprehensive experiments conducted across two model sizes, we validate the effectiveness and scalability of our proposed methods. Results show that RTV exhibits the strongest resistance to reward hacking, followed by GenRM with ground truth, and finally GenRM relying on SFT Best-of-N responses. Moreover, our proposed strategies enable the model to rapidly capture subtle task-specific distinctions, leading to substantial improvements in overall RLHF performance. This work underscores the importance of careful data construction and provides practical methodologies to overcome critical performance barriers in RLHF.