Causal Head Gating: A Framework for Interpreting Roles of Attention Heads in Transformers
Andrew Nam, Henry Conklin, Yukang Yang, Tom Griffiths, Jonathan D Cohen, Sarah-Jane Leslie
We present causal head gating (CHG), a scalable method for interpreting the functional roles of attention heads in transformer models. CHG learns soft gates over heads and assigns them a causal taxonomy—facilitating, interfering, or irrelevant—based on their impact on task performance. Unlike prior approaches in mechanistic interpretability which are hypothesis-driven and require prompt templates or target labels, CHG applies directly to any dataset using standard next-token prediction. We evaluate CHG across multiple large language models (LLMs) in the Llama 3 model family and diverse tasks, including syntax, commonsense, and mathematical reasoning, and show that CHG scores indeed yield causal—not merely correlational—insight, validated via ablation and causal mediation analyses. We also introduce contrastive CHG, a variant that isolates sub-circuits for specific task components. Our findings reveal that LLMs contain multiple sparse, sufficient sub-circuits, that individual head roles depend on interactions with others (low modularity), and that instruction following and in-context learning rely on separable mechanisms.