For both these quilts I am guessing origins in a German Sectarian Community, possibly Pennsylvania, but perhaps Ohio, due to several design characteristics noted by quilt scholar Ricky Clark in a chapter in the book Quilts in Community: Ohio's Traditions. A vivid palette, multiple borders and contrasting binding were favored by women of German ancestry and Anabaptist Protestant faith, women described as German Sectarians. The best-known among these conservative Protestant communities are the Amish and Mennonites.
Amish quilt from the early 20th century.
Women in Amish communities in places like Iowa and Kansas
also used this aesthetic.
Once late-20th-century quilters began seeing these classic Amish and Mennonite quilts in print and in museums we began to think of their double borders as a design necessity.
Amish quilt date-inscribed 1928
Today we tend to call the inner border a spacer border, especially if it is narrower than the outer border. It's a fairly recent term. I found that Marsha McCloskey advised using "a spacer strip...a plain inner border" in her 1984 book Projects for Blocks and Borders, indicating that the term came into use in the mid-1980s.
She was probably talking about using a plain border to separate two pieced borders, so a spacer strip could be any width of plain border as in her wide white border here.
Today we think of a spacer as creating a color space too.
The German Sectarians weren't the only quilters in the past to use double borders. This Drunkard's Path (notice it is two alternate blocks) was probably not made by a woman from a German Brethren group.
Other women liked pink and other women used a double border.
Or a triple border.
And that inner framing border wasn't invented in 1880.
The quilts above and below may be from 1840-1890.
It may be that we see more of these multiple strip borders after 1870 when the sewing machine made long seams more practical.
Whether your machine was treadle or electric powered.
That Germanic aesthetic of the 1880-1930 era works so well.
It's one more thing that makes these quilts so collectible.
Here we have a double inner border with contrasting binding.
Four frames around the baskets.
And then there is the pieced inner border.
You can see why the spacer border is so popular today.
The proportions seem just right.