Location: Soil Plant Nutrient Research (SPNR)
Title: The Biogeochemistry of Bioenergy Landscapes: Carbon, Nitrogen, and Water Considerations Authors
|Robertson, G -|
|Hamilton, Stephen -|
|Del Grosso, Stephen|
|Parton, William -|
Submitted to: Ecological Applications
Publication Type: Peer Reviewed Journal
Publication Acceptance Date: February 5, 2010
Publication Date: June 13, 2011
Repository URL: http://www. esajournals.org/toc/ecap/21/4
Citation: Robertson, G.P., Hamilton, S.K., Del Grosso, S.J., Parton, W.J. 2011. The Biogeochemistry of Bioenergy Landscapes: Carbon, Nitrogen, and Water Considerations. Ecological Applications. 21(4), 2011, pp. 1055-1067. Interpretive Summary: Bioenergy production systems can increase water pollution and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, particularly if marginal lands not currently farmed are converted to annual cropping. However, perennial cellulosic biofuel crops require less fertilizer and are expected to minimally impact water quality and GHG emissions. Measurements of nutrient levels in groundwater and streams that drain fields and GHG emissions from fields are needed to verify these predictions. But measurements are not exhaustive and models are required to estimate the environmental impacts of cropping systems at regional and larger scales. Modeling results suggests that converting existing cropland or prairie to switchgrass production results in a net GHG sink. Outcomes and policy must be informed by science that adequately quantifies the net environmental costs and benefits of alternative cropping systems.
Technical Abstract: The biogeochemical liabilities of grain-based crop production for bioenergy are no different from those of grain-based food production: excessive nitrate leakage, soil carbon and phosphorus loss, nitrous oxide production, and attenuated methane uptake. Contingent problems are well-known, increasingly well-documented, and recalcitrant: freshwater and coastal marine eutrophication, groundwater pollution, soil organic matter loss, and a warming atmosphere. The conversion of marginal lands not now farmed to annual grain production, including the repatriation of Conservation Reserve Program (CRP) and other conservation set-aside lands, will further exacerbate the biogeochemical imbalance of these landscapes, as could pressure to further simplify crop rotations. The expected emergence of biorefinery and combustion facilities that accept cellulosic materials offers an alternative outcome: agricultural landscapes that accumulate soil carbon, that conserve nitrogen and phosphorus, and that emit relatively small amounts of nitrous oxide to the atmosphere. Fields in these landscapes are planted to perennial crops that require less fertilizer, that retain sediments and nutrients that could otherwise be transported to groundwater and streams, and that accumulate carbon in both soil organic matter and roots. If mixed-species assemblages, they additionally provide biodiversity services. Biogeochemical responses of these systems fall chiefly into two areas: carbon neutrality and water and nutrient conservation. Fluxes must be measured and understood in proposed cropping systems sufficient to inform models that will predict biogeochemical behavior at field, landscape, and regional scales. Because tradeoffs are inherent to these systems, a systems approach is imperative, and because potential biofuel cropping systems and their environmental contexts are complex and cannot be exhaustively tested, modeling will be instructive. Modeling alternative biofuel cropping systems converted from different starting points, for example, suggests that converting CRP to corn ethanol production under conventional tillage results in substantially increased net greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions that can be only partly mitigated with no-till management. Alternatively, conversion of existing cropland or prairie to switchgrass production results in a net GHG sink. Outcomes and policy must be informed by science that adequately quantifies the true biogeochemical costs and advantages of alternative systems.