<< Blues Classroom
Click here to download a PDF of this lesson. (1.7 MB)
This lesson will enable students to use the blues to explore urbanization, technology, and their effects on everyday life in the 20th century.
Musicians were among the large number of people who, between 1914 and 1945, participated in the Great Migration, in which rural African
Americans left work on the farms for new opportunities in the cities of the North and the West. At the same time, these cities were in the
process of being transformed by industry, invention, technology, and consumerism. Ultimately, this exercise should help students to appreciate
African Americans' experience of social and technological change in America during this time period.
By completing this lesson, the student will:
- Gain an understanding of the experiences of African Americans who moved to the city during the Great Migration
- Learn about the symbolic meanings of the city in the early to mid-20th century
- Make connections between 20th-century urbanization and such other forces of social change as industrialization and mass communication
Addresses the following themes in the National Curriculum Standards for Social Studies:
Primary Themes: III, VIII
Secondary Themes: II, V, VII
The Blues Teacher's Guide
Robert Johnson, "Cross Road Blues"
Skip James, "Hard Time Killin' Floor Blues"
B.B. King, "Three O'Clock Blues"
Muddy Waters, "Mannish Boy"
The Meaning of the City
Godfathers and Sons (segment on Maxwell Street)
The Road to Memphis ("Coming Home" and "Heaven for a Black Man" segments,
in which B.B. King and Rosco Gordon discuss
black migration to the city of Memphis and the changing face of Beale Street)
The Great Migration
Godfathers and Sons (discussion between Marshall Chess and
Chuck D, backed by historic footage, of migration to Chicago; segment in which the Great Migration is described as a way to escape the Jim Crow south)
The Soul of a Man (segment in the first Skip James portion
of the film in which the farming crisis of the 1920s, sharecropping, and tenant farming are depicted; segment in the first J.B. Lenoir section
where Lenoir discusses his desire to leave the farming life)
One of the major events of American history in the early 20th century was the migration of hundreds of thousands of African Americans (including
many blues performers) from poor and rural areas of the South to growing urban centers, both in the South and in the North. African Americans'
encounters with modernity in America's citiesplaces of tall buildings, machines, lights, noise, and masses of people never before
seen"profoundly affected their behavior, attitudes, and goals for the future. Many of these migrantssome of whom had never had electricity
back home, for instancewere energized by the new environment, at least before they realized that the city contained new kinds of segregation
and that their hopes were not to be fully realized due to institutionalized racism. That initial encounter with the city, however, embodied the
promise of urbanization for all Americans between 1900 and 1940. Today, the city generally has a different set of associations, ones that have less
to do with progress and light than with decay, crime, and poverty. This exercise will explore changing ideas of the city over time.
Start by asking students about their ideas of the city. What are some of its main features? How do cities' tall buildings,
commercial areas, and masses of people make you feel? Do they make you inspired, excited, depressed, frightened, weary, confused, etc.?
Next, as a way to place the discussion in a more concrete historical context, show excerpts from The
Blues films that address the meaning of the city. The Road to Memphis opens with
two segments titled "Coming Home" and "Heaven for a Black Man" which focus on the changes that have occurred in Memphis over the years.
B.B. King says that it "was like going to
Paris" when he first arrived, and that Beale Street had a lively, exciting nightlife. However, Rosco Gordon
reflects that things have changed today: Beale Street fell on hard times and has revitalized itself only as a tourist attraction.
Godfathers and Sons includes a segment on Maxwell Street in Chicago, contrasting its prominence
in 1945 as a lively market for black migrants and Jewish immigrants with its emptiness and decay today.
After watching the excerpts, ask students to characterize the changes experienced by both Memphis and Chicago. How did blues
musicians perceive each city, particularly the black neighborhoods in these cities, in the 1940s? How do they perceive these places now? Based
on their own experiences, and those of their parents and grandparents, do students feel that cities in the United States have changed for the
worse, or at least have changed their appeal? Are cities today still associated with economic opportunity, progress, and invention? Does
moving to the city today equate with improving one's life? Why or why not?
Conclude this exercise by asking students to participate in a debate in which they voice their opinions on whether or not a
Great Migration could happen in the near future and what the defining characteristics of such a migration would be.
This exercise compares the tone, content, and sound of country and urban blues in order to frame a discussion about the Great Migration. First,
explain that the Great Migration, which occurred largely between WWI and WWII, was a mass movement of poor, rural, black Southerners to Southern
and Northern cities. Blacks were seeking to better their lives, both economically and socially, leaving behind the Jim Crow South and tenant
farming for what they saw as an opportunity to start again and gain a new independence in the burgeoning, urban factory environment of the North.
[Portions of The Blues films that discuss the Great Migration are noted in Film Tie-Ins section.]
Suggest that the blues might be a good way to understand what moving to the city meant to migrants. First, play a country
blues song or two (Robert Johnson's "Cross Road Blues" and Skip James' "Hard Time Killin'
Floor Blues"). Then play an urban blues song or two for comparison (B.B. King's "Three O'Clock Blues" and Muddy Waters'
"Mannish Boy"). Ask students to consider both how the music changes and
how it remains the same. As you discuss the similarities and differences with the class, list them on the blackboard.
After focusing on the similarities and differences, take the discussion to another level by asking students how urban blues
songs capture "the city" in sound.
Conclude this exercise by asking students to write a letter, in the voice of someone who migrated from the Delta region to
Chicago in the 1940s, to a family member back home. The letter should enumerate how electric Chicago blues (as heard in "Mannish Boy") differ
from acoustic Delta blues (as heard in "Hard Time Killin' Floor Blues" and "Cross Road Blues").
For a model, students can be provided with actual letters written by migrants to Chicago. [Examples can be found at
Research and Analysis
During the Great Migration, blues musicians traveled to cities like Memphis, St. Louis, Kansas City, Chicago, Los Angeles, and New York. Split
the students into groups and assign each to choose one of these cities and imagine what it would be like for a blues musician arriving there in
the 1940s. How would he/she get there? What would he/she have to do first upon arrival? In what part of the city did African Americans live and
why? Where might a migrant find shelter, food, work, etc.? What might his/her experience of the city be in the first week? What kinds of new
behaviors, attitudes, and values might he or she have to develop in order to survive? In the end, have students create a handbook for new
arrivals to the city in the 1940s. Students can begin their research by consulting encyclopedia entries on the history of these cities and
locating social histories on each. Web sources include http://afroamhistory.about.com/cs/communities/.
Synthesis and Assessment
Ask students to create an advertisement for Muddy Waters' "Mannish Boy" (1955) or B.B. King's "Three O'Clock Blues" (1951). The advertisement
should address the qualities and values that would appeal to potential black urban buyers at the time these songs were released. Assign
students a one-page explanation of their advertisement in which they justify their creations.
1. A key component of the urban blues that developed in the 1940s was the electrification of instruments. Such electrification, particularly
the guitar, bass, and harmonica, was one of the major sound manifestations of the African American experience of the city. Drawing on students
own music listening, first discuss the meaning of electrification in music: How do acoustic instruments make you feel as opposed to electric
instruments? Suggest that electrification and amplification were, for many black migrants, "modern" sounding, signifying the future. Discuss
with students whether they agree with this idea that electrification and amplification create a modern sound. In particular, discuss which
music they find "modern" or "old" and why. Conclude by discussing the relationship between technology and music. Does the sound of music
suggest the time period in which it was produced? Do musicians ever work to make their music sound less modern? Why would they choose to do
2. Newly arrived migrants from the Delta were often frowned upon by middle-class black city dwellers as country bumpkins and
"bad examples" of African Americans, while, in reality, many were striving to distance themselves from the past of cotton, slavery, and
illiteracy. With that in mind, discuss how different blues songs might have been perceived by different groups of people, including the urban
black middle class and black rural migrants. Suggestions include "Hard Time Killin' Floor Blues" by Skip James,
"Mannish Boy" by Muddy Waters, and "Three O'Clock Blues" by B.B. King.
Research and Analysis
The technology of instrumentation, amplification, and recording are central to understanding the blues and its changing appeal as it moved to
cities. In fact, blues musicians were very much like other city dwellers in their embrace of modern technologies and inventions. Ask students
to research the history of one new invention or technology that had an impact on the blues, outlining its role in developing urban life.
- Arnesen, Eric. Black Protest and the Great Migration: A Brief History With Documents. New York: Bedford Books, 2002.
- Mohl, Raymond A. The Making of Urban America. Wilmington: Scholarly Resources, 1993.
- Lemann, Nicholas. The Great Migration and How It Changed America. New York: Vintage, 1992.
- Waksman, Steve. Instrument of Desire: The Electric Guitar and the Shaping of Musical Experience. Boston: Harvard University Press, 2000.