Future research from the Petrie typology of amulets
The five amulets below illustrate the five classes proposed by Petrie, and the chronological scope of material, in Petrie 1914
Amulets of similars
Carnelian leg amulet
First Intermediate Period
Amulets of powers
Amulets of property
Glass model vessel
Amulets of protection
Third Intermediate Period
Amulets evoking gods
faience falcon head
Two of the more serious methodological objections to the classification system are (1) changes over time and (2) the meaning of items within sets.
1. change over time
Petrie gathered together material from several thousand years of Egyptian history, from prehistory to the medieval period. The better documented historical periods towards the end of this time-range include radical transformations in the patterns and expressions of religious belief in Egypt: the Hellenisation of Egypt during the Roman Period, followed by general conversion to Christianity by the fourth century, and then to Islam after the Arab Conquest of AD 639-642. It might be expected that social and individual attitudes to objects differed considerably between periods with different religious beliefs.
For future research - the beliefs of each period should be explored first from the material contemporary with that period (rule of relative synchrony)
2. items in sets
In accordance with the general history of collections, Petrie considered amulets item by item. However at the same time he recorded the groups of amulets found on Late Period burials. Such study of groups may prove more productive than study of single object categories, or at least should not be excluded, because an item may derive meaning not only from its form (content), but equally or more from its place among others (context) and its difference or similarity to others in its time and place. Entirely different ranges of amulets are found in each of the main periods of ancient Egyptian history.
For future research - the groups of amulets in each period should be explored alongside the individual items. The periods at which amulets are grouped together at burial with especial regularity are the First Intermediate Period (exemplified by burials at Qau), the Late Period to early Ptolemaic Period (exemplified by burials at Hawara, Abydos and Nebesheh), and the early Roman Period (exemplified by burials at Denderah).
Copyright © 2002 University College London. All rights reserved.