A green campaign group has bullied Ireland’s largest schools’ publisher into revising a geography textbook because one of its chapters contained an unhelpfully “balanced” view on global warming.
Unlocking Geography, published by Folens, has been used for the last four years to teach sixth year students at Irish primary schools about phenomena such as climate change.
The global warming chapter originally featured a debate between an alarmist called Barry and a sceptic gloriously called James.
According to RTE:
In chapter ten of the book, ‘Barry’ a fictitious climate scientist outlines the effect that human activity is having on the environment.
He is followed by ‘James’, a fictitious meteorological researcher, who disagrees. James says “Most of the things that have led to Global Warming were caused by nature itself”.
He goes on to say that “Humans are not to blame because we have very little control over nature.
The chapter asks children to discuss these points of view.
It quotes from blogs that state “All this talk of Global Warming is silly”, and “Those scientists are always trying to scare us!”.
However, the chapter has now been amended after pressure from An Taisce – Ireland’s National Trust – which was alerted to the chapter by the daughter of one of its members.
Folens has now revised the chapter with guidance from An Taisce and its approved scientists – none of whom, clearly, nurtures any doubt whatsoever about the reality of man-made climate change because all trace of scepticism has now been airbrushed from the book.
In the revised chapter – sent out to all schools which use the book as a replacement for the original – James and all his sceptical questions have disappeared, leaving only Barry the true believer.
John Gibbons, climate spokesman for An Taisce told the Irish Daily Mail:
“Framing climate change as an issue upon which the scientific community is completely divided is a gross misrepresentation of the powerful international scientific consensus that has emerged over the last several decades confirming climate change as being both extremely dangerous and predominantly occurring as a result of emissions arising from human actions.”
John Cadell, publisher of Folens, said:
“When we produced the book that was the opinion that we felt was the most balanced. I think the data and the facts since then have given a slightly different perspective. I think what we’re saying now is that it’s becoming more indisputable.”