I suppose it’s too soon to identify which trees will have marcescent leaves through the winter and which simply haven’t dropped their leaves yet. Marcescence is the term for trees that hold their leaves all winter, often until the new spring buds push the last of the old leaves off. Some trees are notorious for marcescence—the American beech is one and oaks are another, both of which surround my cabin. Often, it’s the younger and smaller trees that are marcescent. And frequently, it’s the lower branches only that retain leaves.
One theory (marcescence has many theories) is that retaining leaves helps protect the smaller branches from being eaten by deer and so helps a young tree retain its both branches and its health. The idea here is that the leaves make it difficult for deer to nip the twigs. The dried leaves are less nutritious and even make their twigs less so. Another theory is that oaks and beech trees have not fully mastered being deciduous yet and that marcescence is some evolutionary in-between stage. Another theory is that marcescence helps smaller understory trees better retain and recycle their nutrients, keeping those goodies to themselves, which could be especially important to small trees with their smaller root systems.One thing about marcesence that is not theoretical is that the leaves provide shelter for birds in winter, helping to protect them from the wind. That’s a result of marcescence, not a cause of course, though clearly the birds know how to take advantage of it.