One of the most common questions I would get about the commonly encountered "Ochre Stars" (Pisaster ochraceus) that live on the west coast of North America.
"Is there any significance to the color?" (or some variant thereof)
Well, its taken nearly 15 years but FINALLY...I can answer this question! I thank a neat paper by Harley et al. 2006 in the Biological Bulletin, which is available via Open Access!
So, here's the story!
This species lives along the coast from Alaska to California, including British Columbia, Washington, and Oregon.
These animals have a brilliant and very distinctive suite of colors that stand out. These include
BROWN (or RED)
and... ORANGE...and in fact, the species epithet, "ochraceus" in "Pisaster ochraceus" or the common name "Ochre Star" refers to the yellow-brown color, which was probably the living color of the the first specimens that were described of this species.
It turns out that the colors DO indeed VARY with region. Different places along the west coast have variable colors. Of populations they surveyed from 31 sites in California (North & South), Oregon, Washington, British Columbia, and Alaska. (diagram below is NOT proportional)
Across the surveyed sites, they found that on the whole MOST of them were brown-reddish with a relative minority of orange colored members as part of the population.
Curiously, those in certain isolated channels..in Georgia Strait (British Columbia) and Puget Sound (Washington) were 95% PURPLE!!
And they got a diagram that showed overall similarity between members from each of the different sampled study sites.
There was a close association between all of the populations in California, Washington, and Oregon (seems like Alaska was omitted).
The Georgia Strait and Puget Sound populations (the purple ones) clusters together AGAIN.
COULD these purple populations be something new or different???
A logical question to ask at this point. Did this separate purple population or ANY population of this species have enough separation or structure to warrant consideration of a new species??
So, The study looked at population genetics of P. ochraceus.
That is, the amount of genetic structure was present in the various populations within the species across its distributed range.
Essentially, there was NO structure of populations across the range.
That is to say, that an individual from San Diego (southern range) and an individual from Alaska (northern range) were really NOT all that different. Gene flow between populations remained high (that is, no subset of the gene pool had been significantly isolated)
They found NO "obvious" relationship between color and each population.
So, to put it in much simpler terms- There is no color (or other) subset of this species that has become isolated enough that its about to become a separate species or even a genetically separated population.
WHAT's going ON with the PURPLE ones then????
One of the coolest conclusions of this paper was that COLOR in P. ochraceus is probably related to what individuals of this species ATE.
So, it turns out that individuals from California, Oregon, and Washington?
They enjoy eating The mussel Mytilus californianus
THEY AIN'T GOT NO MUSSELS!!!
Instead, they have ACORN BARNACLES!! (Balanus spp.)
The immediate correlation seemed to be that this ecological/external effect (i.e., food type) was the reason why you get purple Pisaster ochraceus. It turns out that the mussel Mytilus contians carotenoid pigments, which are the same KIND of pigment that are responsible for the orange color in carrots!!
Harley et al. hypothesize that the mussels provide the pigment that yields the light orange/red color
and that those ochre stars deprived of mussels REVERT back to the bright PURPLE color!!! (note that mussels are absent in the pic below!)
They add anecdotal accounts that some orange adults turn purple when held for long periods under laboratory conditions and that small individuals of Pisaster are actually not fixed on a color. So SIZE and maturity may also be important factors.
But the authors save the best for last. They also speculate that those factors that affect color are apparently stable over relatively long ecological time scales.
In some places, such as the famous Pacific Grove, California (home to Ed "Doc" Ricketts and Cannery Row), they were able to determine that Pisaster size, color frequency and diet have not significantly changed in over HALF a Century!!!
So, this famous population of sea stars has not undergone any real changes in prey abundance for the last 60 years or so!