# When video game age ratings go wrong: Balatro’s battle with Pegi

## Card Game Balatro

Card game Balatro was a huge hit last year – but a year-long struggle with the European age ratings board has exposed how well-meaning rules can have unintended consequences.

## Introduction

It’s an ingenious premise that has allowed a game that began as a small side-project to sell millions of copies since its release in February 2024. Though players win in-game money to buy new cards between rounds, Balatro’s version of poker is fictional, and only bears a faint resemblance to the classic card game. Yet shortly after launching, Balatro hit a snag: it was classified as a gambling game.

At first, Balatro went on sale with a classification that deemed it appropriate for audiences ages three and up. But then, the classification was revised to an adults-only 18 rating. The reasoning? The Pan-European Game Information (Pegi), the organisation that determines age classifications, claimed that Balatro “contains prominent gambling imagery and material that instructs about gambling”.

Without warning, Balatro was pulled from sale on some digital storefronts in Europe and Asia.

“This was obviously a crucial moment and we had two options,” says Wout van Halderen, the communications director at PlayStack, Balatro’s publisher. “Be de-listed, or take the 18+ rating and get back in the store Asap. We opted for the second and started preparing an appeal to have the rating changed.”

The appeal was initially declined – and issues began to snowball. In December, when Balatro won several categories at The Game Awards, the team was also ramping up for a physical release. Another appeal was filed by that version’s distributor, Fireshine. It is only now, a year later and after a handful of updates, that the dust has settled and Balatro has been bumped down to a 12+ rating by Pegi.

“It’s difficult to quantify the sales impact, as Balatro’s surge in popularity may have mitigated losses,” Halderen says. “That said, the de-listing disrupted momentum at a key point in the launch. Development-wise, the rating saga took time and resources, but it didn’t fundamentally delay planned updates.”

Pegi, for its part, reiterated that it seeks to apply a fair criteria for ratings , and that any game that teaches or glamorises gambling will automatically lead to an 18+ rating. The board that oversaw the appeal also ceded that Pegi is a system that “continuously evolves in line with cultural expectations and the guidance of independent experts who support our assessment process”. To that end, Balatro’s dilemma has led Pegi to create a more granular classification system for games that depict gambling. The 18+ rating will now only apply to games that simulate the type of poker people play at actual casinos.

It is a tale with a happy ending for Balatro, yet it highlights the limitations of Pegi’s current system. The appeal process was an extended one, and while that didn’t impact Balatro’s massive success, a smaller game without such acclaim would not fare nearly as well.

The wording of the new classification system suggests that any realistic depiction of gambling within a game would still result in an 18+ rating, even if players cannot actually spend, bet or lose money in the game. Meanwhile, games such as EA’s football series Sports FC, which sell players digital loot boxes with randomised contents, sport Pegi’s 3+ classification. The loot boxes only have a small chance of dropping a rare item, which means players are effectively gambling their money by buying them.

Even with better classification systems and streamlined processes, any age rating system would struggle to keep consumers informed about the contents of a game in the age of user-generated content. A game like Roblox, for example, was deemed to be appropriate for users 7+, before it was given a PG label – but the rating does not apply to anything created by players, which is the vast majority of the content, and .

The reclassification of Balatro has been a great relief for its publisher, and the amendment to Pegi’s rules shows that the organisation is open to change. “We applaud the Pegi Experts Group on their commitment to develop a more granular set of classification criteria as indie games continue to stretch into new ideas and concepts,” Halderen says.

“We believe it is a sign of a healthy classification board that it evolves in line with cultural expectations and continues to ensure that audiences understand the type of content present in games.”

---

This article was amended on 7 March 2025. An earlier version said that Balatro’s age rating barred it from being sold in Korea. This claim has been removed as it could not be satisfactorily substantiated. Also, the title was nominated for game of the year at The Game Awards, but did not win; and Pegi removed its 7+ rating for Roblox in September 2022, replacing it with a parental guidance advisory.

Explore more on these topics:

- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 

This article was originally published on Tue 4 Mar 2025 10:00 EST. First published on Tue 4 Mar 2025 10:00 EST.

---

## More on this story

### Parents should stop children gaming on Roblox if they are worried, says CEO

- 2d ago
- 

### Roblox to give parents more control over children’s activity after warnings over grooming

- 18 Nov 2024
- 

### Pushing Buttons: With the safety of Roblox under scrutiny, how worried should parents be?

- 16 Oct 2024
- 

### Ofcom urged to act after US firm claims Roblox is ‘paedophile hellscape’

- 15 Oct 2024
- 

### Pushing Buttons: Why viral voyeurism game Clickolding became a surprise hit

- 24 Jul 2024
- 

### ‘Advergames’: how games platform Roblox became a corporate marketing playground

- 13 Jul 2024
- 

### The Guardian view on video games: computer generated worlds are influencing real ones

- 9 Feb 2024
- 
- 

---

## Most viewed

### Parents should stop children gaming on Roblox if they are worried, says CEO
- 2d ago
- 

### Roblox to give parents more control over children’s activity after warnings over grooming
- 18 Nov 2024
- 

### Pushing Buttons: With the safety of Roblox under scrutiny, how worried should parents be?
- 16 Oct 2024
- 

### Ofcom urged to act after US firm claims Roblox is ‘paedophile hellscape’
- 15 Oct 2024
- 

### Pushing Buttons: Why viral voyeurism game Clickolding became a surprise hit
- 24 Jul 2024
- 

### ‘Advergames’: how games platform Roblox became a corporate marketing playground
- 13 Jul 2024
- 

---

## Explore more on these topics

- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 

---

### Most viewed

1. 
2. 
3. 
4. 
5. 

---

### Back to top

© 2025 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. (dcr)
```