# AZ GOP allege plagiarism from expert witness opposing their Save Women's Sports bill | Fox News

## Main Content



### Trans youth advocate accused of plagiarism in testimony opposing Arizona's Save Women's Sports Act

University of Michigan's Dr. Daniel Shumer is also an expert witness against President Trump's executive order on gender

By  

Published March 5, 2025 9:00pm EST

### Video



Fox News Digital spoke to Arizona Senate President Warren Petersen about his experience at Trump’s signing of an executive order keeping males out of female sports.

### 'The impact is huge': Top Arizona lawmaker reflects on Trump’s signing of Trump EO protecting women’s sports

Arizona’s state senate president, , told Fox News Digital in a statement. "The ultimate gaslight is to say that a boy is a girl," Arizona’s state senate president, , told Fox News Digital in a statement. "Now, we have learned that the expert witness did more than gaslight. We have presented the court with multiple examples of identical or virtually identical phrasing used by other academics without any attribution."

Petersen is the  in a case challenging the Save Women's Sports Act in Arizona, which is awaiting a decision from the Supreme Court over whether it will hear an appeal of an early order.

Petersen says that Dr. Daniel Shumer, a clinical associate professor of pediatrics and medical director of the Gender Services Program and fellowship director of Pediatric Endocrinology at the University of Michigan, plagiarized his expert witness testimony at least 22 times in his testimony opposing .



Person holding transgender flag (Adobe Stock)

"Over the past two years, I have led the charge to defend Arizona's commonsense law that protects women in sports," Petersen told Fox News Digital. "Despite the many attacks from the left, I've been grateful for this opportunity to champion the integrity of women's sports - especially in the absence of our state's attorney general. I will continue to lead the fight for this law in the courts, and I am hopeful that the U.S. Supreme Court will eventually allow our state to protect women's sports!"

On Wednesday,  a request, legally called a Daubert motion, to remove Shumer as the opposing expert witness.

The motion reads, "Dr. Shumer’s opinions are not reliable because he plagiarized them, he lacks the qualifications to offer them, and he has presented no objective proof that his opinions represent good science."

The document alleges that Shumer took wording from Stephen Rosenthal, a witness in the case challenging Alabama’s law prohibiting surgeries and hormone therapy for minors, and from Joshua Safer, a witness in the case challenging West Virginia’s Save Women’s Sports Act, and did not give proper attribution.

### US JUDGE HALTS ARIZONA FROM BANNING TRANSGENDER GIRLS IN FEMALE SCHOOL SPORTS TEAMS



Screenshot of plagiarism examples from Motion to Exclude Expert Testimony and Reports of Dr. Daniel Shumer.

The University of Michigan’s guide  as "the appropriation of another person’s ideas, processes, results, or words without giving appropriate credit."

In a Feb. 18, 2025, deposition, Shumer appeared to admit to plagiarism.

"I don't believe that an expert report necessarily constitutes research and \ may or may not be applicable to an expert report. Also, as an expert in this case, I'm not performing duties related to my role in the University of Michigan," Shumer said. "All that being said, I think that it's clear that some of the words I used were used from other sources without appropriate credit and that that meets this definition."

When asked during the deposition, "Why do you think now you should have cited the reports in your expert report?"

Shumer responded, "Because I believe that that's the right thing to do when -- when there's material that -- that was initially written by someone else that you're using to make a similar point."

In the deposition, he said among the services provided at the Child and Adolescent Gender Services Clinic at Mott Children's Hospital, which he is the clinical director of, are "medical interventions, such as GnRH agonists or 19 gender-affirming hormones."

Shumer is also an expert witness in cases against .



Dr. Daniel Shumer and the transgender flag. (Photo: screenshot of Dr. Daniel Shumer's page on the University of Michigan Health website, transgender flag: Mike Kemp/In Pictures via Getty Images).

He has been featured in various social media posts from Stand with Trans, an organization "founded to create a safe and supportive space for transgender youth and their loved ones," plugging various sessions both  and  he was giving as part of Trans Empowerment Month celebrated each October.

In a Sept. 12, 2024 Instagram post, Stand with Trans called Shumer, "a leading pediatric endocrinologist," and said that he would "debunk common myths and walk through the referral process for pediatric gender clinics, offering invaluable information for both youth and parents."

 reached out to Shumer and the University of Michigan for comment, but did not immediately receive a response.



### Related Topics

* 
* 
* 
* 

### Fox News Digital

#### Fox News First

Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox.

Arrives Weekdays

By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News  and , and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.

Subscribe

You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter!

#### Subscribe

You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter!

#### Subscribed
```