Kas mõni sigaret päevas kujutab endast ohtu?
Kui napsu osas on ka arstide seas tavaks toonitada, et vahel harva klaas veini teeb tervisele isegi head, siis kuidas on sigarettidega, kui neid vahel suitsetada või teha paar suitsu päevas?
Vastab Tartu Ülikooli Kliinikumi kopsuarst Ülle Ani:
"Iga sigaret päevas on ohtlik tervisele. Kindlasti võib ka filosofeerida antud teemal: näiteks kui 90aastane inimene hakkab suitsetama, siis temal eeldatavasti ei saa tekkida kopsuvähki. Samas peab teadma, et vähirisk on ainult üks haigus kõikidest võimalikest, mis seonduvad suitsetamisega," selgitas ta.
Arvestada tuleb Ani sõnul alati kõigi riskidega ja kõigi hetkeliste muutustega. "On kindlaks tehtud, et iga sigaret tõstab vererõhku 5…10mmHg võrra. Kui me ravime kõrgvererõhu tõvega patsienti, kes vererõhu ravimitega samadel päevadel ka suitsetab (kasvõi 1...2 sigaretti päevas), siis ta ei saa ravimitest piisavat efekti, ning püsib oht vererõhuhaiguse tüsistustele (k.a aju insult). Näiteid saab tuua palju nii noortele sportlikele inimestele kui ka vanemaealistele krooniliste haigustega inimestele suitsetamisel iga sigareti kahjulikust toimest.".
<|begin_of_text|><|start_header_id|>system<|end_header_id|>

Cutting Knowledge Date: December 2023
Today Date: 26 Jul 2024

<|eot_id|><|start_header_id|>user<|end_header_id|>

Below is an extract from a web page. Evaluate whether the page has a high educational
value and could be useful in an educational setting for teaching from primary school to
grade school levels using the additive 5-point scoring system described below. Points are
accumulated based on the satisfaction of each criterion:
- Add 1 point if the extract provides some basic information relevant to educational top-
ics, even if it includes some irrelevant or non-academic content like advertisements and
promotional material.
- Add another point if the extract addresses certain elements pertinent to education but
does not align closely with educational standards. It might mix educational content with
non-educational material, offering a superficial overview of potentially useful topics, or
presenting information in a disorganized manner and incoherent writing style.
- Award a third point if the extract is appropriate for educational use and introduces key
concepts relevant to school curricula. It is coherent though it may not be comprehensive
or could include some extraneous information. It may resemble an introductory section of
a textbook or a basic tutorial that is suitable for learning but has notable limitations like
treating concepts that are too complex for grade school students.
- Grant a fourth point if the extract highly relevant and beneficial for educational purposes
for a level not higher than grade school, exhibiting a clear and consistent writing style. It
could be similar to a chapter from a textbook or a tutorial, offering substantial educational
content, including exercises and solutions, with minimal irrelevant information, and the
concepts aren’t too advanced for grade school students. The content is coherent, focused,
and valuable for structured learning.
- Bestow a fifth point if the extract is outstanding in its educational value, perfectly suited for
teaching either at primary school or grade school. It follows detailed reasoning, the writing
style is easy to follow and offers profound and thorough insights into the subject matter,
devoid of any non-educational or complex content.
The extract: Kas mõni sigaret päevas kujutab endast ohtu?
Kui napsu osas on ka arstide seas tavaks toonitada, et vahel harva klaas veini teeb tervisele isegi head, siis kuidas on sigarettidega, kui neid vahel suitsetada või teha paar suitsu päevas?
Vastab Tartu Ülikooli Kliinikumi kopsuarst Ülle Ani:
"Iga sigaret päevas on ohtlik tervisele. Kindlasti võib ka filosofeerida antud teemal: näiteks kui 90aastane inimene hakkab suitsetama, siis temal eeldatavasti ei saa tekkida kopsuvähki. Samas peab teadma, et vähirisk on ainult üks haigus kõikidest võimalikest, mis seonduvad suitsetamisega," selgitas ta.
Arvestada tuleb Ani sõnul alati kõigi riskidega ja kõigi hetkeliste muutustega. "On kindlaks tehtud, et iga sigaret tõstab vererõhku 5…10mmHg võrra. Kui me ravime kõrgvererõhu tõvega patsienti, kes vererõhu ravimitega samadel päevadel ka suitsetab (kasvõi 1...2 sigaretti päevas), siis ta ei saa ravimitest piisavat efekti, ning püsib oht vererõhuhaiguse tüsistustele (k.a aju insult). Näiteid saab tuua palju nii noortele sportlikele inimestele kui ka vanemaealistele krooniliste haigustega inimestele suitsetamisel iga sigareti kahjulikust toimest.".
After examining the extract:
- Briefly justify your total score, up to 100 words.
- Conclude with the score using the format: "Educational score: <total points>"<|eot_id|>
<|start_header_id|>assistant<|end_header_id|>

The extract discusses the health risks of smoking, providing basic information and expert insights from a medical professional. Although it's coherent and relevant to health education, the content may not be directly aligned with school curricula and lacks structured learning materials. The language and concepts are suitable for older grade school students, but the topic's complexity and lack of educational organization limit its educational value.

Educational score: 3